Renaissance

What Can a School Owe to Pictures Its Master Did Not Paint?

When critics cut down Giorgione’s list of works, Pater turns to influence. Copies, collaborations and prints show how much could travel under one painter’s name.

The Giorgionesque helps explain how a way of painting spreads, as long as the word leaves room for the artists whose hands carried it further.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Authorship and influencePater uses the Giorgionesque to describe ways of painting that reached beyond Giorgione’s own works.
  • How a manner travelsCopies, collaborations and prints give a style ways to reach artists and viewers who may never have seen the original paintings.
  • A name can take up too much roomCalling Giorgione the embodiment of Venice can obscure what Titian, Sebastiano and others contributed.
  • Evidence gives the term its limitsEarly records and surviving works help distinguish a traceable connection from a likeness a later viewer happens to see.

Pater doesn’t stay in mourning for long, which is to his credit. Right after listing what the critics took away, he says that “in what is connected with a great name, much that is not real is often very stimulating,” and that beyond the real Giorgione and his surviving works “there remains the Giorgionesque also,” which he defines as “an influence, a spirit or type in art, active in men so different as those to whom many of his supposed works are really assignable.” The word just means “in the manner of Giorgione,” and Pater’s bet is that a manner can outlive a catalog. The distinction he’s drawing is between influence and authorship, and it’s what lets his argument survive every change to the list of works.

The case for real influence is strong, and it doesn’t rest on Pater’s imagination. Pater gives Vasari’s account of the painter’s vivacity the name il fuoco Giorgionesco, “the Giorgionesque fire.” Vasari also names the young Titian and Sebastiano as artists who learned from Giorgione. Michiel’s notes record pictures begun by Giorgione and finished by others, and painters such as Palma, Cariani and Catena worked with some of the same effects, as did the engraver Giulio Campagnola. So a school can owe a great deal to pictures its master didn’t paint, because copies, finished drafts and imitations could carry his compositions and effects beyond the workshops in which he worked. Campagnola’s engravings in particular carried Giorgionesque figures and landscapes to people who never saw a Giorgione painting, so the manner literally traveled on paper.

Pater’s list of sources mixes two kinds of debt. The school, he says, “grew together out of all those fascinating works rightly or wrongly attributed to him,” out of copies and variations, out of “the immediate impression he made upon his contemporaries,” and out of “many traditions of subject and treatment, which really descend from him to our own time.” Some of these are real channels of influence, a collaborator’s hand or a copy of a lost picture, and some are channels of reputation, painters a century later imitating what they believed Giorgione had done. Both are historical facts, but they’re different facts, and Pater blends them together. He even says that by retracing those traditions “we fill out the original image,” which admits that the Giorgione we picture is partly assembled from what came after him.

The danger comes at the end of the paragraph. “Giorgione thus becomes a sort of impersonation of Venice itself, its projected reflex or ideal, all that was intense or desirable in it crystallising about the memory of this wonderful young man.” It’s a gorgeous sentence and a risky piece of history, because it lets one name absorb a whole city’s mood, so that inventions by Titian, Sebastiano, Palma or Cariani get credited to a legend. It’s like crediting a whole decade of music to one band that broke up early, which flatters the band and robs everyone who actually made the records.

Pater sees the risk and builds a guard rail. At the close of the essay he calls his account the vraie vérité, French for “the real truth,” meaning the “more liberal and durable impressions” that “lie beyond, and must supplement, the narrower range of the strictly ascertained facts.” The verb matters, because to supplement facts isn’t to replace them, and he goes on to say that the exceptions the critics established, “properly qualified,” are “but a salt of genuineness in our knowledge.” Salt preserves and it also stings, and Pater wants the hard facts kept in the dish even while he praises the flavor of influence. He also says such a figure “enlarges his permanent efficacy and really makes himself felt in our culture” through indirect influence, which is an honest description of how reputations actually work.

That gives a usable test for when the Giorgionesque names something real. It does when there’s a channel you can point to, a documented collaborator, a copy of a known composition, a picture Michiel says was finished by someone else, an engraving that carried a design around Italy. It becomes myth when it rests only on resemblance and longing, so that any dreamy young man with a lute in a soft landscape gets filed under Giorgione because he feels right there. Influence travels through people and objects, and a mood that has no route back to the master is just a mood.

Connoisseurs had reason to be wary of the term. A label like “school of Giorgione” can suggest a closer connection than the surviving evidence supports. But the term survived the clearing, and museums still use it with a straight face, as when the Uffizi describes the Concert as Titian’s work with a clear Giorgionesque atmosphere, which uses the term to describe a recognizable relationship between two painters’ work.

So my verdict is that a school can owe a great deal to pictures its master didn’t paint, as long as we keep “Giorgione” and “the Giorgionesque” carefully apart, which is exactly what Pater’s own line about facts as salt demands. Where he follows that rule, his rescue works and still holds up, since influence really did run through copies, collaborators and finished drafts. Where he lets the name swallow the city, the sentence is splendid and the history isn’t, and the honest way to love that sentence is to read it as a portrait of what Venice wanted from Giorgione rather than of what he gave it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What distinction allows Pater’s argument to survive changes in which paintings are attributed to Giorgione?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.