Philosophy

What Became of Critias and Charmides

The two men Socrates talks with about temperance later held office during the rule of the Thirty. Their careers give the dialogue’s last joke about orders and force a sharper edge.

Xenophon records the deaths of Critias and Charmides on the same battlefield. Their later history changes how the dialogue sounds and leaves its arguments to be judged on their merits.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Plato’s relatives enter the gymCritias introduces Charmides as his cousin. The two men are also related to Plato, whose mother was Charmides’ sister.
  • Critias leads the ThirtyXenophon records Critias’ part in the regime’s killings and in the condemnation of Theramenes. He also records a law against teaching the art of argument.
  • Charmides serves in PiraeusCharmides was among the Ten who governed the harbor. He and Critias both died fighting the democratic exiles at Munychia.
  • The arguments still need a hearingTheir careers give the dialogue’s talk of rule, obedience, and force an added weight. The reasoning about temperance still has to stand or fall on what the speakers say.

Charmides 153c–154b, 171d–172a, 176c–d · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.3.12–19, 2.3.51–56, 2.3.56, 2.4.19 · Xenophon, Memorabilia 1.2.12–24, 1.2.31–33, 3.7 · Xenophon, Symposium 4.29–32 · Athenian Constitution 35 · Aeschines, Against Timarchus 1.173

In the dialogue Critias is a cultivated aristocrat, proud of his learning and fond of fine distinctions, and Charmides is his young cousin and ward, the most admired youth in Athens, already thought a philosopher and a poet. Plato tells us nothing of their futures, and the conversation stands complete without them. Readers who knew what happened to both men had reason to hear something darker in the ending. The edition used here sets out the family facts plainly, Critias as the cousin of Plato’s mother and Charmides as her brother, which makes the dialogue a portrait of the author’s own relatives.

Critias was a poet, prose writer, and political figure. Xenophon says that Socrates’ accuser blamed him for having taught Critias and Alcibiades. Xenophon argues in Socrates’ defense that the two sought him out for his skill in argument and left him once they thought they had what they wanted. He also says that Critias and Charicles made a law against teaching the art of argument, and that they used it to order Socrates to stop speaking with the young.

In 404 BC, after Athens lost the Peloponnesian War, the victorious Spartans backed a narrow oligarchy of thirty men, and Critias quickly became its most powerful and most ruthless member. The Thirty disarmed most citizens, executed opponents and seized the property of wealthy residents, and the Athenian Constitution puts the death toll at no fewer than fifteen hundred. When Theramenes, a fellow member, objected to the killings, Critias had him struck from the list of protected citizens and put to death, and Xenophon tells how Theramenes drank the hemlock and tossed the last drops out with a mock toast to Critias, in mockery of a drinking-game custom. Critias was not the only extremist among the Thirty, but he was the one later Athenians remembered, and his name became shorthand for the regime.

Charmides’ role was smaller but real, since he was one of the Ten appointed to govern the Piraeus, the harbor town of Athens, under the Thirty. Xenophon portrays him in two earlier scenes, once as a capable man who shrank from speaking in the Assembly and whom Socrates urged to take part in public life, and once at a dinner party praising the freedom of poverty, since after losing his property he could sleep easily and was free of the demands placed on wealthy citizens. Neither portrait suggests a natural tyrant, which makes his later career all the more striking.

The end came quickly. Democratic exiles led by Thrasybulus seized a fort on the frontier and then took up a position at Munychia, the hill above the harbor. The Thirty marched against them in 403 BC. Critias died in the fighting, and Xenophon names Charmides son of Glaucon, one of the Ten who ruled in Piraeus, among the dead.

This history gives several moments in the conversation a second meaning. The picture of “us” ruling a city without error, with nobody permitted to act outside his competence, was spoken to a man who would later rule by excluding most citizens from power. The guardian who gives the orders and the ward who promises force at the end became, in fact, an oligarch and his subordinate. And the virtue they spent the afternoon failing to define, the virtue of moderation and self-restraint, is exactly the one their regime most conspicuously lacked.

What the history can’t do is decide the arguments. Critias’ definitions are tested in the dialogue by their own merits, and they fail or survive for reasons that have nothing to do with what he did twenty-five years later. A true claim doesn’t become false because a tyrant once made it, and a bad argument doesn’t become worse because its author later killed people. A reader who dismisses Critias’ ideas because of his career has stopped doing philosophy and started keeping score, which is the very habit the dialogue warns against. Athens itself felt the pull of that habit, since the orator Aeschines told a jury half a century later that the city had put Socrates to death for having educated Critias.

My verdict is that the historical background is indispensable for hearing the Charmides as Plato’s readers heard it, and useless as a substitute for analyzing what its characters say. Critias led the Thirty and Charmides served among the Ten in the Piraeus, and both died at Munychia in 403, and that knowledge gives the dialogue’s talk of rule, obedience and force a weight it couldn’t otherwise have. But the arguments stand on their own, and the best tribute a reader can pay to the history is to let it sharpen the irony while leaving the reasoning to be judged by reason.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the proper role of historical background when reading the Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.