Renaissance

What a Star Rating Leaves Out

Pater asks what kind of pleasure a work gives you and what you notice differently after you leave it.

Two experiences can be equally strong and feel entirely different. Pater’s questions about art make room for that difference, from Botticelli’s peculiar appeal to a painting’s aftereffect on an ordinary walk home.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What kind of pleasure?The Preface begins by asking whether a work pleases, then asks about the kind and degree of pleasure and how the encounter affects the viewer.
  • Two ways for art to pleasePater contrasts the freshness of early Renaissance work with the delicate sweetness of the late French Renaissance. A shared rating could hide what makes each experience distinctive.
  • Botticelli’s peculiar appealThe essay on Botticelli asks what sensation his work produces that viewers cannot find elsewhere. That question lets Pater explain the painter’s appeal even as he calls him secondary.
  • What you notice afterwardThe Conclusion values passions that make consciousness more alert and various. The article uses that test to ask what a picture can change about how we look outside the gallery.

These days every app wants your opinion as a number, one to five stars, thumbs up or down, and often leaves it at that. Pater’s Preface asks the same first questions and then refuses to stop. Facing a song or a picture, his critic asks “Does it give me pleasure? and if so, what sort or degree of pleasure? How is my nature modified by its presence, and under its influence?” A star rating answers the first question and half of the second, and Pater thinks the parts it skips are where criticism actually happens, so it’s worth walking through his questions in order to see what each one adds that the number can’t.

The first question is a gate, and a pretty boring one, since it’s a yes or a no and tells you almost nothing about the thing that pleased you. The second question is where Pater starts to get interesting, because it comes as a pair, “what sort or degree of pleasure,” and the order of that pair matters, since kind comes before amount. Pater could have asked how much the picture pleased and then, if there was time, what kind of pleasure it was, but he puts the sort first. That order invites you to say what a pleasure is before asking how strong it feels.

You can see why intensity alone fails if you think about two experiences that hit equally hard and have nothing else in common. A horror movie and a funeral hymn can both leave you shaking, a heavy metal show and a long walk in the snow can both leave you wiped out and happy, and a scale from one to ten would score them the same while telling you nothing about either one. Pater’s Preface hands you a pair of its own a couple of pages later, when it says the Renaissance’s early phases have “the freshness which belongs to all periods of growth in art,” while its late French aftermath has “that subtle and delicate sweetness which belongs to a refined and comely decadence.” You could rate those two pleasures equally and still need completely different words for them.

In the Botticelli essay, the question about kind takes over. The edition’s note on this question points out that it becomes a working test for the essays that follow, and that in the Botticelli chapter Pater repeats it almost word for word. Look at how it comes back, though, as “What is the peculiar sensation, what is the peculiar quality of pleasure, which his work has the property of exciting in us, and which we cannot get elsewhere?” The word “degree” has dropped out, and in its place you get “peculiar” twice and a pleasure “which we cannot get elsewhere,” so the question about Botticelli is entirely a question about kind. That matters for a painter Pater calls “a secondary painter.” A place in the general ranking tells us little about the experience Botticelli offers.

The third question is the one that a star rating can’t even pretend to answer, because it asks what a pleasure does to you, including what you may carry away. “How is my nature modified” asks whether you leave the picture a slightly different person, noticing something you didn’t notice before, the way a week with Botticelli’s Madonnas might leave you seeing sadness in pretty faces on the bus, or an afternoon with Venetian painting might make you hear the pauses in a conversation. It’s an odd thing to ask of a pleasure, since pleasures are supposed to be over when they’re over, and Pater is saying that the ones worth a critic’s time aren’t over when they end.

He even supplies a standard for that third question, though he holds it back until the last page of the book. In the Conclusion, when he tells you how to know whether a passion is worth having, the test is that it “does yield you this fruit of a quickened, multiplied consciousness.” Read alongside the Preface, that test suggests one change worth looking for. You come out more alive to more things. That turns the third question from a vague invitation to introspect into a real criterion, and it makes the whole sequence point somewhere, from a yes, to a kind, to a change in you that can be judged.

Put the sequence to work on an ordinary visit to a gallery and you can feel the difference. “I liked it, four stars” becomes something like this, that the picture pleased, that the pleasure was cool and wistful rather than warm, that it was quiet but stayed with me, and that on the way home I kept noticing light falling on faces. That’s a review somebody else can argue with, because it makes claims about a kind of pleasure and an aftereffect that another viewer can test, while a star rating is something you can only disagree with. Some people worry that taking pleasure apart like this kills it, but naming a kind forces you to attend longer, and attending longer usually deepens the pleasure rather than spoiling it.

So the order of Pater’s questions is right, and it amounts to a quiet demotion of intensity. Degree still matters to Pater. He asks how thoroughly Wordsworth’s distinctive power enters his verse. The star rating’s weakness is that it gives amount almost the whole job. The ordinary way of talking about art answers the two least interesting questions on his list and skips the two that matter, and the best thing his Preface can do for a casual museumgoer is to make “how much did you like it” feel like the start of the conversation instead of the end of it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article emphasize that Pater asks about the “sort” of pleasure before its “degree”?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.