Renaissance
What a Sentence Can Keep of a Glance
Pater uses a carved smile and a passing expression to teach two ways of looking.
The Renaissance (1893)A sentence about Luca’s shallow relief can send readers back to the marble. In the Conclusion, Pater describes moments that cannot be revisited and gives readers a way to notice the next one.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Two passing impressionsA child’s smile and a hand or face momentarily at its best show how quickly an impression can disappear.
- A sculpture can be revisitedLuca’s shallow marble gives readers a place to look for the expression Pater describes.
- The Conclusion changes the taskA general example of a passing expression trains readers to notice a comparable moment in their own lives.
- Recognition helps teach attentionPater’s examples are familiar enough that readers can bring their own memories to the act of looking.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, a passing smile · Note 117, shallow relief and the direction of light · Conclusion, the moment gone as we apprehend it · Conclusion, some form grows perfect in hand or face · Opera del Duomo, Luca’s Cantoria
Two of Pater’s most memorable phrases describe things that last about a second. In the Luca essay, the whole essence of Tuscan relief is “expression, the passing of a smile over the face of a child, the ripple of the air on a still day over the curtain of a window ajar.” In the Conclusion, “Every moment some form grows perfect in hand or face; some tone on the hills or the sea is choicer than the rest,” and each of these is precious “for that moment only.” Both sentences are about glances, and both raise the same problem, since by the time a critic has finished writing a sentence the smile has long since left the face. Pater knew this better than anyone, because the Conclusion’s whole analysis turns on the way an impression is “gone while we try to apprehend it.”
Look first at the grammar, because it gives the game away. Pater never says which child, which hand, which hill. It’s always “a child,” then “some form,” then “some tone,” a run of indefinite articles that describe a kind of event rather than an event, and that’s a deliberate choice for someone who elsewhere names pictures and places with great precision. A sentence about a particular smile Pater once saw would hand the reader his memory, while a sentence about the passing of a smile over the face of a child hands the reader a category, something to recognize when it happens again. Even the curtain is anonymous, a window ajar in no particular house.
The Luca sentence has an advantage the Conclusion lacks, and it’s that the glance has already been kept by someone else. Pater treats the smile as a possibility of shallow carving. He says its shadows can be “almost invisible except in a strong light.” So the smile in a Tuscan relief is still a passing thing, appearing and fading as the light moves across the stone, but it can be visited again. Pater’s sentence works as a pointer, sending the reader back to an object where the glance is stored, and a reader who goes and looks can check the description against the thing it describes. That’s also why the Luca sentence sets the smile beside an event of the same scale, the ripple of air over a curtain, since the sculptor’s achievement is to make a very slight movement survive in a very hard material.
The Conclusion has no such object behind it, and that changes everything. The perfect hand or face belongs to life, not art, and it’s gone the moment it arrives, so the sentence can’t send anyone back to check. All it can do is train the reader for the next time, and that’s exactly what the surrounding paragraph asks for, since the question that follows is how we may “see in them all that is to be seen in them by the finest senses.” The sentence about the perfect hand isn’t a report, it’s practice, like a coach describing the kind of pitch to watch for without being able to show you the one he saw.
So the two passages divide the work between them. In Luca, language recovers the glance by pointing to a place where an artist has already fixed it, and the reader shares an observation in the ordinary sense, since Luca’s surviving reliefs give readers something to examine for themselves. In the Conclusion, language recovers nothing in particular and instead hands the reader a way of looking, which is less than an observation but in a sense more, because it can be used again on moments Pater never saw. Notice, too, that the Conclusion’s list goes on past bodies to “some mood of passion or insight or intellectual excitement,” moments with no visible form at all, which no sculptor could store and only a trained attention could catch.
There’s a serious objection to the training reading, and it deserves a full hearing. Plenty of readers feel that Pater’s phrases do give them something seen, not just a habit, and the reason is that his examples are so generic that every reader has already met them. Almost everyone has watched a smile cross a child’s face, or seen a curtain lift in a draft, so when Pater names the event the reader supplies a memory of their own. On this view the reader does share an observation, just not Pater’s, and the sentence works like a song that everyone thinks was written about their own summer.
That’s right, and it actually strengthens the case for teaching over transmitting. What the reader shares is recognition, the shock of seeing one’s own unnoticed glance given a name, and recognition is the first step in learning to look. Once you’ve read the curtain sentence, you notice curtains, and once you’ve read “some form grows perfect in hand or face,” you start watching hands. The sentence has changed what you attend to, which is a bigger effect than any description of one particular hand could have had. Pater’s whole book works this way, which is why readers come away from it seeing differently rather than simply knowing more.
A critic’s language, then, can’t keep the glance itself, but it can do two other things, and Pater’s two passages show both. Where an artist has given a passing expression a durable form, the sentence can direct the reader to the kind of detail Pater noticed. When nobody has stored it, as with the passing hand in the Conclusion, the sentence can only teach a way of looking. Pater’s genius is that his examples are ordinary enough for the teaching to arrive disguised as recognition, so the reader learns a habit while believing they’ve simply remembered something.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article emphasize Pater’s use of phrases such as “a child,” “some form,” and “some tone”?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a sentence cannot preserve a fleeting glance itself, in what sense might teaching someone to notice future glances be a form of preservation?→
- How does the ability to revisit Luca’s relief affect the authority of Pater’s description, and what changes when no object is available for comparison?→
- Does the reader’s use of a personal memory make Pater’s language more universal or more subjective? What assumptions underlie your answer?→