Renaissance

What a Ritual Keeps When the Household Forgets

Pater thinks a repeated act can outlive the household practice that once made sense of it. Stories give the surviving act new ways to mean.

An ox is killed and the axe goes on trial. Ancient accounts of the rite help show both the usefulness and the limits of Pater’s distinction between persistent practices and changing stories.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Ordinary acts can lastPater starts from fire, washing and harvest to imagine how household practices could persist in explicitly religious form.
  • A sacrifice in two accountsPausanias describes an axe put on trial after a sacrifice. Aristophanes can use the Bouphonia to get a laugh about old customs.
  • The story has room to movePater distinguishes the repeated act from the myths that can take on new forms around it.
  • An argument about originsWilliam Robertson Smith often explains myths by earlier rites. Pater gives stories an independent part in transforming the practice they meet.

Think about everything a birthday asks of you, the cake, the candles, the song, the wish you aren’t allowed to say out loud and the big breath at the end, and then try to explain why any of it is done that way. Almost nobody can, and almost nobody skips it, which is exactly the kind of fact Pater builds his account of Greek religion on. Underneath the bright Olympian surface, he says, lies a “universal pagan sentiment” that attaches itself “to certain usages of patriarchal life, the kindling of fire, the washing of the body, the slaughter of the flock, the gathering of harvest, holidays and dances.” Those household acts become “the beginnings of a ritual,” and the ritual outlives the household, which is where things get interesting.

Pater describes the process with real precision, and the key sentence is worth reading slowly. The old ways of life change, “but this germ of ritual remains, promoted now with a consciously religious motive, losing its domestic character, and therefore becoming more and more inexplicable with each generation.” The logic in that “therefore” is sharp, because a practice that once made obvious sense at home loses its explanation the moment it moves out, and the more solemnly it’s kept, the stranger it looks. A city hearth or a ceremonial washing can help us picture what Pater means. A familiar act can acquire a new setting and a more formal purpose. His proposal about the origins of any given rite still has to be tested against its own evidence.

The slaughter of the flock produced the strangest survivor of all. At the Athenian sacrifice to Zeus Polieus, Pausanias tells us, the man who killed the ox threw away the axe and fled. The others brought the axe to trial. By the late fifth century this was already a byword for fuddy-duddy antiquity, and in Aristophanes’ Clouds the slick new Argument sneers at the old one as stale stuff straight out of the Bouphonia and the age of golden cicada hairpins. That’s Pater’s “more and more inexplicable” caught in the act, a rite sufficiently familiar to serve as a punchline about old-fashioned practices.

Then comes the move that makes the whole passage work. “Always,” Pater writes, “the fixed element is the religious observance; the fluid, unfixed element is the myth, the religious conception.” Myth, he insists, didn’t come from a religious source at all, and it brought to the ritual “the power of the wing,” his gloss on a phrase from Plato’s Phaedrus, meaning a capacity for ascent and refinement. So practice supplies durability and myth supplies mobility, and while the ritual stays put, “the æsthetic element, only accidentally connected with it, expands with the freedom and mobility of the things of the intellect.” Art, in other words, attaches to the part of religion that can move.

Pater’s split looks remarkably prescient when you set it beside later scholarship. In his Lectures on the Religion of the Semites, first published in 1889, William Robertson Smith also distinguishes fixed rites from variable myths. He argues that a myth which explains a rite is generally derived from that rite. Pater allows myth to come to ritual from somewhere else. It’s an independent force that lands on the ritual from outside and lifts it, which is why he can treat Greek religion as a two-story building with a damp cellar and a sunlit upper floor.

He’s honest about the cellar, too, and that honesty is what keeps the passage from being a Victorian postcard of Greece. Greek religion had “its mendicants, its purifications,” its “statues worn with kissing,” its addolorata, its Lady of Sorrows, and its “mournful mysteries,” so that hardly a gloomy note of the medieval church went unanticipated. Pater even borrows a story from Athenaeus to show how far the old cult images were from classical beauty, and in Athenaeus’s account it concerns a man named Parmeniscus, who lost the ability to laugh after visiting a famous underground oracle, and the Delphic priestess told him his mother at home would give it back. Nothing worked until he walked into Leto’s temple on Delos expecting a grand statue of Apollo’s mother, saw a shapeless lump of wood, and burst out laughing, cured by the mother after all.

Still, the fixed-versus-fluid line is cleaner than the evidence. Rituals do change, slowly, picking up new steps, new officials and new explanations, and different accounts of the Bouphonia preserve different details of the trial. Myths can also harden into something close to scripture once poets like Homer and Hesiod fix them. So the difference Pater describes is really one of speed rather than kind, with practice changing at the pace of habit and story changing at the pace of imagination.

My verdict is that Pater’s distinction earns its place even with that correction, because it explains something real about how Greek religion could become an artistic ideal. The rites kept their dark, half-understood persistence, and the gap that opened as they became “inexplicable” was exactly the space where myth, and after it sculpture and poetry, could move in and do their work. Pater imagines an act surviving the immediate explanation it had in the household, and Pater’s point is that a culture willing to fill that gap with beautiful stories ends up with an art, while the ritual underneath goes on as stubborn as a birthday candle.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does a practice become increasingly inexplicable, according to the article’s reading of Pater?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.