Greek Antiquity

What a Broken Fast Can Tell Us About a Rite

The Mother’s fast at Eleusis points toward an initiatory practice whose details need other witnesses.

The hymn places a broken fast just before the Mother’s descent to Hades. The article tests how far a few lines of myth can take us toward the practice of the mysteries.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Three lines hold the journeyAntaia searches in grief, breaks her fast at Eleusis, and goes down to Phersephoneia in Hades.
  • Other witnesses describe the drinkThe essay compares Clement and Ovid, whose accounts connect the initiates’ practice with the goddess ending her fast.
  • The named festival fast has its own settingThe edition places the day called the Fast at the Thesmophoria, a different festival of Demeter.
  • The descent belongs to the storyThe hymn gives the Mother a journey to Hades, while evidence for what initiates did must come from outside those lines.

Orphic Hymns, XLI.1–5, with the apparatus and the notes on the title and on XLI.4

The hymn to the Mother Antaia tells part of a familiar story in three lines. She is the goddess “who once, searching in far-wandering grief, / broke your fast in the glens of Eleusis / and went to Hades, to noble Phersephoneia.” The edition’s note on the title explains that Antaia is a cult title of the Mother, the fourth heading under which the collection has addressed her, and the story fits Demeter, who searched the world for her daughter. The note on line 4 adds that the hymn “names Eleusis at 4 and Hades at 5 with no narrative between them.”

The note also shows why the broken fast invites a ritual reading. The fast, it says, “is both a stage of the story,” told in the Homeric hymn to Demeter, where the grieving goddess refuses food and drink until she accepts a drink of barley and water called the kykeon at Eleusis, “and a stage of the rite.” In the Homeric hymn the goddess refuses red wine and asks instead for barley and water mixed with fresh pennyroyal, and she is coaxed into smiling first by the jokes of a servant woman named Iambe. Clement of Alexandria quotes the password of the Eleusinian initiates, which began, “I fasted, I drank the kykeon.” So a reader who knows both texts can connect the goddess breaking her fast in the hymn with the initiates breaking theirs in the sanctuary.

That connection has independent support, which is what makes it responsible. Clement was a hostile witness, a Christian writing against the mysteries, but his formula is precise, and it agrees with a Roman poet who had no reason to share his agenda. Ovid, in the Fasti, says that because the goddess first broke her fast at nightfall, the initiates take their food when the stars appear. Two independent writers, one Greek and Christian, one Latin and pagan, describe the same practice and tie it to the same story, so the hymn’s broken fast can fairly be heard as an echo of something initiates actually did.

But the note adds a warning that keeps the reading honest. The fast “is not a named day of the Eleusinian celebration,” it says, since the day called the Fast, the Nēsteia, belongs to the Thesmophoria, a different festival of Demeter celebrated by women, “and the two festivals are often conflated.” A reader who hears the word fast and imagines an Eleusinian fast day is importing a detail from another rite. Plutarch describes the Athenian women keeping the fast of the Thesmophoria sitting on the ground, which is a vivid picture of a ritual fast, but it belongs to that festival and not to the mysteries at Eleusis. The hymn permits a connection between the goddess’s fast and the initiates’ fasting, but not a reconstruction of the festival’s calendar.

The descent to Hades raises a sharper problem for anyone hoping to read ritual out of the hymn. In the Homeric hymn, Demeter never goes to the underworld, since Zeus sends Hermes to bring Persephone back. This hymn says that the Mother herself “went to Hades,” guided, as the next line says, by the child of Dysaules, which belongs to a different, Orphic version of the story that Clement also reports, with Dysaules and Baubo receiving the goddess at Eleusis, and Baubo, in Clement’s report of the Orphic verses, making the grieving goddess laugh and drink the kykeon. So the descent is part of the hymn’s own myth, not evidence that initiates enacted a journey to the underworld, however tempting it is to imagine one in the darkness of the sanctuary.

What could the hymn tell us, and what would need other testimony? It tells us that its singers knew a story in which the grieving Mother ended her fast at Eleusis and then went down to her daughter, and that this story mattered enough to sing in a short prayer. Whether the initiates fasted, what they drank and when they ate are questions answered by Clement and Ovid, not by the hymn. Whether the search itself was acted out needs testimony like Clement’s other remark that Eleusis celebrates with torches the wandering, the abduction and the grief of the two goddesses. Each step from story to rite needs its own witness. Archaeology can show where the initiates gathered, in the great hall of the sanctuary at Eleusis, but even the excavated building can’t say what was shown inside it.

Christian practice offers an instructive comparison, close to home for anyone who keeps Lent. Someone who read only the gospel story of Jesus fasting forty days in the wilderness couldn’t reconstruct the rules of Lent, that it begins on Ash Wednesday, that its Sundays are not counted as fast days, or how a parish keeps it. You would need the Prayer Book, the calendar and the memories of people who keep the season. The story explains why Christians fast, but the rite itself lives in other documents, and a hymn that alludes to a story is in the same position.

My verdict is that the hymn permits readers to connect its broken fast with the initiates’ fasting and their drink of kykeon, because Clement and Ovid independently describe that practice and tie it to the same story, but that it allows no more than that. The note rightly warns against importing the Thesmophoria’s fast day, and the descent to Hades is the hymn’s own Orphic myth rather than evidence for a ritual underworld journey. A broken fast in three lines can point toward a rite, but recovering the rite takes witnesses outside the hymn.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider the connection between the hymn’s broken fast and Eleusinian initiates’ practice responsible rather than merely speculative?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.