Philosophy

Undressing a Soul

Socrates proposes to examine Charmides’ soul before looking at his body. A glimpse inside the boy’s cloak shows how difficult Diotima’s account of educating through love is to live out.

Diotima describes attraction growing into an education in virtue. The wrestling school gives the process an audience, an embarrassed teacher, and an uncertain result.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A change in what to look atSocrates borrows the gym’s language of undressing to ask what Charmides’ soul is like.
  • Diotima’s educational turnDiotima describes love prompting someone to speak about virtue and try to educate the beloved.
  • The teacher loses his footingA look inside Charmides’ cloak knocks the boldness out of Socrates. He has to recover before his proposed examination can begin.
  • An education still to comeCharmides wants to return for more conversation, and Critias orders him to do so. The dialogue leaves the proposed education unfinished.

The Charmides begins with a crowd going wild over a beautiful teenager. Chaerephon says that if the boy were willing to strip, “you’d think he had no face at all, his figure is so perfectly beautiful,” and Socrates replies that he would be invincible “if he has just one little thing more,” a well-made soul. Then he makes a proposal, “Then why don’t we strip that very part of him,” he says, “and take a look at it before we look at his figure?” The language of the gym, where young men undressed to exercise, is turned on the soul, and a scene about looking at bodies becomes, at least in intention, a scene about examining character. The same verb describes stripping the body and, a moment later, exposing the soul. The joke turns a gym habit into a philosophical proposal.

In the Symposium, Diotima describes how this kind of turn is supposed to happen. A person who is pregnant in soul, she says, goes looking for something beautiful in which to give birth, and if he finds a beautiful soul in a beautiful body, he is delighted with the combination, and at once he is full of speeches about virtue, about what a good man should be and what he should practice, and he tries to educate the person he loves. What they produce together, the conversations and understanding they share, is a kind of offspring, more lasting than children of the body. Diotima goes on to describe an ascent from one beautiful body to the beauty of bodies and souls, then of practices, laws and knowledge, and finally to beauty itself.

Socrates in the Charmides follows that pattern quite closely. Faced with a boy of extraordinary beauty and a reputation for temperance, he turns the encounter almost at once into a conversation about what temperance is and whether the boy has it. That is exactly the move Diotima describes, interest in a beautiful person becoming talk about virtue, and Socrates even frames his charm as “beautiful words,” the right kind of conversation, which is the medium Diotima says such love works in.

Diotima also names some of the most admired offspring of this kind of love, and one name lands with special force here. Alongside the poems of Homer and Hesiod, she mentions the laws that Lycurgus left in Sparta and the laws of Solon in Athens, children of the soul, she says, that have won their fathers greater honor than any children of the body. Charmides’ family boasted of its kinship with Solon, and Socrates flatters Critias that the family’s gift for philosophy and poetry came “from your kinship with Solon.” By Diotima’s standard, the family’s finest inheritance was not its famous beauty but the kind of offspring Solon produced, which can only be passed on through education. The uncle Socrates praises as the handsomest man on the continent is a reminder of what the family more usually took pride in.

Yet the encounter resists any smooth account of philosophical ascent, and Plato seems to enjoy showing how. The first problem is that Socrates’ own composure collapses. When the boy sits beside him and gives him “a look beyond words,” Socrates says, “I saw inside his cloak, and I was on fire, and was no longer in my own possession.” Diotima describes the passage from bodies to souls in an orderly sequence, while Socrates, the very man who in the Symposium tells Diotima’s story, gets bowled over by a glimpse, and has to gather his boldness again before he can speak. He even borrows a line from the poet Cydias, warning the fawn not to come into the lion’s presence, to describe what has happened to him, an image that makes the encounter sound more like a capture than an ascent.

The second problem is the setting, since Diotima’s account centers on what lover and beloved produce together. In Plato’s other scene, Socrates meets Charmides in a crowded wrestling school, with the boy’s guardian beside him and a ring of admirers pressing in. The conversation is a public performance as much as an education, and the guardian keeps taking it over. The Charmides ends without a definition of the virtue it set out to examine. The future conversations are arranged by command, and any lasting result is still ahead of them.

Even so, something real happens in the wrestling school, because Socrates does manage to turn the encounter from the body to the soul, and Charmides, by the end, is eager to keep being examined, which is at least the beginning of the relationship Diotima describes. The awkwardness doesn’t cancel the ascent so much as show what it costs and how fragile it is, since the first step, from desire for a beautiful body to concern for a beautiful soul, is the hardest, and the Charmides shows a master of that step stumbling on it and getting up again.

Read beside the Symposium, the scene at the wrestling school shows moments Diotima’s account leaves out. The lover fumbles, the crowd leans in, and another person takes over. Socrates has still managed to get a conversation about virtue started. When Charmides asks to come back, it’s possible to see the beginning of the education Diotima describes, and how much could happen before anything comes of it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the main philosophical effect of Socrates’ proposal to “strip” Charmides’ soul before examining his figure?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.