Philosophy

Two Ways of Not Resisting

Socrates gives in when Charmides insists on more lessons. Ordered by the Thirty to help bring in Leon of Salamis, he goes home. The difference is in what each demand asks of him.

A playful surrender in the Charmides and a dangerous refusal in the Apology show Socrates judging the action someone wants him to take.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Charmides wants more lessonsSocrates plays along when Charmides threatens to use force. The young man has asked to keep coming back for the charm.
  • The Thirty order an arrestSocrates says the Thirty ordered five men to bring in Leon for execution. Four went to Salamis, and Socrates went home.
  • The speaker judges the demandThe two scenes give Socrates different reasons to yield or refuse. In each, the action being asked of him matters more than who gives the order.
  • The comedy gains a shadowCritias’ later role among the Thirty gives the joke an edge. The Apology shows where Socrates draws a line when force is used in earnest.

Charmides 176c–d · Apology 32c–d, 32d–e · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.3.15, 2.4.19

The last lines of the Charmides are a comic surrender. Charmides says he will use force, “since this man here gives the orders,” and Socrates replies, “There’s no counsel left,” since when Charmides sets about anything and uses force, “no man alive will be able to oppose you.” Charmides says, “Then don’t you oppose me either,” and Socrates answers, “Then I won’t oppose you,” and the dialogue ends. It’s affectionate and funny, a teacher pretending to be overpowered by a pupil who wants more lessons. Socrates can sound as if he enjoys being overpowered.

In the Apology, Socrates tells a story about force that isn’t funny at all. Under the oligarchy, he says, the Thirty summoned him and four others to the Tholos, the round building used by the presiding councillors, and ordered them to bring Leon of Salamis to be put to death, one of many such orders by which the regime tried to implicate as many people as possible in its crimes. Socrates says he showed, by deeds and not words, that he didn’t care about death at all, but cared above everything not to do anything unjust or impious. The other four went to Salamis and brought Leon back, and Socrates went home, adding that he might have been executed for it if the regime hadn’t soon fallen. Socrates presents the order as an attempt to make the five men share responsibility for an injustice.

The two stories share a vocabulary of orders, compliance, and resistance. Critias is the guardian who gives the order in the wrestling school and will go on to lead the Thirty. In the Apology, Socrates says the order to bring in Leon came from the Thirty collectively. The difference in scale is part of what makes the pairing telling.

Placing them side by side reveals what the comic surrender quietly assumed. Socrates can say “I won’t oppose you” in the wrestling school because what he’s being forced into is good, spending more time examining a promising young man, which is what he would have chosen anyway. His non-resistance depends on the content of the demand. When the demand is to do something unjust, as in the Apology, the same man who yielded so gracefully becomes completely immovable, and the limit his joke left unstated turns out to be absolute. Seen this way, the joke was never a promise of unconditional compliance, only a happy agreement with a demand he already wanted to meet.

The comparison also shows how different kinds of force deserve different responses. Friendly force, the kind friends use when they drag you to a party, is a form of affection and can be met with laughter. Political force, the kind a regime uses when it orders citizens to commit crimes, is a demand for complicity and has to be met with refusal. Socrates handles both correctly, and the difference in his response isn’t inconsistency but discernment, the ability to tell what is really being asked of him. In both scenes he goes along with a demand, or refuses it, because of what the demand is, never simply because someone with power has made it.

There’s an irony in the vocabulary that a reader can feel without overreading. In the Charmides, Socrates declares that “no man alive” can oppose Charmides when he uses force, and in the Apology he shows that one man can, and does, when the force is put to an unjust use. The playful claim of helplessness is refuted, years later, by the same speaker’s conduct, and his refusal didn’t require any special power, only a willingness to walk home instead of to Salamis. Four men went to Salamis that day, and the fifth showed that the regime’s force, however great, depended on people agreeing to carry it out.

What changes, then, when the comic language is placed next to the serious claim? The comedy gains a shadow, since we see that the people who play at force in the wrestling school will later use it in earnest. But the serious claim gains something too, since we see that Socrates’ refusal to arrest Leon wasn’t the act of a man who resisted everything on principle. He was a man who could yield with good humor when yielding was harmless, which makes his refusal, when it came, a judgment rather than a reflex. Together the scenes rule out the lazy picture of Socrates as either a perpetual rebel or a perpetual conformist.

In the wrestling school, Socrates lets himself be talked into something he has reason to welcome. In the Apology, he walks away from an order he judges unjust and accepts the danger that follows. Read together, the two passages give the friendly surrender a condition we can hear even after the dialogue stops. He’ll go along as long as he can answer for what he’s being asked to do.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what principle best explains why Socrates yields in the wrestling school but refuses the Thirty's order?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.