Renaissance
Two Parisians Caught in a Cobweb
Pater turns to Browning for a missed proposal that poetry can keep turning over. The woman telling the story also makes a case against being perfectly complete.
The Renaissance (1893)A woman reconstructs another person’s thoughts about an encounter ten years earlier. Browning’s layers of memory explain why Pater chooses the poem and why its argument unsettles his ideal of Greek repose.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A walk remembered ten years laterThe speaker returns to a visit to a church and a proposal that, as she understands it, the man never quite made.
- The story passes through her mindThe reader hears the man’s thoughts as the woman reconstructs them, including what she thinks he expected her to feel years later.
- What a situation gives the poemPater takes the surrounding allusions and reversals as an example of what poetry can do with an otherwise ordinary pair of people.
- A starfish and a human lifeThe woman uses the completeness of a starfish to make room for a different kind of ambition in a person who is still unfinished.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, pp. 138–139, Browning’s two Parisians · Winckelmann, note 312 · Winckelmann, pp. 139–140, what the poem can do with a situation
Pater needs an example of modern art at its most intricate, and he picks a poem from Robert Browning’s Dramatis Personae (1864) with the double title “Dîs Aliter Visum; or, Le Byron de nos Jours,” which means “the gods saw it otherwise; or, the Byron of our day.” “Those two jaded Parisians are not intrinsically interesting,” Pater says, and “they begin to interest us only when thrown into a choice situation.” Then he describes how Browning makes them interesting, with “a cobweb of allusions,” with “double and treble reflexions of the mind upon itself,” and with “an artificial light” built and broken over the scene, so that you see “on how fine a needle’s point that little world of passion is balanced.” The poem is worth actually reading, because it does everything Pater says and something more that he doesn’t mention.
The situation is a reunion with a grudge in it. A woman meets a famous older man again after ten years and demands, from the first line, “STOP, let me have the truth of that!” Ten years earlier, at a seaside resort, the two of them walked arm in arm up a cliff road above a blazing sea, went into a lonely church “With spire and sad slate roof, aloof,” and came out again, and on that walk, as she recalls it, he came close to asking her to marry him. The poem gives us the cliff, the bathing beach and the church without naming the resort. Now she reconstructs the reasoning she believes went through his head that day, and the whole middle of the poem is her version of his thoughts.
That’s where Pater’s “double and treble reflexions” come from, and they’re literally there in the structure. She imagines him thinking about her, then imagines him imagining her future thoughts, picturing how she’d later compare his fame with other men’s and decide that boys grow old too, so that we’re reading a woman’s memory of a man’s forecast of her own regret. He’s a celebrity of the Paris art world in her account, lame, wigged and expecting a seat in the Academy, and he weighs her youth and fresh cheeks against his learning and ends up deciding the whole affair would be “all for a nosegay,” a lot of fuss over a bunch of flowers.
The cobweb of allusions is real too, and much of it is still easy to see. His imagined reasoning name-checks the culture of the moment, “Schumann’s our music-maker now,” “Ingres’s the modern man that paints,” and “Heine for songs; for kisses, how?” The Latin title comes from Virgil’s Aeneid, where it’s said of Rhipeus, the most just of the Trojans, who died in the fall of Troy anyway, and the French subtitle mocks him, since he’s a “Byron” whose reputation and limp make the comparison possible while his careful reasoning makes it funny. The last stanza drops into society gossip about a dancer named Stephanie whose “vogue has had its day,” and then the speaker ends with “Here comes my husband from his whist.”
Pater puts the weight on the situation. A cautious celebrity and a woman who married someone else are not tragic heroes, and the poem makes them matter by catching them at the precise point where a whole life turned on a few minutes in a church, and by surrounding that point with mirrors. Sculpture can’t do this, Pater argues, because it “cannot command” the “remote associations and suggestions” of language and must therefore choose “the type, the general character,” leaving the “special situation” to poetry and painting.
What Pater doesn’t mention is the argument the poem makes in its closing stretch, and it cuts across the ideal of finished form Pater is considering. The woman tells the man that his prudence cheated them both, and she makes the point with a starfish, “Let the mere star-fish in his vault / Crawl in a wash of weed, indeed, / Rose-jacynth to the finger-tips,” which, “whole in body and soul, outstrips / Man, found with either in default.” The starfish is complete, and that’s exactly its limitation, since a thing that’s already whole can’t grow, while a human being reaching past what he can finish is aiming at a kind of eternity. She asks whether there was “No feat which, done, would make time break / And let us pent-up creatures through / Into eternity, our due?”
That’s a modern, Christian, Browningesque case for incompleteness, and it sits strangely beside Pater’s praise of Greek sculpture as an art of finished types in repose. The poem Pater chose to illustrate what modern art can do happens to argue that completeness is the starfish’s virtue, beautiful and limited, and that human greatness lies in failing upward. It’s the same contrast he draws between the Venus of Melos and Angelico’s fresco, now played out in the way a woman remembers a missed chance.
My verdict is that Pater’s example works even better than he claims. It shows ordinary figures made aesthetic by situation, and it shows “the clear ring of a central motive” emerging from all that intricacy, since every allusion and reflection serves the single idea of a moment missed. It also shows that the poetic resources Pater credits to modern art come with a modern philosophy attached, one that values the unfinished over the perfect, and by choosing it Pater lets the opposing case into his chapter on Greek perfection, and gives the reader a way to ask what the two kinds of art value differently.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article describe the poem’s structure as involving “double and treble reflexions” of the mind?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the two Parisians become interesting only through their situation, what does that suggest about the relationship between character and circumstance in art?→
- Does the woman’s reconstruction of the man’s thoughts make her account more persuasive or less reliable? What features of the poem’s layered structure shape your judgment?→
- Can the poem’s ideal of unfinished human striving be reconciled with Pater’s admiration for the repose and completeness of Greek sculpture, or must the two ideals remain opposed?→