Renaissance

Two Little Cups That Keep You Watching

The jeweled baptismal cups in Amis and Amile help Pater explain how a recurring object holds a reader’s attention.

The cups bring two friends together, while Othello’s handkerchief gives him a false conviction. Pater puts the objects side by side to ask why a thing that fits in the hand can feel as consequential as fate.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A second likenessThe pope gives the two friends matching cups at baptism. Pater sees the cups as a second visible reflection of the likeness that already joins their faces.
  • A detail that holds the eyePater says the recurring cups keep sensation awake and lend refinement to the scenes they enter. Their beauty makes them worth noticing even before the plot turns on them.
  • A handkerchief that misleadsIago uses Othello’s handkerchief to make an innocent person look guilty. Pater’s comparison brings out how a small object can direct belief in either story.
  • The gift becomes a clueThe cup starts as a baptismal gift and becomes evidence at the gate. It gives a servant something to compare and Amile something to ask about.

The cups are a lovely detail, and Pater lingers on them. They are “two marvellously beautiful cups, also exactly like each other,” he writes, “children’s cups, of wood, but adorned with gold and precious stones,” given to the two boys by the pope when he baptized them in Rome. Plain wood dressed in gold and gems is already a nice paradox, humble material made precious, and the fact that there are two of them, matching exactly, makes the cups a little copy of the friendship itself. Pater calls them “a second reflexion” of the friends’ inner likeness, after the likeness of their faces, so the story doubles its doubles. The wood and the jewels belong together in Pater’s description. They make the cups at once small enough for children and rich enough to be remembered as the pope’s gifts.

What he says about how the cups work is the interesting part. They “cross and recross very strangely in the narrative, serving the two heroes almost like living things, and with that well-known effect of a beautiful object, kept constantly before the eye in a story or poem, of keeping sensation well awake, and giving a certain air of refinement to all the scenes into which it enters.” Pater has already said the cups bring the friends together. Now he asks what they do to the reader. They keep the senses alert and lend a touch of elegance to every scene they enter.

That’s an aesthete’s theory of the plot device, and it’s different from the one most writing teachers give. The usual rule is that an object introduced in a story has to pay off later, the gun on the wall in the first act that must go off by the third. Pater cares about that too, but he thinks a beautiful object earns its place before it pays off, simply by giving the eye something to rest on and the mind something to remember. It’s the way a film keeps cutting back to a particular necklace or a song on the radio, so that the object becomes a thread of pleasure running through the whole thing even before it matters to the plot.

Then he adds the second effect, which is fate. “That sense of fate, which hangs so much of the shaping of human life on trivial objects, like Othello’s strawberry handkerchief, is thereby heightened.” Shakespeare’s handkerchief, spotted with strawberries, is a small love token that Iago turns into false evidence of Desdemona’s guilt. A small object repeated across scenes starts to feel like destiny, as if the whole story had been waiting for it, and Pater thinks the cups give the French tale the same feeling of necessity even though it’s much looser and simpler than Othello.

The edition’s note points out a neat reversal hidden in the comparison. The handkerchief is an instrument of false recognition, making Othello see a betrayal that never happened, while the cups are instruments of true recognition, helping the friends find each other when their faces no longer match. Both objects carry stories about their origins. Othello tells Desdemona that a sibyl stitched the handkerchief and that its fabric has magic in it. The pope gives the cups when he baptizes the boys. So the two objects are cousins, small things carrying a charge from their beginnings that makes them feel stronger than their size. One is used to tell a lie and the other to uncover a truth, and Pater’s comparison quietly sets the two uses side by side.

The cups also do several different kinds of work, which is part of what makes them feel alive. At the baptism they’re a gift and a ritual sign, binding the two boys together before they can even talk. In the middle of the story they keep the friends linked and, as Pater says, “help to bring the friends together at critical moments.” And in the famous scene at Amile’s gate, one cup becomes a piece of evidence, the thing a servant notices and the clue that prompts Amile to ask who the visitor is. The cups change jobs as the story goes on, from gift to link to evidence, and yet because they’re always there and always beautiful, they feel like one continuous thread.

Pater finishes with a remark that tells you about him as much as about the tale. The cups, he says, bear witness “to the enjoyment of beautiful handiwork by a primitive people, their simple wonder at it, so that they give it an oddly significant place among the factors of a human history.” You can wince a little at “primitive people,” a Victorian condescension toward the medieval audience. The point underneath is generous. Pater takes the place of these well-made things in the tale as evidence of delight in beautiful work, the kind of delight his whole book asks us to notice.

So how can a repeated object produce both pleasure and a feeling of necessity, even when the plot keeps changing its job? Pater finds pleasure in beauty kept before the eye. Repetition also prepares the cups to feel like part of the friends’ fate when the plot needs them. I think he’s right, and his account is a little ahead of its time, closer to a modern critic talking about motifs than to a Victorian talking about plots. The cups don’t need a consistent function to work, because they already have a consistent effect on the reader, and that effect is what Pater was reading for all along.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does Pater’s view of a recurring object differ from the usual rule that such an object must eventually advance the plot?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.