Renaissance

Too Little Story, Too Much Story

Biographical corrections unsettle Pater’s Botticelli and Leonardo in different ways.

Pater fills the gaps in Botticelli’s biography with a mood, while he makes Leonardo’s paintings the starting point after historians challenge the anecdotes. The contrast shows how much interpretive weight a single story can carry.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Two uneven biographiesPater opens with few events for Botticelli and an abundance of disputed anecdotes for Leonardo.
  • A date becomes a moodBotticelli’s later death date helps Pater imagine years of dejection that the surviving chronology does not establish.
  • A painting changes handsThe Palmieri painting that helped shape Pater’s reading of Botticelli is now attributed to Francesco Botticini.
  • Leonardo’s legend becomes supporting evidencePater asks what the paintings make him see before bringing in the corrected stories about their maker.

Set the two openings side by side and they look like opposite problems. Botticelli’s life, Pater says, “is almost colourless” in “an age when the lives of artists were full of adventure,” and “in Botticelli’s case there is no legend to dissipate,” since “Only two things happened to him,” the summons to paint in the Sistine Chapel and what Pater takes to be Botticelli’s adherence to Savonarola. Leonardo’s legend, by contrast, “with the anecdotes which every one remembers, is one of the most brilliant chapters of Vasari,” until in 1804 a critic “applied to it a criticism which left hardly a date fixed, and not one of those anecdotes untouched.” One essay is starving for story and the other has been force-fed and then put on a diet. Pater even notes at the start that Leonardo’s treatise on painting names Botticelli, so the two painters meet on the first page of one essay, the quiet man mentioned by the famous one.

Botticelli’s problem is that scarcity invites a mood to fill the gap. With little to go on, Pater starts from Vasari’s late chronology and imagines years of inactive melancholy, and then admits that “one almost wishes that some document might come to light, which, fixing the date of his death earlier, might relieve one, in thinking of him, of his dejected old age.” The note reports that the date now accepted is 1510, five years earlier, so in a sense the wish came true. But the episode shows how a thin biography magnifies every error, since a single wrong number had produced a whole emotional chapter, an old age of dejection that may never have happened. It’s the biographer’s version of a rumor in a small town, where one false detail can define a person for years because there’s nothing else around to contradict it.

Scarcity also tempts the critic to take whatever story is on offer. Pater says there’s no legend to dissipate, and then, a page later, he reaches for the one tale he has, a picture with the donor Matteo Palmieri that was supposedly suspected of heresy, and uses it to interpret the melancholy of Botticelli’s figures. “True or false,” he writes, “the story interprets much” of that sentiment. In a life with only two events, one doubtful anecdote becomes a key, and the note now records that the picture itself belongs to another painter, which shows how much weight a single story was carrying.

Leonardo’s problem runs the other way, since there’s more charming material than anyone can trust, and Pater’s response is a method. The historical questions, he says, have become “subjects of special study,” but “a lover of strange souls may still analyse for himself the impression made on him by those works,” and the legend, “as corrected and enlarged by its critics, may now and then intervene to support the results of this analysis.” The anecdotes are demoted from foundation to witness, which is a real change of status. The paintings come first, and the stories are allowed in only when they agree with what the paintings already show. He also separates his job from the specialists’ in so many words, leaving to others the editing of the manuscripts and the sorting of what in the reputed works is really Leonardo’s, which is a clear division of labor between the historian and the critic.

And yet, right after that statement of method, Pater tells the anecdotes anyway. “We see him in his boyhood fascinating all men by his beauty, improvising music and songs, buying the caged birds and setting them free,” he writes, fond “of odd bright dresses and spirited horses.” Those are exactly the stories the critics had touched. Pater keeps them for their color, the way a filmmaker keeps a disputed but vivid scene in a biopic, and his method lets him do it honestly, since nothing in his analysis depends on whether the young Leonardo ever really bought a single bird.

That’s why correction does less damage to the Leonardo essay than you might expect. Because Pater has made the impression primary, many of the anecdotes can fall without taking the argument with them, the way you can remove a decorative column without bringing down the building. The Botticelli essay is paradoxically more exposed, even though it has less story, because the little story it has carries more weight. A wrong death date shaped the old age, and a reassigned picture shaped the melancholy, so every correction in that essay touches the interpretation directly.

Both essays, in the end, make the paintings the main evidence, but for opposite reasons. In Botticelli, Pater finds “an under-current of original sentiment, which touches you as the real matter of the picture through the veil of its ostensible subject,” so the pictures supply the inner life that the biography lacks, and the colorless life becomes the occasion for reading feeling directly from the work. In Leonardo, the pictures come first because the biography can’t be trusted, so the work has to check the stories rather than fill their place. The Botticelli essay never states this method as plainly, and its lapses into story are correspondingly harder to spot. Scarcity and surplus both lead back to the same place, which is the picture in front of you.

Vasari, then, offers the quiet life a few facts that carry too much weight and the brilliant legend a store of images that carry too little. Vasari’s real gift to both essays may be tone rather than fact, a way of imagining a life that a critic can keep even after the facts have been corrected. Correction is gentle with the Leonardo essay because Pater had already put the paintings in charge, and harsher with the Botticelli essay because a sparse life turns every error into an interpretation. In both, though, Pater leaves wide room for reading the paintings, and that’s the right lesson to take from his practice, since the most reliable biography of a painter is usually the one his pictures tell.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why do Botticelli’s and Leonardo’s paintings become the primary evidence in Pater’s essays for different reasons?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.