Greek Antiquity
Time Without the Word
Kronos consumes and renews the world as time does, and the hymn lets the likeness emerge through what he does.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThe hymn makes the Titan who swallowed his children into a god who consumes and increases all things. A familiar ancient likeness between Kronos and Chronos helps make sense of the cycle.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The myth expands to the whole worldKronos consumes all things and increases them again, turning the old story of swallowing his children into a recurring process.
- The hymn names the ageThe phrase all-begetter of the age brings a word for a lifetime or span into the god’s praise.
- The Titan remains a member of a familyKronos is the child of Gaia and Ouranos and the husband of Rhea as he carries out the work of time.
- The prayer brings the cycle homeThe last line asks for a blessed and blameless end of life.
Orphic Hymns, XIII.1–10, with the apparatus and the notes on XIII.3, 5 and XIII.10; XII.3
Everybody who knows one story about Kronos knows the worst one. In Hesiod he swallows his children as they’re born, afraid that one of them will overthrow him, until Rhea hands him a stone wrapped in baby clothes instead of Zeus and he’s later made to cough the whole family back up. The hymn to Kronos remembers that story and changes it in a single line, “you who consume all things and yourself increase them again.” The victims are no longer five divine babies but all things, the eating is no longer a single grim episode but something he does continually, and the regurgitation has turned into growth, so that the god who once gulped his children down now consumes the world and makes it flourish again in an endless round.
That one line is a small masterpiece of reinterpretation, because it takes a family horror story and turns it into a description of how anything exists at all. Everything you know arrives and departs, grows and wears out and gets replaced, and the line hands that whole process to Kronos without explaining itself. The edition’s note calls it the old play of Kronos on Chronos, the Greek word for time, and adds that the hymn works the play “without ever naming Chronos,” since no form of the word for time appears anywhere in its ten lines. So the reading is there for anyone who wants it, and the word that would make it explicit is exactly the one the poet keeps back.
The cues keep coming once you start listening for them. Two lines later he is “Kronos, all-begetter of the age, Kronos of intricate speech,” and the word for age, aiōn, means a lifetime, a generation or eternity itself, depending on how far you let it stretch. The name rings twice in that one line, Krone, Krone, and a Greek ear hearing the name struck twice in a line about the age would hardly need prompting, since the two words differ by little more than a breath on the first consonant. It’s like hearing a song set up a rhyme so clearly that the whole crowd shouts the last word before the singer gets there, and the hymn trusts its listeners to do the shouting.
The pun wasn’t new, and that’s why the hymn could leave it unspoken. Cicero, writing two or three centuries earlier, reports the Stoic reading plainly, that Kronos is the same as Chronos, a span of time, and that the story of his devouring his sons means that time devours the passing seasons and gorges itself without end on the years gone by. By the time these hymns were sung the identification was a commonplace of philosophy, the sort of thing an educated reader carried around as automatically as we carry the idea that Father Time has a scythe, which in fact descends from Kronos’ sickle, the one he used on his own father.
Line 7 adds the most interesting cue, though it takes a look at the apparatus to see it whole. The printed line calls Kronos “birth, diminisher of growth,” which already names both ends of a life, but the manuscripts read slightly differently, since the word the Dutch scholar Lennep corrected was a plain noun, giving “birth, growth, waning,” three stages in a row. That reading is the clearest statement in the hymn of what time does, the whole curve of a living thing in three words, and it reads like a pocket version of Ecclesiastes, which says there is a time to be born and a time to die, a time to plant and a time to pluck up what was planted. Either way the line makes Kronos the name for the arc every creature travels.
So why not just say the word? The answer, I think, is that naming Chronos would force a choice the hymn doesn’t want to make. Kronos in this hymn is still very much a person, “offspring of Gaia and of starry Ouranos,” husband of Rhea, father of gods, with a genealogy and a marriage, and if the poet called him Time outright he’d dissolve into an abstraction, while if he dropped the time language he’d shrink back into the family monster of Hesiod. By describing time’s work and withholding time’s name, the hymn keeps the Titan and the process in one figure, and lets you hear whichever you’re ready to hear.
A Christian reader has a famous example of the same old shape surviving in plain sight. Isaac Watts, in the hymn that begins “O God, our help in ages past,” sings that time, like an ever-rolling stream, bears all its sons away, which is Kronos and his children translated into an English river, with time as the parent who loses every child. The hymn to Kronos knew that shape too, and it ends by asking the god for exactly what you’d ask of time, “may you send an end of life ever blessed and blameless.” The note on the line reads it as a prayer for a good life brought to a good close, which is the only sensible thing to ask of the power that measures every life from its birth to its end.
My verdict is that the hymn doesn’t just allow the reading through Chronos, it builds the reading in and then leaves the last step to the listener. Every cue is there, the consuming and increasing, the begetter of the age, birth and growth and waning, the prayer for a good end, and Herakles had even been called father of time one hymn earlier, so nobody arrives at Kronos unprepared. The name itself is held back so that Kronos can stay a Titan with a wife and a family while doing what time does to everything, and that withheld word is the most skillful thing in the poem.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the hymn chiefly transform Hesiod’s story of Kronos swallowing his children?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does withholding the word “Chronos” make the hymn’s interpretation more powerful or less certain than naming time directly would?→
- Which cue discussed in the article most strongly supports the identification of Kronos with time, and what makes it more persuasive than the others?→
- Does transforming Kronos’s devouring of his children into a cycle of consumption and renewal soften the original horror, preserve it, or give it a different kind of force?→