Renaissance

Three Ways to End a Renaissance

Pater places the end of the Renaissance in France, then writes beyond it. Winckelmann and the Conclusion show what can survive the end of a period.

The French chapters give the history a boundary. The final two essays turn revival into a possibility that remains open to the reader.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • An ending in FrancePater names French poetry and Du Bellay as the later growth that brings his Renaissance history to a close.
  • A revival outside the periodWinckelmann belongs to eighteenth-century Europe, yet Pater sees in him a renewal of an impulse that shaped the earlier studies.
  • From centuries to momentsThe Conclusion applies the critic’s attention to a person’s own experience and takes the book from historical periods down to individual moments.
  • What the outline emphasizesThe editorial outline moves from Du Bellay’s poetry of distance to Winckelmann’s revival and then to the reader’s experience of time.

Pater gives his history an apparent stopping point. The Preface says that “the Renaissance ends also in France, in French poetry,” with Joachim du Bellay as its most perfect illustration, and the first essay opens with “The history of the Renaissance ends in France, and carries us away from Italy to the beautiful cities of the country of the Loire.” Yet the book doesn’t end with Du Bellay, because after him comes Winckelmann, an eighteenth-century German in Rome, and after Winckelmann comes the Conclusion, where the subject becomes the reader’s experience of time. So the volume offers at least three candidate endings, a national one in France, a later revival in Winckelmann, and a change of scale in the Conclusion, and it’s worth asking how they fit together.

Start with France, since Pater gives it the most explicit billing. He admits in the Preface that he chose the medieval French stories partly “because they help the unity of my series,” since the Renaissance both begins and ends in France, which makes the national ending at least half a matter of design. He calls the French ending “an aftermath, a wonderful later growth,” and the word is precise, because an aftermath was originally a farmer’s term for the second crop of grass that comes up after the first mowing. Du Bellay’s France is a second harvest, late, thinner and sweeter, with a sweetness Pater says “belongs to a refined and comely decadence,” so the national ending is really an ending by afterglow.

The outline at the back tells the story without that claim. Its entry for the French stories says Pater “looks for an early revival of imaginative freedom,” and its Du Bellay entry says that “French poetry meets classical and Italian models” and that his time in Rome “yields a poetry of distance in which the small particularities of home become newly distinct.” Nowhere does the outline say the Renaissance ends in France. It treats Du Bellay as a meeting and a homecoming, a poet who discovers his own country by being away from it, and then it calls Winckelmann “the last of Pater’s examples of revival,” a phrase that treats revival as a kind of event with more than one instance rather than a period with a closing date. It’s a small editorial choice, but it changes the shape of the book, since a reader who used only the outline would never suspect that Pater thought his history had a French border at both ends.

That phrase changes how Winckelmann’s chapter works as an ending. Pater says Winckelmann, “coming in the eighteenth century, really belongs in spirit to an earlier age,” and calls him “the last fruit of the Renaissance.” But if a man trained in the eighteenth century who learned to see Greek art in Rome can have a Renaissance, the Renaissance isn’t a period at all, it’s a pattern, something like a song that keeps getting covered by new bands in new decades. The last example is only the last one Pater chose to include, and the chapter ends the series without ending the thing the series describes, which is a strange and interesting way for a history to close.

The Conclusion goes further and changes the scale entirely. The outline’s summary is exact, since “the attention asked of a critic is applied to time and experience,” and the unit of attention shrinks from centuries to moments and from a nation to a single consciousness. What the Renaissance meant, in Pater’s definition, was “the love of the things of the intellect and the imagination for their own sake,” and the Conclusion hands that love to the reader as a way of living now, without dates or places. The last word of the book isn’t about the past, and the history ends by turning into advice.

A historian could fairly object that this is the wrong way to count. Pater states the French ending twice in his own voice, at the front of the book and at the head of the first essay, while much of the Conclusion first appeared in Pater’s 1868 review of William Morris’s poems before he made it his closing statement. On that view, the history ends with its last historical chapter, Winckelmann is a coda, and the Conclusion is a postscript about something else, so the national ending is the only one that belongs to the history proper. It’s a reasonable reading, and it takes Pater at his explicit word.

But structure speaks too, and Pater’s structure gives the Conclusion the last word on purpose. He withdrew it from the second edition and then restored it in 1888, which means he chose, after reflection, to make his book end there rather than with Winckelmann. And the three endings answer different questions, so they don’t really compete. France answers when the period stopped, Winckelmann answers whether the impulse outlived the period, and the Conclusion answers what the impulse is for, which is the only question still open to a reader once the history is over. Read that way, the endings nest inside one another like the rings of a tree, the period inside the pattern and the pattern inside the practice.

The book closes through a combination, then, but not an equal one. The national ending is a frame of convenience that Pater openly admits, the revival ending is the hinge that turns a period into a pattern, and the change of scale is the ending that matters, because it’s the only one a later example can’t supersede. The outline is right to drop the claim that the Renaissance ends in France, since by the last page Pater has moved it somewhere much closer, into whatever moment the reader happens to be living.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article interpret Winckelmann’s role as the “last fruit of the Renaissance”?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.