Greek Antiquity

Three Gods at One Tiller

Eros, Nomos, and Death hold overlapping claims to the same image of divine steering.

Three hymns give the tiller to three different powers. The article reads their sequence as a passage from the impulses that set life in motion to its course and close.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Eros holds the widest tillerThe hymn gives him the tiller of all the regions named in its account of his keys.
  • Nomos steers living thingsLaw’s tiller stands beside its care for straight purposes and the difference it makes to lawful and lawless people.
  • Death holds the tiller of mortalsThe hymn asks the power that gives each person a span of time to arrive as late as possible.
  • The claims overlapBecause mortals are among living things, the article reads the three steering powers through what they do at different stages of a life.

Orphic Hymns, LVIII.4–10, with the note on LVIII.4; LXIV.8–11, with the note on LXIV.8; LXXXVII.1–2, 8–12, with the note on LXXXVII.1; X.24, 28

A ship has one tiller and only one hand can hold it at a time, which is why the Orphic hymns create a small puzzle when they hand the tiller to three different gods. Eros is told “for you alone hold the tiller of all these things,” Nomos is praised because “he alone holds the tiller of living things,” and Death is addressed as “you who hold the tiller of all mortals.” The note on the Nomos hymn says it flatly, that two gods are each said to steer alone and that “the hymns do not notice each other, and the edition does not reconcile them.” So the reader is left holding the question of whether these claims can be fitted together or whether each hymn simply puts its own god at the helm for as long as the hymn lasts.

The first thing to check is scope, since three helmsmen can share a fleet if each steers a different ship. Eros’ tiller covers the regions his hymn has just listed, “of heavenly aither, of the deep, of earth, and of all the breaths” that Rhea feeds, along with Tartaros and the sea, which is everything there is. Nomos steers living things, the creatures that can obey or break a law, and his hymn calls him “companion of the straightest purposes, unwarped for ever.” Death steers mortals, the ones who die, which is narrower again. So the scopes shrink from cosmos to creatures to mortals, and you might hope that settles it, with each god in charge of his own circle.

It doesn’t quite settle it, though, because the circles are nested, not separate. Mortals are living things and living things are part of everything, so Eros’ claim to steer all these things alone already includes the ground Nomos and Death claim. The word alone makes the collision sharper, and the note on Death’s hymn adds a twist, that this is the one of the three without the word in its opening line, even though Death “has the best title to it.” The hymn supplies it later, in two lines in a row, “for in you alone of all is what has been judged brought to fulfilment” and “for you alone are won over neither by prayers nor by entreaties,” so Death’s alone is about finality, not about steering.

The collection is generous with that word in general. Physis, ten hymns into the book, is “alone accomplishing what is decreed,” the same claim Death’s hymn makes about judgment, and four lines later she is told that “you alone make all these.” If Physis and Death can both alone bring judgment to fulfilment, the word is behaving less like a legal claim than like praise turned all the way up, the way a fan will tell three different singers on three different nights that each is the only voice that matters. That supports the second reading, that each address puts its god at the center while it lasts and doesn’t worry about the others.

There is a third possibility, and it comes from what each tiller is actually for. Eros steers by desire, and his hymn asks him to come to the initiates and “send base and outlandish impulses away from them,” so his steering is about where impulses push a life. Nomos steers by keeping things true, rewarding the lawful and bringing misery to the lawless. Death steers by ending, “giving to all a holy span of time,” and the worshipper asks him only to come late, “that old age may be a goodly prize among men.” Desire sets a life moving, law keeps it on course, and death brings it in, and those are three different stretches of one voyage.

Sailors know this arrangement well, because no one person holds a helm for a whole voyage. The watch changes every few hours and the helmsman is relieved, and when a ship comes into a busy harbor a local pilot climbs aboard and takes the con from the captain for the last stretch, since he knows the channel and the captain doesn’t. Plato used the image in the Statesman, telling a myth in which the pilot of the universe lets go of the tiller and withdraws to his lookout, and the world runs on without him until he takes it up again. A tiller can be held alone and still change hands, and the Psalms speak of storm-tossed sailors being brought at last to the haven they wanted.

The order of the book makes that relay easy to see, whether or not anyone planned it. Eros’ hymn stands at LVIII, Nomos’ six hymns later at LXIV, and Death’s at LXXXVII, the last hymn of the collection proper, with only the disputed hymn to Ares after it. A reader going from front to back hands the tiller from desire to law to death, and the book’s last prayer asks the final helmsman for a long voyage and an honored old age. The note is right that the hymns don’t notice each other, and the reconciliation, if there is one, belongs to the sequence and to the reader, not to any single hymn.

My verdict is that the differences in scope and in the use of alone don’t reconcile the three images by logic, since the circles nest and the word alone is spent too freely to carry a strict claim, but the images reconcile as a relay. Each hymn centers its own god at the helm while it’s being sung, and the collection, read in order, passes the tiller from the god who starts a life to the god who keeps it straight to the god who brings it into harbor. That is how a living world can have three gods at one tiller, because each holds it alone for his own stretch of the voyage.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article reject differences in scope as a complete logical solution to the three tiller claims?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.