Renaissance

Theory Under the Microscope

Pater gives theory the work of a microscope. A point of view earns its place by bringing a feature of experience into sight.

Hugo’s image of the microscope helps Pater describe what an idea can reveal. The two editions differ in how far he is willing to let an idea make demands on experience.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A borrowed microscopeHugo uses the microscope to describe a way of looking into what a city conceals, and Pater applies the image to overlooked experience.
  • What a theory can revealPater gives a point of view the job of bringing something into focus that the reader or viewer might otherwise pass over.
  • The reader’s own orthodoxyPater places the critic’s own system beside the systems of Comte and Hegel as a view that needs continued testing.
  • Morality becomes theoryThe fourth edition replaces abstract morality with abstract theory in the warning about ideas that demand the sacrifice of experience.

Pater has just said that we’ll “hardly have time to make theories about the things we see and touch,” which sounds like a brush-off, and then he turns around and gives theory a job. “Philosophical theories or ideas, as points of view, instruments of criticism, may help us to gather up what might otherwise pass unregarded by us,” he says, and he caps it with a borrowed aphorism, “Philosophy is the microscope of thought.” The line comes from Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables, where the narrator asks a social observer to enter the darkness of the Paris sewers. Pater’s 1873 printing gives the line in French with a feminine article before a masculine noun.

A microscope is a good choice because it describes what a theory does and what it can’t do. It shows you detail you couldn’t see with the naked eye, cells in a leaf, the structure of a crystal, and it does that by narrowing the field, so you see a tiny region very well and everything else not at all. It also needs constant adjustment, focus and lighting and the choice of lens, and every lens shows something the others hide. The modern version is the map on your phone, where you flip between satellite, transit and terrain views, and each layer reveals something the others bury, while none of them is the map.

So a point of view earns its keep by what it discloses. Read a novel with an economic lens and you suddenly notice who pays for everything, and switch to a psychological one and the same scenes fill with motives you didn’t see. Pater’s phrase is careful about the result, since the theory helps us “gather up” what might otherwise “pass unregarded,” which makes theory an aid to attention rather than a substitute for it. The thing gathered is still the experience, now noticed in finer grain, and a good theory on this view works like a good teacher, who makes you notice what was in front of you all along and then gets out of the way.

The limit actually comes right before the permission, in the sentence that opens the passage. “What we have to do is to be for ever curiously testing new opinions and courting new impressions, never acquiescing in a facile orthodoxy, of Comte, or of Hegel, or of our own.” Auguste Comte, the founder of positivism, and Hegel stand for the great system-builders of the century, and the note points out that adding “our own” turns the danger from a doctrine into a habit of mind. That’s the sharpest bit of the sentence, since your own theory is the one most likely to harden into orthodoxy, precisely because you can’t see it as a lens anymore and start thinking it’s simply the view.

Then Pater states the rule that keeps theory in its place. “The theory or idea or system which requires of us the sacrifice of any part of this experience, in consideration of some interest into which we cannot enter, or some abstract theory we have not identified with ourselves, or of what is only conventional, has no real claim upon us.” A microscope that tells you to stop looking at things it can’t show you has forgotten what it’s for. A theory can earn authority by what it reveals, and it loses that authority the moment it starts forbidding you to see what lies outside its field.

The revisions show where that rule ran into trouble. In 1873 the second item read “some abstract morality we have not identified with ourselves,” and the list of useful instruments began “Theories, religious or philosophical ideas,” while in 1893 morality became “theory” and religion dropped out of the list. The first version said, in effect, that a moral rule you haven’t made your own has no claim on you if it costs you experience, a wider claim about authority than the fourth edition makes. Changing “morality” to “theory” narrows the rule to where it’s actually defensible, since it’s fair to say a theory shouldn’t censor experience, and a good deal harder to say the same about ethics.

That’s where I’d push back on even the revised rule. Some demands to give up experience are reasonable, and a friend may ask you to give up something you would enjoy for a reason you can understand only after listening to them. A microscope also produces artifacts, smudges on the lens or tricks of the stain that look like structures, so testing a theory has to include testing what it seems to show. Pater’s own word “testing” points the right way here, because a tested instrument is one you trust for some jobs and not others, which is a more modest authority than either obedience or dismissal. Pater’s note says he once omitted the Conclusion for fear some young readers would be misled. The history of the essay itself gives him a reason to care about how someone will use a point of view.

What a philosophical microscope can show is real and specific, the fine structure of experience that the naked eye passes over, and Pater’s image explains both its power and its narrowness, a lens that reveals by excluding. The demand to keep testing, your own views included, sets the right limit on its authority, since a lens earns trust by what it shows and never by what it forbids. The change from “morality” to “theory” suggests that Pater knew his rule was safest when it governed instruments, and that’s the version worth keeping.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the most important implication of Pater's warning against an orthodoxy “of our own”?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.