Philosophy
The Wrong Inside
Socrates plans to examine Charmides’ soul. Once the boy sits beside him, a glance inside his cloak upends the plan.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates proposes to look inside the boy before looking at his body, and then a glimpse inside the boy’s cloak unsettles him. Plato makes him tell us so, and the confession does more work than any dignified version could have done.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Socrates’ planSocrates proposes examining Charmides’ soul before looking at his body. He borrows the wrestling school’s language of undressing.
- A glance takes overWhen Charmides sits beside him, Socrates sees inside the boy’s cloak and says he is on fire. The examiner becomes the subject of his own story.
- Two people at a lossSocrates tells his listener how he lost his composure. Later he says Critias seemed to catch his perplexity as one person catches a yawn from another.
- Whose eyes are we using?The crowd has been looking at Charmides since he arrived. Socrates’ admission turns the reader’s attention to the people doing the looking.
At the height of the scene on the bench, Socrates tells his friend the most embarrassing thing in the whole dialogue. Charmides has given him a look, the gym has crowded round, “then, my noble friend, I saw inside his cloak, and I was on fire, and was no longer in my own possession.” The cloak was a loose mantle, and a narrator worried about his reputation as a philosopher might have quietly left that glance out of the story, since it’s the one sentence in the dialogue a careful image manager would cut first. Plato keeps it in, and puts it in Socrates’ own mouth, so the real question is what that confession is doing for the reader.
Start with the joke, because it’s built with real care. Earlier Socrates had proposed a plan for meeting the boy, asking “why don’t we strip that very part of him,” and adding, “and take a look at it before we look at his figure?” The soul was to come first and the body later, the inside before the outside, and then what catches Socrates’ eye on the bench is the inside of the boy’s clothes. The Greek says simply that he saw what was inside the cloak. The grand metaphor of undressing a soul comes true in the most literal and least philosophical way imaginable.
That makes the glance a first-class pratfall, and the comedy matters. It’s like a nutritionist announcing his new diet to a room full of people and then getting caught with his face in the cake, which is funny precisely because he just told everyone what he was going to do. The laugh keeps the scene human, and it also keeps the erotic material from turning heavy or sleazy, since a philosopher tripping over his own plan is a lot easier to watch than one leering at a teenager, and the joke is clearly on him. Plato was a good enough comic writer to know that a joke lands hardest when the setup is the hero’s own confident plan.
The confession also buys Socrates something valuable as a narrator, which is our trust. A storyteller who reports his own worst moment, in detail, to a friend, is a storyteller you’re inclined to believe about everything else, the way a witness who admits the fact that hurts his own side becomes more credible on all the rest. So when Socrates later reports that Critias seemed to catch his confusion “like people who catch a yawn” and then refused to admit he was stuck, we’re inclined to listen. Socrates has already made himself look foolish. It works the way an honest restaurant review earns trust by mentioning the one bad dish, which makes the praise of everything else believable.
Then there’s the picture of the examiner, which the glance changes for good. We tend to imagine a philosophical examiner standing calmly outside what he examines, like a doctor reading an X-ray or a judge looking down from the bench, untouched by the person in front of him. The cloak puts Socrates firmly inside the scene, with eyes and a body and a temperature of his own, and in a dialogue that will end up asking whether anyone can know himself, the narrator’s report on what just happened to him is an early piece of self-knowledge on the table. Socrates isn’t a camera mounted on a tripod at the edge of the room, he’s one of the people the camera ought to be pointed at.
Notice too how brief the confession is, because the length of a confession says something about the person making it. Socrates gives the glance one sentence, adds a fragment of verse to describe how caught he felt, and then gets on with answering the boy’s question about the remedy, so there’s no wallowing, no long description, nothing like a modern tell-all. The candor comes with proportion, which is its own small display of the virtue under discussion, since knowing how much to say about yourself is part of saying it well, and Socrates says exactly enough to make the point and not a word more.
The glance also does something to the reader, and it’s a little uncomfortable. Since Charmides came in, we’ve been looking at Charmides through other people’s eyes, the men who are astounded, the boys who stare at him like a statue, Chaerephon who wants us to imagine him undressed, and we’ve been enjoying the comedy of all that looking. When Socrates admits where his own eyes went, he holds up a mirror to the kind of looking the scene has been inviting from us too, and the reader gets a small jolt of recognition about whose gaze the story has been borrowing. That’s a characteristically Platonic move, turning a story about other people’s eyes into a question about our own.
My verdict is that the glance belongs in the dialogue because the Charmides is about seeing inside people, and from the very start we can see how easily looking inside goes wrong. By confessing that he saw the wrong inside first, Socrates earns the right to go looking for the right one, and he does it as a man who has just shown us, comically and honestly, how hard the search is going to be. A Socrates who never looked would have nothing to teach us about looking well.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article describe Socrates’ glance as a carefully constructed joke rather than merely an embarrassing incident?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the comic reversal of looking inside Charmides’ cloak complicate the distinction between examining a body and examining a soul?→
- Does admitting a humiliating moment necessarily make a narrator more trustworthy? What assumptions about honesty underlie the article’s argument?→
- In what ways does the scene turn the reader from an observer of other people’s gazes into someone who must examine their own way of looking?→