Renaissance
The World in God’s Hands, and the Silence Beyond It
A fresco at Pisa gives the universe an edge and hands to hold it. Pater sets it beside a line of Pascal that makes the sky feel immeasurable.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater turns a change in cosmology into a change in feeling. Pascal’s silence and Sagan’s pale blue dot suggest two responses to a world that no longer looks made to our scale.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A bounded universeThe Pisa fresco shows concentric rings that let the viewer take in the whole cosmos at a glance.
- The hands holding the worldPater compares the universe in the divine figure’s hands to a shield or a toy, making its limits feel familiar.
- The setting Pater addsPascal’s fragment gives us a line about silence and fear. Pater imagines him looking up on a starlit night.
- More than one feeling fits the skyPater allows that modern awe might itself be a kind of superstition. Sagan finds humility and care for others in another image of Earth’s smallness.
The Renaissance · Pico della Mirandola, the Pisa fresco and Pascal’s silence · Note 70, the creative Logos · Note 71, Pisa’s Camposanto · Note 72, Pascal’s words on infinite space · Piero di Puccio’s fresco, University of Bologna catalogue · Comune di Pisa, the Camposanto and the 1944 fire · Pascal, Pensées 206, the silence of infinite spaces · Pascal, Pensées 348, the thinking reed · Paul Valéry, Variation sur une pensée · NASA, Voyager 1’s Pale Blue Dot and Carl Sagan’s reflection
Pater’s description of Pico’s universe is one of the most vivid sentences in the chapter. The world, for Pico, is “a limited place, bounded by actual crystal walls, and a material firmament,” and it is “like a painted toy, like that map or system of the world, held, as a great target or shield, in the hands of the creative Logos, by whom the Father made all things, in one of the earlier frescoes of the Campo Santo at Pisa.” The edition’s notes gloss the two hard words, Logos, the Greek for word, account or reason, which in Christian usage means the creative Word of the opening of John’s Gospel, and camposanto, Italian for holy field, the name of Pisa’s great cemetery.
The fresco is real and still worth the trip. Piero di Puccio painted his Theological Cosmography on a wall of the Camposanto between 1389 and 1391, showing a giant divine figure with Christ-like features holding the universe in front of his body as a set of concentric rings. At the center is a little map of the earth’s three known continents, and around it run the rings of the elements, the planets, the sun and moon, the stars with the signs of the zodiac and, at the outside, the nine choirs of angels, while Augustine and Thomas Aquinas stand in the lower corners. It was badly damaged after an artillery shell struck the Camposanto and set its roof on fire on July 27, 1944, and Pater’s word target is exact, since the rings look like an archery butt.
Pater asks us to feel what that picture permits, and the first answer is intelligibility. A world drawn as rings within rings has an edge, so nothing in it is lost or unaccounted for, and the whole of reality can be seen at once, like a snow globe that holds a complete little town you can pick up in one hand. Pater calls it a painted toy and later a “childish dream,” which sounds dismissive, but toys are things we love and hold close, and the most important feature of the fresco isn’t the rings at all. It’s the hands, since this universe has someone holding it, and to live inside it is to live inside something that is being carried.
Then Pater turns to his own century and its very different sky. “How different from this childish dream is our own conception of nature, with its unlimited space, its innumerable suns, and the earth but a mote in the beam; how different the strange new awe, or superstition, with which it fills our minds!” Read that last clause twice, because it’s the most honest thing in the passage. Pater won’t let his modern readers feel simply enlightened, since the awe they feel before infinite space might itself be a superstition, a mood projected onto the sky as surely as the medieval painter projected his rings, so the comparison stays fair to both sides even as it marks the distance between them.
The emotion he chooses for the modern picture comes from Pascal, whom Pater imagines “contemplating a starlight night” and quotes first in English, “the silence of those infinite spaces terrifies me,” and then in French, which the edition translates as the eternal silence of these infinite spaces frightens me. In the Pensées the line stands alone as a single fragment, without any scene, so the starlit night is Pater’s addition. The fragment leaves the voice open to interpretation. Elsewhere in the Pensées, Pascal says space engulfs him like a point while thought lets him comprehend it. Paul Valéry wondered whether the beauty of the line about silence gave us reason to question how directly it expressed Pascal’s own fear.
Here is how Pater makes history felt, and it’s a remarkable technique. Instead of describing a change of doctrine, he gives each picture an emotion, so the bounded world permits the comfort and smallness of a toy and the unbounded world permits awe edging into terror, and the long story of Copernicus, Galileo’s telescope and infinite space becomes a change in the mood of looking up. His phrase “the earth but a mote in the beam” has an unexpected parallel. When Voyager 1 photographed the earth from billions of miles away in 1990, Carl Sagan described it as a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam, and from that image he drew humility and a call to kindness toward one another rather than terror, which suggests a picture permits several feelings without dictating any one.
The comparison also flattens something on the medieval side, which had terrors of its own. A universe of rings around the earth was a universe in which the stars could rule your fate, and astrology was the fear that came with the comfort of enclosure. Pico spent the last years of his life writing a long attack on divinatory astrology, published after his death, challenging the idea that the stars could tell us what human beings would do. So the enclosed world wasn’t all safety, and the infinite one isn’t all dread, since Pascal himself answered the silence with the dignity of thought and Sagan answered it with tenderness.
My verdict is that Pater’s comparison is a brilliant way to make the history of science felt on the skin, and fairer than it first looks because of his two words “or superstition.” But the deepest difference between the two pictures isn’t size, or walls, or even fear. The fresco shows a world held in the hands of the Word, and Pascal’s line complains of silence, so what Pater is really registering is the loss of a world that speaks to us, and the most interesting emotion his comparison permits is the one that sits between the two, the sense of looking up at a sky that used to have a voice and listening for whether it still does.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author consider Pater’s phrase “or superstition” crucial to the fairness of his comparison?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a representation of the universe can permit several emotions without determining one, what gives a cosmic picture its emotional power: its visual form, its cultural context, or the viewer’s interpretation?→
- Does describing modern awe as a possible “superstition” genuinely place medieval and modern outlooks on equal terms, or does Pater’s language still privilege one over the other?→
- Why might the contrast between a world held by the Word and a silent universe be more significant than the contrast between a bounded and an infinite cosmos?→