Renaissance
The Work, the Viewer and What Happens Between Them
Virtue, temperament and impression name three parts of one encounter. The critic starts with what they feel and asks what gave rise to it.
The Renaissance (1893)The glossary helps readers tell the power of an artwork from a person’s capacity to respond and the effect the work actually has on them.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A property in the workThe glossary’s virtue is the active quality that gives an artwork its distinctive effect.
- A capacity in the viewerTemperament is the critic’s particular disposition and ability to register what a work does.
- An effect to examineAn impression is what happens in the encounter, and Pater asks the critic to describe it and work back toward its source.
- A wider sense in the ConclusionThe glossary gives impression a second meaning as an element of changing experience, extending the word beyond an encounter with art.
The Renaissance · Preface, p. 2, the effect on the critic · Preface, pp. 2–3, virtues of works of art · Preface, p. 3, temperament and analysis · Preface, p. 3, Wordsworth’s distinctive effect · Glossary, p. 156, impression · Glossary, p. 156, temperament · Glossary, p. 156, virtue · 1893 Conclusion, pp. 150–151, the shifting impressions
The glossary keeps each of these entries short, almost telegraphic. Virtue is “In the Preface, the active property that gives a work its distinctive effect.” Temperament is “A characteristic disposition of feeling and perception,” and the entry adds that “In the Preface, the critic requires an unusual susceptibility to the effects of art.” Impression is “A felt effect to be discriminated and examined,” with a second sense for the Conclusion. Each word lives in a different place, the virtue in the work, the temperament in the person, and the impression in the meeting between them, like a song, a listener, and the moment the chorus hits. The glossary lists them alphabetically, so their connection only emerges when a reader compares the entries, so the first job for a reader is to pull the three entries out of their order and set them side by side.
The grammar of the definitions is worth a second look, because it quietly assigns roles. Virtue gets “the active property,” a definite article and an active adjective, so it’s one specific power in the work that does something. Temperament gets “a characteristic disposition,” something standing and settled rather than acting, a capacity waiting for an occasion. Impression gets “a felt effect to be discriminated and examined,” and the infinitives describe what the critic is to do with it. It becomes raw material, something that has happened to you and now has to be worked on. The work acts, the critic is disposed, and the impression is the thing the critic’s work begins with.
The Preface fills in the scene in more detail, with all three terms in play. The objects of criticism “possess, like the products of nature, so many virtues or qualities,” and the critic needs “a certain kind of temperament, the power of being deeply moved by the presence of beautiful objects.” The encounter produces an effect, and Pater’s question is “What effect does it really produce on me?” From there the method runs in steps, first “to know one’s own impression as it really is, to discriminate it, to realise it distinctly,” then “to distinguish, to analyse, and separate from its adjuncts, the virtue” of the work, and finally “to indicate what the source of that impression is, and under what conditions it is experienced.”
Notice that the method runs in the opposite direction from the cause. Causally, the virtue in the work acts on a temperament and produces an impression. Methodologically, the critic starts with the impression, examines it with the help of his temperament, and works back to the virtue, like a sound engineer who hears a hum and traces it back through the cables until he finds the faulty amplifier. Pater’s critic walks backward along the chain of causes, and that’s only possible if the three links stay distinct, since you can’t trace an effect back to its source if the source and the effect are the same thing. That backward walk also explains why Pater thinks abstract definitions of beauty help so little, since a general definition cannot by itself tell the critic what produced this particular impression.
The first mistake the glossary guards against is treating virtue and impression as synonyms. If the work’s property simply is my feeling, then criticism turns into a diary of moods, and Pater’s instruction to find “what the source of that impression is” stops making sense, because a feeling can’t be traced back to itself. The Preface needs the virtue to be out there in the work, which is why Pater compares the critic to someone who notes an element “as a chemist notes some natural element,” and why his example from Wordsworth names a quality in the poems, “that strange, mystical sense of a life in natural things,” that many readers can find and argue about. Someone who disagrees with Pater about Wordsworth is disagreeing about something in the poems, which is only possible if the virtue is distinct from anyone’s particular impression of it.
The second mistake is letting temperament collapse into either of the other two. A susceptible critic isn’t someone who has strong feelings about everything, which would only be a mood, but someone whose range of response is wide and fine, and Pater says that “Our education becomes complete in proportion as our susceptibility to these impressions increases in depth and variety.” If temperament merges with impression, then “I felt it strongly” becomes evidence of insight. If it merges with virtue, the critic starts finding his own temperament in every work he looks at and calls it discovery, which is projection wearing the clothes of method.
The glossary’s entry for impression also does something subtle with its second sense, “In the Conclusion, an element of ever-changing experience.” In the Conclusion, objects themselves dissolve into impressions, and the triangle of work, critic and effect seems to collapse into a stream of passing sensations. By giving the Preface’s sense first, the glossary keeps the triangle in the reader’s mind when the Conclusion seems to dissolve it, so that the later essay’s flux reads as a description of experience and not as a cancellation of the Preface’s method. The order follows the book, where the Preface gives the word a task in criticism and the Conclusion gives it a wider role in experience.
Three words, then, name three positions, a property in the work, a capacity in the critic and an event between them, and Pater’s method is the patient walk backward from the event to the property by way of the capacity. The glossary’s definitions are brief, but they make the whole encounter reconstructable, and they protect the reader against the two easiest ways of misreading Pater, a record of feelings that never returns to the work, or a reading that mistakes the critic’s own temperament for something the work contains. That’s a lot of work for three short entries, and it’s the strongest argument for putting a glossary at the back of a book like this.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why must virtue, temperament, and impression remain distinct in Pater’s critical method?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If criticism begins with a personal impression but must return to the work, what might distinguish disciplined self-examination from a mere diary of feelings?→
- Why does the article describe Pater’s method as moving in the opposite direction from causation, and what strengths or limitations might that backward movement have?→
- How might a critic remain receptive enough to develop a wide and fine temperament while avoiding the projection of that temperament onto every work?→