Renaissance

The Work a Fragment of Venetian Glass Can Do

A shard of glass, a patch of sunlight and a woven carpet help Pater describe the moment a painting first catches the eye.

Pater’s three comparisons trace how color attracts attention and how a painter gives that pleasure a form in which meaning can arrive.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A shard catches the eyeThe Venetian glass illustrates how color can attract attention before the viewer recognizes a subject.
  • Light can be enough to look atA patch of sunlight and shadow has no fixed message, yet its changing relations can hold the eye.
  • A woven pattern holds the effectThe carpet gives Pater a way to describe how a painter fixes and refines a moment of light.
  • Pleasure carries meaningPater says the pleasure of looking is the route by which a painting can make its story or thought felt.

Think about the last time a painting stopped you from across a gallery, before you knew who painted it or what was going on in it, just because some color grabbed your eye. Pater thinks that moment is where pictures begin, and he says so with an image that can still sound a little outrageous, insisting that the drawing and coloring of a painting “must first of all delight the sense, delight it as directly and sensuously as a fragment of Venetian glass.” He follows it with two more comparisons in the space of a few lines, sunlight on a wall and the colors in an Eastern carpet, and the three together make an argument, because each one strips away something you might have thought a picture needed.

Start with the glass and notice the word “fragment,” which Pater could easily have left out. A whole goblet has a use and a shape and maybe a story about who drank from it, but a broken piece can catch your eye before you know any of that, and you pick it up anyway because of what the light does when it passes through, the way people pocket sea glass on a beach without any idea what bottle it came from. Venice was celebrated for its fine glass, but the point is general, that something made by skilled hands can delight you with no subject at all. The glass gets rid of the subject while keeping the maker, and it keeps the most physical kind of pleasure, color you see through rather than color that tells you something.

The second image goes further and takes away the maker too. “In its primary aspect,” Pater writes, “a great picture has no more definite message for us than an accidental play of sunlight and shadow for a few moments on the wall or floor,” and everything in that phrase is about chance, a light that lasts a few moments and falls wherever the window puts it. It’s the bright patch on the kitchen floor that the cat finds every afternoon, which means nothing and is still the best spot in the house. Then Pater turns it around and says a picture “is itself, in truth, a space of such fallen light,” which is a lovely way of putting it, because a canvas really is a fixed area where light has been made to land and stay.

The third image puts back the maker and adds something the first two lacked. The fallen light in a picture is “caught as the colours are in an Eastern carpet, but refined upon, and dealt with more subtly and exquisitely than by nature itself,” and a carpet is a crafted thing that holds its color in a pattern, knotted in for good, unlike the patch on the floor that slides away by suppertime. Ottoman carpets reached Venice through trade, and Venetian painters loved them enough to drape them over tables and balconies in their pictures, with Lorenzo Lotto painting one type so carefully that collectors still call it a Lotto carpet. So the sequence runs from a made thing without a subject, to a bright thing without a maker, to a made pattern that keeps light from escaping, and the picture is what you get when all three come together.

The date of publication gives these images an extra edge. Pater published the essay in the Fortnightly Review in October 1877, a few months after Ruskin, the most powerful art critic in England, had attacked Whistler’s night scene of fireworks at the new Grosvenor Gallery by accusing him of “flinging a pot of paint in the public’s face.” Whistler sued, and at the libel trial the next year an aesthetic question lay beneath the legal one. How much finished work could a viewer recognize in an arrangement of color and light with little story? Pater names neither man. Read beside that dispute, the comparison with sunlight shows how far he thought the immediate effect of a painted surface could take a viewer.

The strongest objection is easy to state, since if a great picture’s first appeal is the same as a carpet’s, you can fairly ask why anyone should prefer Titian to a really good rug, and whether Pater is quietly turning altarpieces into wallpaper when the people who paid for them cared first about the Virgin and the saints. A reader sympathetic to Ruskin might also worry that treating a picture as a beautiful surface discourages questions about what it says or how it was made. Those are serious points, and they get sharper when you notice that Pater calls the painter “the composer,” as if the painter’s job were arrangement first and storytelling a distant second.

But read the whole sentence, because Pater says these qualities must delight the senses first “and through this delight alone become the vehicle of whatever poetry or science may lie beyond them in the intention of the composer.” The meaning hasn’t been thrown out, it’s been put at the end of a road, and the word “alone” says that road is the only one in, so the Virgin and the saints reach you through the color or they don’t reach you as painting at all. And “primary” means first in order, the aspect a picture shows you before any other, rather than the aspect that matters most, while the carpet comparison ends with the picture going further, “refined upon” and handled more “subtly and exquisitely than by nature itself,” so the comparison begins with a shared pleasure, and Pater’s next question is what the painter makes of it.

So I’d read the glass, the sunlight and the carpet as an order of attention rather than a ranking of value. They tell you what has to happen first, and they give you a fair test, since a picture that can’t hold your eye the way a shard of colored glass can won’t be rescued by its subject, however noble, while a picture that passes that test hasn’t yet shown it’s great, only that it’s earned a closer look. The work a fragment of Venetian glass can do is open the door, and in 1877 Pater thought too many critics were trying to get into the house through the walls.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article interpret the progression from Venetian glass to sunlight to an Eastern carpet?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.