Renaissance

The Weather Report Behind Greek Beauty

Pater draws on a mild sky, the sculpted body and Goethe’s Mothers to explain Greek art. Some of those details work better as images than as history.

Pater’s case for the fit between thought and form makes a different claim from his account of the climate and bodies that produced it. The essay’s language makes room for chance as well.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A proposed fitPater says Greek sculpture found a moment when thought could be given a form that appeared to express it fully.
  • An air borrowed from ShakespeareThe pleasant air Pater borrows from Macbeth turns climate into a feeling the reader can recognize.
  • The body as evidenceA sculptor can select and recombine features, which limits what an ideal figure tells us about the people the artist observed.
  • A place for good fortuneGoethe’s Mothers let Pater picture the coming together of conditions whose combined effect he also attributes to good luck.

When people try to explain why one city produced a whole music scene, they usually stack up cheap rent, a couple of good clubs and a few geniuses who happened to be around, and then they shrug and say there was something in the water. Pater’s account of how Greece produced its artistic ideal has the same shape, and he’s candid about it. “That delicate pause in Greek reflexion was joined, by some supreme good luck, to the perfect animal nature of the Greeks,” he writes, and “Here are the two conditions of an artistic ideal.” Then he adds a delicate air, a fine human clay and Goethe’s “Mothers” presiding over the whole thing. Each piece is doing a different kind of explaining, and it’s worth pulling them apart to see which ones would survive a historian’s questions.

The first condition belongs to intellectual history, and it’s the subtlest of the lot. The Greek mind, Pater says, “had advanced to a particular stage of self-reflexion, but was careful not to pass beyond it,” so that thought hadn’t yet grown “too inward” to live comfortably in a body of marble. Taken literally this is shaky, since the age of the Parthenon also produced the sophists and Socrates. Its habit of questioning makes the idea of a single pause hard to sustain. But Pater’s real claim is about the fit between thought and form, the idea that Greek art captured ideas that still felt at home in bodies, and that claim can be tested against the pose and proportion of particular sculptures.

The second condition is weather, and Pater borrows a famous line for it. The Greek enters life with “That delicate air, ’nimbly and sweetly recommending itself’ to the senses,” which adapts a line from Duncan’s arrival in Macbeth. He praises the air around the castle where he is about to spend the night. The irony is probably unintended, but it’s useful, because climate is the most seductive and least reliable explanation in the whole kit. The idea that climate shapes a population is old. It is also part of Winckelmann’s account of the conditions in which Greek art arose. Pater uses the same move elsewhere in the chapter, where religions “brighten under a bright sky” and wine “becomes in a happier climate clear and exhilarating.”

The trouble is that a constant cause can’t explain a changing effect. The same place can support very different kinds of sculpture at different times, so climate can tell us little on its own about why a style changes. Pater’s own chapter supplies a counterexample too, since the same Greek religion had its “mournful mysteries” and its wandering beggar-priests under that same delicate air, and climate can tell you why marble weathers as it does in Attica without telling you why the fifth century looked so different from the seventh.

The third condition is the body, “the finer lime and clay of the human form,” with its “dainty framework of the human countenance.” As history this runs into a circle, because most of our evidence for the perfect Greek physique is the statues themselves, and using idealized sculpture to prove the population was beautiful is like judging a city’s looks from its billboards. Athletic training shaped the bodies some sculptors had a chance to see, but the sculptor’s job was to select and improve, which Pater himself says a few pages later when he describes art “selecting, transforming, recombining the images it transmits.”

That leaves the Mothers, the strangest piece of the explanation and maybe the smartest. In the second part of Goethe’s Faust, Mephistopheles describes the Mothers as goddesses beyond familiar space and time. They are associated with form and transformation. Pater has them “preside, at the beginning of Greek culture, over such a concourse of happy physical conditions as ever generates by natural laws some rare type of intellectual or spiritual life.” Notice the double move, since the Mothers stand for natural law and also for the luck of a rare conjunction, and Pater needs both, because no list of conditions adds up to the Parthenon on its own.

The fair defense of Pater is that he calls these elements “conditions” and still leaves room for “supreme good luck.” Nobody has a settled explanation for why genius clusters in fifth-century Athens or fifteenth-century Florence, and the honest accounts all end with some version of good fortune. Pater says “supreme good luck” right in the middle of his main sentence, which hands the reader the tool needed to test everything around it.

So my verdict is that Pater’s weather report holds up unevenly. The pause in reflection is the most defensible claim once it’s read as a point about the fit between thought and form, the physique claim leans on its own evidence in a circle, and the climate claim is the weakest, since it offers a constant cause for an effect that came and went. The Mothers are the most honest piece, because they mark the place where explanation runs out, and Pater’s account works best as a list of ingredients for a dish whose cooking remains a mystery, which is where the honest historians of golden ages still leave it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider climate the weakest part of Pater’s explanation?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.