Renaissance

The Wall That Venetian Painting Keeps Remembering

Pater traces Venetian painting back to the gold and marble of church interiors. Bellini’s painted apse shows how a picture could carry the look of a wall with it.

Murano’s mosaics and Saint Mark’s colored surfaces help explain why Pater treats decoration as central to Venetian painting. His contrast with Florence shows both the reach and the limits of that idea.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The gold of the apsePater begins with the marble and gold surfaces of Murano and Saint Mark’s, where color is part of the building.
  • A painted wall inside a pictureBellini’s San Giobbe altarpiece creates the illusion of a church apse with paint.
  • Pater’s contrast with FlorencePater casts Florence as a school of intellectual burdens and Venice as one of color and surface. That contrast is deliberately broad.
  • What survives the moveIn Pater’s history, the Venetian eye for color and place survives when a painted image can be moved away from the wall.

Walk into the basilica of Santi Maria e Donato on Murano and you can see a tall Virgin standing alone in the apse against a field of gold, with a patterned mosaic floor under your feet that looks like a carpet someone forgot to roll up. That’s the place where Pater starts his history of Venetian painting. Venetian painting, he says, links itself to “the last, stiff, half-barbaric splendours of Byzantine decoration,” and it begins as nothing grander than “the introduction into the crust of marble and gold on the walls of the Duomo of Murano, or of Saint Mark’s, of a little more of human expression.” The Duomo is Murano’s former cathedral, and Pater’s claim is that a whole school of painting began as a slight warming of faces on a jeweled wall.

The word “crust” has a history of its own behind it. Ruskin had argued in The Stones of Venice that Saint Mark’s is the purest Italian example of a style in which the ruling principle is “the incrustation of brick with more precious materials,” a brick body dressed in marble the way an animal wears its skin, and he’d insisted this was honest building, not cheap veneer. Pater takes that picture over and adds a twist, because if the church is a brick body in a precious skin, then Venetian painting starts life as one more layer of the skin. It’s less like a picture hung on a wall than like a tattoo, part of the surface it decorates and impossible to imagine anywhere else. Ruskin had even said as much in his own way, writing that Venice’s great painters at last created for her “a color more priceless than gold or porphyry,” as if the painting were the wall’s final and most precious coat.

Pater’s bigger claim is that the school never got over its birthplace. Its work was “always subordinate to architectural effect,” he says, and its painters never forgot “that painting must be before all things decorative, a thing for the eye, a space of colour on the wall, only more dexterously blent than the marking of its precious stone.” Anyone who has stood in Saint Mark’s knows what he means by that marking, since the marble slabs there are sawn and opened like a book so their veins make mirror patterns, a kind of painting done by geology. You can see the memory in Giovanni Bellini, whose San Giobbe altarpiece places the Virgin and saints in an illusionistic apse. The painting makes an interior that resembles the kind of space it was made for. Even in the sixteenth century some of Saint Mark’s mosaics followed designs by painters including Titian, as if the wall kept calling its children home.

Then comes the comparison that turns decoration into history. Venetian painting, he says, was “unassisted, and therefore unperplexed, by naturalism, religious mysticism, philosophical theories,” and so “it had no Giotto, no Angelico, no Botticelli.” Each name is pinned to a burden, Giotto to the hard work of making painted people look solid and real, Fra Angelico to visionary piety, Botticelli to the Neoplatonic theorizing of Medici Florence, and Pater says the Venetians were “exempt from the stress of thought and sentiment, which taxed so severely the resources of the generations of Florentine artists.” Florence packed for a long expedition with a heavy backpack of ideas, while Venice traveled light and kept its eyes on the color.

That contrast does real work in Pater’s larger argument. It explains why Venice, coming late, could produce in Giorgione a painter who seems to have understood his art all at once, since the decorative habit had kept the “essential limitations” of painting in view for centuries while Florentines were busy wrestling with anatomy and allegory. It also sets up the next turn in Pater’s story, where Giorgione lifts these spaces of color off the wall and makes them portable. So the history has a shape like a life, with painting born on the wall, raised under its discipline, and finally old enough to leave home.

The trouble is that “unperplexed” is a stretch, and Venice knew it. Bellini’s altarpieces gave devotion a place in Venetian painting. Carpaccio painted a sequence of canvases for the confraternity of Saint Ursula, telling her story from the embassy that arranges her marriage to the martyrdom and its aftermath. A city like that wasn’t free of philosophy, mysticism or story, and Pater’s own sentence quietly admits as much, allowing that “higher matter of thought, or poetry, or religious reverie” could play its part “between” the decorative beginning and the decorative end.

That admission points toward a better reading of the contrast. The difference between the two cities was where the thought went once it arrived. Read as a comparison of ways to paint, Pater’s distinction prompts a question about where ideas are made visible. A Botticelli can invite the viewer to follow an intricate story or program. A Bellini Madonna can give a sense of devotion through the space around her and the light that falls on the figures. The wall worked as a discipline, since any idea that wanted into a Venetian picture had to survive being turned into “a space of colour,” if the viewer was to encounter it through the eye.

So Pater’s Florence is a caricature as a history of ideas but a sharp insight as a history of a medium. Venice had its thinkers and its mystics like any other great city, and his “no Giotto, no Angelico, no Botticelli” can’t be taken literally as an account of what Venetians believed. What he gets right is the habit of eye that the jeweled wall trained into its painters, a habit of treating a picture first as color fitted to a place, and I think that’s the wall Venetian painting keeps remembering, the condition under which its thought had to become visible to count at all.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article describe Bellini’s San Giobbe altarpiece as remembering Venetian painting’s architectural origins?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.