Renaissance

The Tree That Waits Out the Frost

Pater takes a mulberry tree as a sign of Ludovico Sforza’s patience. Leonardo painted the same tree across a Milanese hall, where the emblem tells a different story.

Pliny’s late-budding mulberry and Leonardo’s painted canopy help distinguish how the Sforza court presented itself from how its ruler acted.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A tree that waitsPliny calls the mulberry wise because it delays budding until the cold has passed.
  • A ruler’s emblemPater reads Ludovico’s mulberry as a claim to patience and decisive action, a claim the collapse of his rule puts in doubt.
  • A painted canopyLeonardo turned the court’s emblem into an entire room of interlaced mulberry branches at the Sforza castle.
  • A city with problemsThe cathedral model and two-level streets show Leonardo applying practical questions to the Milan that Pater describes as dreamlike.

Pater introduces Leonardo’s new patron with a sentence that packs a whole reign into a few lines. Pater calls Ludovico Sforza the man “who murdered his young nephew by slow poison,” repeating an unproven accusation. He also says the ruler combined earthly passion with “a sort of religious sentimentalism” and “took for his device the mulberry-tree,” which Pater reads as a “symbol, in its long delay and sudden yielding of flowers and fruit together, of a wisdom which economises all forces for an opportunity of sudden and sure effect.” It’s a brilliant piece of compression, a ruler summed up in his logo the way you might sum up a tech founder by the company emblem on his hoodie, and it’s worth asking what the logo was selling, because Pater uses it as the doorway into Leonardo’s Milan.

The emblem had an ancient pedigree that Ludovico’s courtiers knew well. Pliny says the mulberry is the last of the cultivated trees to bud, never before the cold weather is over, which is why it was called the wisest of trees, and that when it finally does bud, it does the whole job in a single night, so violently that you can hear it. Moro could name the mulberry as well as mean “Moor,” so Ludovico’s nickname readily became a visual pun. The mulberry also fed silkworms, and Ludovico encouraged planting it across Lombardy for the silk trade, so the device was a pun, a boast of political patience and an advertisement for the duchy’s economy all at once.

Set beside the actual career, the boast looks shaky. Pater himself calls Ludovico’s spirit “capricious” later in the same paragraph, and the record bears him out. His nephew Gian Galeazzo, the rightful duke, died in 1494 at twenty-five, and rumors of poison went around at once, though nothing was ever proved and Pater states it as fact. Ludovico became duke within days, and that same year he encouraged Charles VIII of France to march into Italy, a sudden effect that turned on him five years later when Louis XII took Milan. He came back briefly in 1500, was betrayed and captured at Novara, and died a prisoner in the castle of Loches in 1508. The wise tree, in other words, got caught by the frost.

So why does Pater give the emblem such a prominent place? I think the answer is that it describes the court better than the man. Milan under Ludovico ran on devices, mottoes and staged surprises, “a life of brilliant sins and exquisite amusements,” in Pater’s phrase, and it’s no accident that Leonardo eventually built the emblem with his own hands. In 1498 he began painting a large hall in the Castello Sforzesco, the Sforza castle, as a pergola of mulberry trees, their branches knotted together with golden cord around the arms of the Sforza and Este families, and the room was known as the camera de’ moroni, the mulberry room. A letter of April 1498 has him promising to finish it by September, and a year and a half later the French were in the castle.

Pater then turns to the city, and here his portrait gets dreamier. “The Duomo, work of artists from beyond the Alps,” he writes, was “so fantastic to the eye of a Florentine used to the mellow, unbroken surfaces of Giotto and Arnolfo,” and in the streets below “moved a people as fantastic, changeful, and dreamlike.” The cathedral was a Lombard undertaking to which builders and engineers from beyond the Alps also contributed, and the contrast makes a point, since the forest of pinnacles really did look foreign next to Florence’s flat marble skins. What’s interesting is how Leonardo actually responded to it, because in 1487 he entered the competition for the cathedral’s crossing tower, had a carpenter build a wooden model, and drafted a letter comparing the ailing building to a patient who needs a doctor-architect who understands its nature.

Leonardo’s plans for streets are similarly practical. In the years after a serious outbreak of plague in Milan, he sketched a city on two levels in Manuscript B, with upper streets where no carts were allowed and lower streets for carts and goods, canals running under the houses for deliveries and drainage, and a rule that “the width of the streets be equal to the average height of the houses.” He even specified that the high streets were “exclusively for the use of gentlemen,” which tells you whose comfort he had in mind. Where Pater sees a dreamlike crowd drifting under fantastic spires, Leonardo’s plans separate different kinds of traffic and carry goods and waste by water.

That contrast tells us what the miniature portrait contributes and where it misleads. It gives the change of scene a tempo and a tone, moving us from a city of mellow surfaces to a court of emblems and surprises, a theater where a charmer could flourish, and that’s true to much of what Leonardo did there. But Pater adds that “to Leonardo least of all men could there be anything poisonous in the exotic flowers of sentiment which grew there,” which makes him one more exotic flower in the hothouse. The cathedral model and the two-level city show a man taking Milan’s measure, treating its strangeness as a set of problems to solve.

My verdict is that the mulberry sentence is a superb miniature of a court’s image of itself and a poor portrait of its owner. Ludovico was the capricious one, and the tree was his advertisement, borrowed from Pliny and planted for profit. The person in Milan who really did economize his forces for a sure effect was the engineer drawing streets as wide as the houses were high and the painter who turned the duke’s advertisement into a room. Keep the emblem, then, as a picture of Milanese taste and of the theater Leonardo was hired to dress, and let go of it as evidence of Ludovico’s wisdom, which his loss of Milan puts in doubt.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why was the mulberry especially effective as Ludovico’s emblem, according to the article?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.