Renaissance

The Tears in a Theatre and the Pain of a Friendship

Winckelmann compares the beauty of art to tears at a play. Pater puts beside it the less manageable feelings of the friendships that helped form his eye.

An audience can feel sorrow without suffering a character’s loss. Pater asks what happens when a person’s very different experience of living beauty carries over into how they look at a work.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A comparison from the theatreWinckelmann says the beauty of art needs cultivation and compares its effect to tears shed at a play.
  • The pain outside the workPater brings in letters from a friendship that began formally and ended in anger, giving living beauty consequences that a statue cannot have.
  • What sharpens the eyePater thinks strong attachment can make a person attend to small differences of colour and form that might otherwise escape them.
  • Two kinds of evidenceThe controlled language of the art history and the volatile letters reveal different parts of the life Pater is trying to describe.

Winckelmann’s essay on taste contains one especially striking comparison. “The beauty of art demands a higher sensibility than the beauty of nature,” he writes, “because the beauty of art, like tears shed at a play, gives no pain, is without life, and must be awakened and repaired by culture.” The point is that living beauty works on us automatically, through desire and circumstance, while the beauty of a statue has no life of its own to stir us and so needs a trained viewer to bring it alive. Tears at a play are real tears, although the child or the kingdom lost in the story belongs to somebody on the stage.

The comparison draws on an old puzzle in the philosophy of art. Augustine asked in his Confessions why a spectator wants to grieve over things they would never choose to suffer. David Hume returned to the question in “Of Tragedy” in 1757. Aristotle’s Poetics had already remarked on the pleasure of seeing representations of things that can be painful to see in life. Winckelmann’s answer is implicit in his phrase, since art lets us feel without being harmed, and that safety is what makes contemplation possible. You can weep at a film and still have enough distance to attend to the way the scene is made. That distance does some of the work in Winckelmann’s comparison.

Pater picks up the phrase and turns it against its author’s life. “Certainly, of that beauty of living form which regulated Winckelmann’s friendships, it could not be said that it gave no pain.” He then gives the evidence, “One notable friendship, the fortune of which we may trace through his letters, begins with an antique, chivalrous letter in French, and ends noisily in a burst of angry fire.” The beauty of art may be like tears at a play, but the beauty of living people produced real tears, quarrels and wounds, and Winckelmann’s letters, Pater says, are full of their “troubled colouring.”

Pater doesn’t simply set the two kinds of beauty against each other, though. “Far from reaching the quietism, the bland indifference of art, such attachments are nevertheless more susceptible than any others of equal strength of a purely intellectual culture.” Of passion, he says, “they contain only just so much as stimulates the eye to the finest delicacies of colour and form.” In other words the painful friendships were also a school of perception, since the intensity of looking at a beloved face sharpened the eye that would later look at marble, and the pain and the close attention belonged to the same experience. It’s the logic of every apprenticeship that hurts, the musician’s aching hands or the athlete’s sore body, applied to the most private kind of education.

That’s where the two passages give art and living form different kinds of consequence. In Winckelmann’s comparison, art works on a sensibility that can be “awakened and repaired” without the loss the spectator watches. Living form’s consequence is external and risky, a matter of hopes raised and disappointed, letters written and regretted, and partings that leave the lover with “no hope of seeing you again.” One changes the viewer by refining him, and the other changes him by exposing him, so looking can have quite different consequences when the subject can look back.

Pater’s phrase “only just so much” deserves some skepticism. It’s the language of a Victorian critic keeping a delicate subject within bounds, holding the reader’s attention on what these attachments did for the eye. His own account of the “burst of angry fire” suggests they had consequences beyond that. The letter that opens in an “antique, chivalrous” manner, and in French, is itself a kind of theater, a role borrowed from the old romances, and its “burst of angry fire” is what happens when the play stops being a play. Pater knows it, which is why he calls the letters “an instructive but bizarre addition to the History of Art,” a turbulent annex to “that shrine of grave and mellow light around the mute Olympian family.”

That image of the shrine is the best summary of the relationship. The History of Ancient Art is a temple of calm, its gods mute and its light mellow, and beside it stand the letters, noisy and colored and full of pain. The calm of the temple was built, at least in part, by a man whose life was anything but calm, and the serenity Winckelmann found in Greek sculpture may have been so precious to him precisely because his own attachments gave him so little of it. Tears at a play are painless partly because we’ve already shed real ones, and the theater’s safety means most to those who have known the danger.

My verdict is that the two passages assign art and living form opposite consequences and then show them working together, since art’s painless beauty cultivates a sensibility while the attachments Pater describes could sharpen an eye that would later look at art. Winckelmann’s comparison with tears at a play is exact about what art offers, safety for contemplation, and Pater’s reply is exact about what made Winckelmann able to use that safety so well. The shrine of mellow light and the letters full of fire belong to the same life, and each helps explain the other, the calm made more valuable by the storm and the storm made more fruitful by the calm.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does Winckelmann claim that appreciating art requires a higher sensibility than appreciating living beauty?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.