Philosophy

The Studio Audience

With the whole gym watching, admitting confusion becomes part of the test.

The Charmides looks like an intimate conversation, but it happens in a packed gym with people watching every move. Plato makes the crowd part of the argument, and he knew better than anyone what a crowd could do to a philosopher.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The room is watchingThe crowd greets Socrates, stares at Charmides, and closes in as the questioning begins.
  • Critias takes overCharmides lets his guardian take the blame for a borrowed definition. Eager to shine in front of the room, Critias steps into the argument.
  • A way past embarrassmentWhen Critias tries to hide his confusion, Socrates grants a point provisionally to keep the inquiry moving.
  • An echo at the trialIn the Apology, Socrates says young listeners copied his examinations and that the people they questioned blamed him.

Charmides 153b, 154c, 155c–d, 162b–d, 169c–d · Apology 23c–d

It’s easy to read the Charmides as a conversation among three people, Socrates, the boy and his guardian, but nobody in it is ever alone. The crowd is there from the first lines, when the regulars spot Socrates and start “greeting me at once from across the room, from every side,” and it never really leaves. It stares at Charmides when he walks in, it laughs at the scramble for a seat, and it comes “swirling round us in a ring” just as the conversation is about to begin, so that every word that follows is spoken in front of an audience that never says a word itself.

Think of it as a studio audience, the kind that sits in the bleachers of a talk show and never gets a line but changes everything about how the guests behave. Nobody on stage forgets they’re there, and the guests start playing to the room, timing their jokes, protecting their dignity, saying things they wouldn’t say over coffee. Put somebody on a podcast taped in front of a live crowd and the guest who’d happily say “I don’t know” in private suddenly finds a confident answer, because the room is listening and nobody wants to look slow. Plato gives us a version of that in the Charmides, and once you start watching for the audience, you notice how much of the argument is shaped by the fact that people are watching it.

Charmides is the first to feel it, and the first to use it. When his borrowed definition, that temperance is “doing one’s own business,” starts going badly, he doesn’t defend it or drop it. Instead he laughs “slyly and looked across at Critias,” and then, Socrates tells us, he “kept prodding him, and made out that he had been refuted,” which is a teenager working a crowd, pinning the failure on the man who taught him the line and doing it in public, where the guardian can’t ignore it. The kid who blushed when asked about himself turns out to know exactly how an audience works.

Critias takes the bait, and Socrates explains why in terms that are all about the room. Critias “had plainly been on edge for some time, and eager to shine before Charmides and the company,” and he’d been holding himself back until he couldn’t anymore. Socrates then reaches for a theater image, saying Critias seemed as angry with Charmides “as a poet is with an actor who makes a mess of the poet’s own verses.” That’s Plato telling us straight out that the argument has turned into a performance, with an author, an actor and a house full of spectators, and the author is about to step onto the stage himself.

From then on the audience works like pressure in a pipe. Critias’ definitions get grander as he goes, which is what happens when you’re trying to impress a room, and when the questions finally corner him, the crowd is the reason he can’t admit it, since he was ashamed in front of the company and kept covering up his confusion. The interesting move here is Socrates’, because instead of pressing his advantage in front of everyone, he says, “to keep our argument moving,” that they can grant Critias’ point “for now” and look into it again another time. It keeps the inquiry going, and it also happens to let a proud man off the hook in front of the people he was trying to impress.

Plato had good reason to take crowds seriously, because in the Apology Socrates explains that young men with time on their hands used to follow him around because they enjoyed watching people get examined, and then went off and examined people themselves, while the people examined got angry, not at themselves, but at Socrates, and he traces the prejudice that finally brought him to trial to exactly that resentment. A public examination is a spectacle, and a spectacle produces winners, losers and grudges, which is exactly the dynamic we watch building in the Charmides, with an audience that enjoys the show and a powerful man who gets embarrassed in front of it.

So the audience is a lot more than scenery, since it’s the reason embarrassment and the wish to impress become part of the argument’s working conditions, and it turns the dialogue into a test of character as well as a test of definitions. Charmides plays the room, Critias performs for it and then hides from it, and Socrates is the only person on stage who doesn’t seem to care how he looks, which is why he can admit he’s at a loss when he is and why he can afford to be generous when Critias is.

My verdict is that Plato builds the crowd into the Charmides to show both edges of doing philosophy in public. A watching room makes people honest in one way, because there’s nowhere to hide a bad answer, and dishonest in another, because there’s every reason to cover one up, and the dialogue’s best picture of temperance in action is a man who can think clearly while being watched without either showing off or shutting down. Plato wrote knowing where public examinations had led Socrates in the end, and the studio audience in the gym is a reminder that the same crowd that loves the show can also come to resent the man who puts it on.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does Charmides’ reaction to his failing definition reveal about his relationship to the audience?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.