Philosophy
The Statue Opens Its Mouth
A room full of admirers sees a statue. Socrates asks how to get to know the person they’re staring at.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe boys in the gym stare at Charmides as if he were the statue of a god, and nobody says a word. Plato has a favorite thing to do with statues, and the Charmides does it when the boy begins asking questions.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Like a statueEven the youngest boys watch Charmides as if he were a statue. The image makes their admiration feel distant and one-way.
- What a statue can hideIn the Symposium, Alcibiades compares Socrates to a figure of Silenus that opens to reveal divine images. He says opening up Socrates reveals temperance.
- The boy speaksCharmides asks about a headache remedy. The scene shifts from the room staring at him to two people talking.
- The risk of talkingOnce Charmides joins the discussion, he can blush, hesitate, and change his mind. The inquiry gives him a chance to find out what he thinks temperance is.
When Charmides walks into the wrestling-school, Socrates notices something stranger than the grown men falling over themselves. He watches the boys and finds that not one of them is looking anywhere else, “not even the littlest,” because “they were all gazing at him as if he were a statue.” The Greek word is agalma, which comes from a verb meaning to glorify or take delight in, and which came to mean an offering that delights a god and above all the statue of a god in a temple, so the stare Socrates describes is closer to worship than to a crush.
Think about what that comparison makes visible, about the people doing the looking as much as about the boy. A statue gets looked at and never looks back, and the people admiring it stand at a distance, quiet, the way you stand behind the rope at a museum. Nobody expects a statue to have opinions, and nobody worries that it might say something dumb, which is exactly what makes this kind of admiration so total and so safe. Statues also don’t age, don’t have bad days and don’t change their minds, so the admirer can keep his picture of them perfectly intact. It’s the admiration you feel for a face on a poster or an account you follow but have never talked to, and it depends on the admired person staying silent, because the moment he speaks he can disappoint you.
Plato has a favorite trick with statues, and it helps to know it. In the Symposium, a drunk Alcibiades compares Socrates to the little figures of Silenus sold in sculptors’ shops, ugly on the outside but made to open up and reveal images of gods inside, and the word he uses for those hidden images is agalmata, the same word as in the Charmides. When Alcibiades describes what he found inside Socrates, he says the man is full of, of all things, sōphrosynē, temperance, the very virtue the Charmides is about to hunt for.
Put the two scenes side by side and they run in opposite directions. In the Symposium we have an ugly statue with temperance packed inside it, and in the Charmides we have a gorgeous statue whose inside nobody has checked. The whole room has agreed that the outside is perfect, and the question Socrates raises almost immediately is the one Alcibiades answered about him, whether there’s anything divine inside the beautiful casing or whether the boy is all surface. Plato’s readers would also have caught the irony that the one man in the gym whose inside had already been checked and found full of temperance was the funny-looking one on the bench, not the beauty everyone was staring at.
The way to open this statue is to get it talking. Socrates’ plan is to look at the boy’s soul before his body, and his reason for thinking it can be done is simple, since “at his age he must surely be willing to have a conversation.” A statue can be admired from across a room, but a soul can only be inspected by someone close enough to talk to it, so the proposal is really a plan to move Charmides out of the category of things you stare at and into the category of people you speak with.
The moment it happens is easy to miss, because it comes right after the slapstick on the bench and Socrates’ near meltdown. Charmides sits down, Socrates tells him there’s a remedy for his headache, and the boy’s first directly quoted words are a question, “So what is it?” The statue opens its mouth, and the first thing it does is ask for something, which is precisely what statues never do, since a statue receives offerings and stares and never needs anything from anyone. With one short question the relationship flips from admirer and object to two people, one of whom wants to know something the other might have. It’s the move Socrates makes in dialogue after dialogue, where he refuses to treat anyone, a famous general or a celebrated sophist, as a monument to be admired, and insists on treating him as a person who can be asked a question.
Speaking costs Charmides his perfection, and the dialogue doesn’t hide the price. Once he talks he can blush, hesitate, borrow a line from his guardian and watch it fall apart, all things a statue is spared, and the crowd’s silent worship can’t survive any of them. A little later he’ll even laugh slyly and shoot a look at his guardian to dodge the blame for a bad answer, which is about as far from marble as a person can get. But speaking also gives him something no statue can have, which is the chance to get better, since a marble figure is finished the day it leaves the workshop, while a young man who has just discovered he can’t define temperance has somewhere to go. It’s the difference between idolizing someone you’ve only seen in pictures and actually getting to know them, where you lose the fantasy and gain the person.
My verdict is that the statue comparison shows admiration at its most comfortable, silent, distant and one-way, and that the dialogue’s first real move is to break it. Socrates turns the boy everyone was worshipping into somebody who asks and answers, which is the only way to find out whether there’s anything like temperance inside him. The Charmides never quite settles that question, and that’s the honest result of treating someone as a person rather than a statue, because people, unlike statues, are never finished.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What central contrast emerges when the article places the statue imagery in the Symposium beside that in the Charmides?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Why might admiration feel safer when the admired person remains distant and silent, and what does that safety prevent the admirer from learning?→
- If conversation destroys an idealized image but reveals a real person, what responsibilities do the speaker and listener have toward each other?→
- Does the dialogue’s failure to settle whether Charmides possesses temperance weaken the inquiry, or does uncertainty better reflect what it means to know a person?→