Renaissance
The Small Silk Figure on Titian’s Big Staircase
Pater finds childlike humor in the Virgin’s climb up Titian’s monumental steps. Her size and position make a familiar sacred story feel newly observed.
The Renaissance (1893)The Presentation of the Virgin and Bacchus and Ariadne show how Titian creates humor and drama by deciding where to put a figure and when to arrest its motion.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A small figure in a large roomThe Virgin as a child climbs an enormous painted stair in a canvas made for the room where it still hangs.
- A detail Pater calls humorousThe distance between the tiny girl and the adult scale of her surroundings gives the solemn scene an unexpected note.
- A different kind of movementIn Bacchus and Ariadne, Titian suspends a leap between the departing ship and the constellation that points to Ariadne’s future.
- Poetry made by paintingScale, placement and timing give the two stories effects that come through Titian’s arrangement of figures and color.
The Renaissance · Pater on the gradations from fan painting to Titian · Diotimos editorial note on Bacchus and Ariadne · Diotimos editorial note on the Presentation of the Virgin · Titian’s Presentation of the Virgin, Gallerie dell’Accademia · The Golden Legend on Mary climbing the steps · Titian’s Bacchus and Ariadne, National Gallery
Right after telling you that a picture should first please the eye like colored glass, Pater builds a ladder to show how poetry gets into painting “by fine gradations upwards.” The bottom rung is “Japanese fan-painting,” where “we get, first, only abstract colour,” then “just a little interfused sense of the poetry of flowers,” then “perfect flower-painting,” and so on up to Titian. Pater starts with a kind of object that had become familiar amid London’s 1870s interest in Japanese art. You’d expect something grand at the top, a battle or a martyrdom, and instead Pater gives you two things, the “poetry” of Titian’s Ariadne and “a touch of true childlike humour in the diminutive, quaint figure with its silk gown, which ascends the temple stairs” in the Presentation of the Virgin in Venice.
The Presentation is huge, more than twenty-five feet long, and it still hangs on the wall it was made for. Titian painted it between 1534 and 1538 for the room where the officers of the Scuola Grande della Carità, the Great Confraternity of Charity, held their meetings, in a building that’s now part of the Accademia, and he fitted his painted stonework over a real door so neatly that the doorframe looks like part of the picture. A second door was cut through the canvas in 1572, a practical alteration to a painting fitted into the room. A long procession of Venetian worthies moves from left to right toward a monumental staircase, and partway up, all by herself in a pale blue dress with a glow of light around her, is the child.
The story comes from the old legends about Mary’s childhood, retold in the medieval Golden Legend, where her parents bring her to the temple at three years old and she climbs the steps without anyone’s help, which the storytellers took as a sign of what she’d become. Titian keeps that point and makes it visible through nothing but size and placement, so the stairs are built for adults, the crowd is made of grown-ups in heavy robes, and the person the whole event is about is tiny next to all of them. It’s like watching a kindergartner cross the stage at a huge graduation to collect her certificate while the whole auditorium holds its breath, totally serious about it and slightly ridiculous at the same time, and that mix is what Pater means by “quaint.”
Titian adds a figure who makes the joke land. At the foot of the staircase, in the foreground and drawn on a much bigger scale than the child, an old woman sits with a basket of eggs, looking the opposite way from the procession, as if the miracle going on behind her were none of her business. Whatever symbolic meaning the figure may have, her place in the composition gives us a different scale for looking at the child. She’s a heavy, earthbound body facing away, and next to her the little girl in silk looks even lighter and more determined, climbing toward something the old woman won’t turn around to see.
Pater’s other example, the Bacchus and Ariadne, works on a different axis. Painted in 1520–23 for Alfonso d’Este’s private rooms in Ferrara and now in London, it catches the instant Bacchus first sees Ariadne, abandoned on the island of Naxos, and leaps from his chariot toward her, so that he hangs in the air above the ground with his cloak flying while she turns in a startled gesture. Theseus’s ship is sailing off in the distance on the left, and up in the sky her crown is already a ring of stars, which is how the story ends, so before, now and after all fit into a single frame without anybody having to explain them. What Pater means by “poetry” here is poetry of timing, the painter choosing the one split second, like a photo snapped at the top of a jump, that holds the whole story.
Side by side, the two pictures get their effects in opposite ways. The Ariadne squeezes time, packing a before and an after into one suspended moment, while the Presentation stretches space, laying a long procession across a whole wall so that the event at its center looks small and touching. One gives you poetry and the other gives you humor, and both come from decisions only a painter can make, about how big to make a body, where to set it and which instant to stop the clock. That’s the real claim folded into Pater’s ladder, that the poetry at the top hasn’t been imported from a book, because it grows from the same handling of size and color that the fan painter works with at the bottom.
You could push back and say the humor is in the story rather than the painting, because the Golden Legend already has a three-year-old marching up the temple steps alone, and any medium could make that cute. The ladder can also look like a pecking order, with Japanese fans at the bottom and Titian at the top, which says more about Victorian taste than about Japanese art, since fan painters weren’t failing to become Titian. The second point is fair, and I’d read the ladder as a ramp of possibilities inside painting rather than a ranking of cultures. The story supplies the unaided climb. The scale of the stair and the woman at its foot give that climb its particular comic touch in Titian’s painting.
So the small silk figure is Pater’s best evidence for his own theory, better than the grander Ariadne, because humor seems like the most literary of effects, the kind of thing you’d expect a story to supply, and here it comes straight out of scale and placement. The story in these pictures emerges from pictorial decisions rather than arriving ready-made from a text, which means the top of Pater’s ladder is built from the same stuff as its bottom rung. My verdict is that Pater picked exactly the right detail, a little girl in a silk dress who is funny and holy at once because of how small she looks against the architecture and the watching adults.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, how does Titian make Mary’s unaided climb feel both serious and faintly comic in the Presentation?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Does interpreting Pater’s ladder as a range of possibilities within painting adequately answer the concern that it places Japanese art below European art? Why or why not?→
- How does the old woman’s refusal to look at the procession affect your understanding of Mary’s smallness, determination, or holiness?→
- If the Golden Legend already supplies the image of a three-year-old climbing alone, what part of the Presentation’s humor belongs specifically to Titian’s pictorial decisions?→