Renaissance

The Slow Water by the Bank

Pater uses one river for the slow changes of a body and the quick changes of thought. William James’s account of attention gives the mind a quieter current of its own.

The eye and the wall fade at the bank while glimpses and thoughts race midstream. The difference helps explain Pater’s impatience with habit and where that impatience runs into trouble.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The body changes at the shorePater pairs the aging eye with fading color on a wall to show changes slow enough to pass for stillness.
  • Thought moves faster in the same riverQuick changes of sight, feeling and thought occupy the middle of the same current.
  • The revision slows down the sentencePater repeats “gradual” and makes “movement” plural in 1893, letting readers notice the changes separately.
  • The mind has resting places tooWilliam James’s image of flights and perchings makes room for the settled attention that can teach us to notice a fleeting difference.

Stand on a riverbank on a calm afternoon and look at the water right by your feet, where a leaf barely drifts and the surface looks almost still, and then look thirty feet out, where the same river is plainly racing. That isn’t an illusion, since friction with the bank and the bed really does slow the water at the edges, so a single current can move at two speeds at once. Pater uses that picture to carry his whole essay across from the body to the mind, and he announces the crossing with a comparative, saying that “if we begin with the inward world of thought and feeling, the whirlpool is still more rapid, the flame more eager and devouring.”

The slow water belongs to the body and its surroundings, “the gradual darkening of the eye, the gradual fading of colour from the wall,” which Pater calls “movements of the shore-side, where the water flows down indeed, though in apparent rest.” The fast water belongs to the mind, “the race of the mid-stream, a drift of momentary acts of sight and passion and thought.” Both examples on the shore are changes you only notice across years, the way a parent can’t see a kid growing day by day and then gets ambushed by a photo from last summer, while the midstream is the stuff of seconds, a glance or a pang or a thought that’s gone before you can name it.

Look closely at the slow examples, because they have something odd in common. The eye darkening is the instrument of sight wearing out with age, and the color fading from the wall is the thing seen wearing out in the light, so both shore-side changes are about seeing, the organ and its object dimming together. Meanwhile the fast changes are “acts of sight” among others, so vision sits on both banks of the river at once. That’s where the passage gets its quiet sadness, since you’re spending a slowly failing instrument on quick moments, and the eye that catches the bright second is itself running down at the speed of the shore.

The reason for keeping one river instead of two is philosophical, and it’s smart. Pater never says the mind is a different kind of thing from the body, a ghost riding a machine, and he never says it’s simply the same thing either, because his grammar is the grammar of degree, where the whirlpool is “still more rapid” and the flame “more eager.” The metaphor puts the mind in the fast region of the same current. It gives Pater one image for both kinds of change and leaves room for how differently they feel. It’s an elegant dodge between the materialists and their opponents, done with nothing but a comparative adjective and a river.

The revision of 1893 sharpens the contrast in a small way. In 1873 Pater wrote of “the gradual darkening of the eye and fading of colour from the wall,” calling it “the movement of the shore side,” and in the final text he repeats the word “gradual” before the fading and turns the single movement into plural “movements.” The repeated word slows the shore down even further, like a film editor stretching a shot, and the plural suggests many slow changes going on at once around us, the way a whole house ages in a hundred places nobody is watching. The midstream, by contrast, needed no adjustment, because the point of it was already its rush.

William James found two speeds within the mind itself. In an 1884 essay he describes “the different pace of its different portions,” and compares mental life to a bird’s alternating flights and perchings. He develops the same image in The Principles of Psychology (1890). James’s perchings are the resting places of thought, a clear image or a settled word, and his flights are the transitions between them. Pater puts the body and the wall on the slow side of his comparison. In this passage the mind appears as a “drift of momentary acts.”

That’s where the river image turns into a value judgment that I think goes too far. A few paragraphs on, Pater says that “In a sense it might even be said that our failure is to form habits,” and habit is exactly the mind’s slow water, the shore-side of thinking where things settle into grooves. The warning puts a premium on the mind’s ability to stay out in the race. But some of the mind’s best possessions move slowly, like a skill built over years, a long friendship, or a grief that changes shape across a decade, and those slow things are what make a fast moment recognizable at all, since you can’t hear that one tone is “choicer than the rest” without a slowly trained ear to hear it with.

The two-speed river is one of the most exact images in the Conclusion, accurate to how water moves and to how a life feels, with the body aging at the pace of the bank and attention racing in the middle. Keeping one current for both lets Pater avoid splitting the self in two, and that’s a real philosophical gain. The image has room for more than Pater makes of its slow water, when the mind has banks of its own, James’s perchings, and those quiet places are where the fast water is learned. The river itself is wiser than the hurry Pater builds on it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider Pater’s use of one river, rather than two separate rivers, philosophically significant?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.