Philosophy

The Siege Socrates Came Home From

How a city caught between Athens and Corinth helped draw Sparta into war.

The Charmides opens with Socrates fresh from the army at Potidaea, and Plato assumes you know what that means. Here’s the story his first readers already knew, from the quarrel that lit the fuse to the siege that cost Athens two thousand talents.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Divided loyaltiesPotidaea paid tribute to Athens while Corinth still sent its magistrates. When Athens demanded that the city break those ties, Potidaea revolted in 432 BCE.
  • The cost of the siegeAthens besieged Potidaea by land and sea until famine forced its surrender. Thucydides puts the cost to Athens at 2,000 talents.
  • The road to warCorinth pressed Sparta to act over Potidaea. Thucydides saw Sparta’s fear of Athens’ growing power as the deeper cause of the war that began in 431 BCE.
  • Socrates comes homePlato opens the Charmides with Socrates back from Potidaea. The campaign gives weight to his dry reply when Chaerephon asks how he survived the fighting.

The first line of the Charmides has Socrates back from “the army at Potidaea,” and Plato drops the name the way a novelist might open with a character just home from Saigon, trusting that the reader will feel the weight of it without a history lesson. Plato’s first readers certainly felt it, because Potidaea was where the great war between Athens and Sparta started in everything but name. Modern readers mostly don’t know the story, so it’s worth telling, because once you know what Socrates had just lived through, his deadpan “Like this, as you see” sounds very different.

Potidaea sat on the narrow neck of land that joins Pallene, the westernmost of the three fingers of the Chalcidice in northern Greece, to the mainland, and its loyalties were split down the middle. It had been founded by Corinth and still received magistrates sent out from Corinth every year, but it also paid tribute to Athens as a member of the Athenian alliance, which by the 430s was an empire in all but name. Think of a business that still takes its managers from the parent company while paying protection money to that company’s biggest rival, and you can see why everyone was nervous about it.

The fuse was lit somewhere else entirely, on the other side of Greece, when in 433 Athens sided with Corcyra in a naval war against Corinth, and Athenian ships helped stop a Corinthian fleet at the battle of Sybota, which left Corinth furious and looking for payback. At the same moment Perdiccas, king of Macedon and formerly a friend of Athens, turned hostile because the Athenians had allied themselves with his brother Philip and a prince named Derdas, who were working against him. Perdiccas started lobbying Sparta for war, courting Corinth, and urging the Chalcidians and Bottiaeans, the peoples on his borders, to revolt. Athens saw where this was heading and struck first, ordering Potidaea to tear down its wall on the Pallene side, hand over hostages, and send the Corinthian magistrates home for good.

The Potidaeans tried to talk Athens out of it and got nowhere, so they also sent envoys to Sparta alongside the Corinthians, and there the Spartan authorities promised to invade Attica if Athens moved against Potidaea. With that promise in their pocket the Potidaeans revolted in 432, together with the Chalcidians and the Bottiaeans, and Perdiccas persuaded the Chalcidians to abandon their towns on the coast and gather in one strong city at Olynthus, giving them land of his own around Lake Bolbe to farm while the war lasted. The first Athenian force, thirty ships and a thousand hoplites under Archestratus, arrived to find the whole region already in revolt and turned on Macedonia instead.

Corinth then sent help without officially going to war, about sixteen hundred hoplites and four hundred light troops, volunteers and Peloponnesian mercenaries under Aristeus, a man so well liked at Potidaea that most of the Corinthians signed up out of loyalty to him. Athens answered with two thousand more hoplites and forty ships under Callias, patched up a forced deal with Perdiccas, and marched on Potidaea, while Perdiccas promptly switched sides again and took command of the enemy’s cavalry. In the battle on the isthmus, Aristeus’ own wing routed the troops in front of it and chased them a long way, but the rest of his army was beaten and fled into the city, and Aristeus had to fight his way back in along the breakwater. Close to three hundred Potidaeans and allies died, along with a hundred and fifty Athenians and their general Callias, and when another sixteen hundred Athenians arrived under Phormio and walled off the Pallene side, the city was sealed in by land and sea.

Then the siege turned into a money pit and a graveyard. In 430 a fresh Athenian army under Hagnon arrived with siege engines and brought the plague with it, losing one thousand and fifty of its four thousand hoplites in about forty days and infecting the troops already there. By the winter of 430/29 the people inside Potidaea had eaten everything and, Thucydides says, had started eating each other, so they surrendered on terms, leaving with one garment apiece, two for the women, and a fixed sum for the journey. The siege had cost Athens two thousand talents, at a time when Pericles reckoned the empire’s yearly tribute at around six hundred, and the Athenians were angry with their generals for granting terms without asking them first, and then sent settlers of their own to take over the empty city. Socrates served at Potidaea, and in the Symposium Alcibiades remembers him walking barefoot over the northern ice and saving Alcibiades’ life in battle.

So did Sparta get involved, and was this the start of the Peloponnesian War? The siege did drag Sparta in, but slowly and almost reluctantly. Thucydides notes that while Corinth was fighting at Potidaea the treaty between the two blocs technically still held, since Corinth was acting on its own, but once Corinthians were trapped inside the city, Corinth summoned Sparta’s allies to Sparta and demanded action. In 432 the Spartan assembly voted that Athens had broken the treaty, and Thucydides adds that they voted that way less because of the allies’ arguments than because they feared Athens’ growing power. Spartan envoys then ordered Athens to lift the siege of Potidaea, free Aegina and repeal its decree against Megara, and Pericles talked the Athenians into refusing. The official war, though, began in the spring of 431, when Thebes attacked Plataea and a Spartan army invaded Attica, and even those invasions never made Athens let go of Potidaea, which Sparta never managed to relieve.

My verdict is that Potidaea was the war’s opening scene in every sense but the formal one. Thucydides names it, along with Corcyra, as one of the two open grievances that broke the peace, while insisting that the deeper cause was Spartan fear of Athenian power, and you can watch that power at work in miniature at Potidaea, in the hostages, the demolished walls, the endless siege and the bill. Whether the battle Socrates mentions in the Charmides is the big fight of 432 or a later clash before the city fell is disputed, but either way he walks into the wrestling-school straight out of the first chapter of a catastrophe, one that would end with Athens defeated and Critias and Charmides, the two men he sits down with, in power over its ruins.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why did Potidaea’s political position make it especially vulnerable to conflict between Athens and Corinth?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.