Philosophy
The Reporter Between Two Experts
Two engineers disagree about an aging dam. A reporter can compare their reasons and find out where other specialists stand, even when she can’t check the calculations herself.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA hypothetical dispute about a dam puts Socrates’ distinction between testing an argument and knowing its subject to work.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The disputeTwo qualified engineers disagree about an aging dam. The reporter can’t decide whose calculations are right.
- The questions she can askShe can test whether each explanation is consistent and ask what evidence would change each engineer’s mind.
- Two kinds of disagreementThe engineers may differ about measurements or about the amount of risk the town should accept. The story should tell readers which issue divides them.
- Proportion mattersWhen one view is widely held among the specialists who know the case and another is rare, equal space can give readers a misleading picture of expert opinion.
The case here is hypothetical, though its shape will be familiar, with a town’s aging dam and two respected engineers who disagree about it. One says the structure has decades of safe life left and needs only routine repairs, and the other says hidden weaknesses make it a serious danger within a few years. Both have impressive credentials, both speak with confidence, and the town council will decide in a month whether to spend a fortune on reinforcement. A local reporter has been assigned the story, and she has no engineering training at all. Whatever she writes will shape how the council and the town understand the choice, so the stakes of getting the story right are real.
The doctor argument tells her the bad news first. Judging whether a claim about a dam is true requires knowing about dams, and only a fellow engineer can examine another engineer in the things his craft is about. The reporter can’t look at the stress calculations and say who has them right, and if she pretends she can, she will be doing exactly what the Charmides warns against, claiming to know what another person knows without knowing his subject. Her readers can’t judge the calculations either, which is exactly why they rely on her, and she owes them an honest account of what she can and can’t tell.
But there is a lot she can do, and much of it is what Socrates does. She can check each expert’s argument for consistency, asking whether his conclusions follow from what he says about the evidence, and whether what he says now fits with what he said last year. She can ask each what evidence would change his mind, since an expert who can name no such evidence is telling her something important. She can ask each what the other side gets right, which often reveals how much they actually agree on, and where the real disagreement lies. She can also ask each to explain his reasoning in plain terms, since an expert who can’t make his central point intelligible to a careful outsider may not understand it as well as he thinks.
That last question is especially useful, because disagreements between experts are often smaller than they look. The two engineers may agree on the measurements and differ only on how much risk is acceptable, which isn’t an engineering question at all but a question of values that the town is entitled to decide for itself. Or they may agree on the risk and differ on the measurements, which is a genuine technical dispute. Sorting the two is something a careful outsider can do, and it changes what the story should say. Many public arguments that look like disputes about facts are really disputes about how much risk a community should accept, and naming that clearly is one of the most useful things a reporter can do.
Socrates gives the reporter another useful principle earlier in the dialogue. When Critias accuses him of trying to refute him personally, Socrates tells him to “say goodbye to whether it is Critias or Socrates who is being refuted” and to pay attention to the argument itself. The reporter should do the same, setting aside which engineer is more charming, more famous or more quotable, and following the reasons each gives. That alone protects her from much of the drama that tends to swamp coverage of expert disputes. Socrates says there that he examines arguments partly for his own sake, out of fear of thinking he knows something when he doesn’t, which would be a good motive for a reporter too.
There’s a familiar trap she needs to avoid, because giving both sides equal space can look like fairness, but if one engineer represents the view of nearly every specialist who has studied the dam and the other is a lone dissenter, equal space misrepresents the state of expert opinion. A review of science coverage commissioned by the BBC Trust in 2011 criticized exactly this, the habit of giving marginal views undue weight in the name of balance. The reporter can’t judge the engineering, but she can find out how other qualified engineers see it, which is the outsider’s version of borrowing the fellow craftsman’s judgment.
What she can’t do is settle the question, and the honest story says so. Checking an argument’s consistency is a real skill, and it can show that one side’s case is muddled or self-serving, but a perfectly consistent argument can still be wrong about the dam, and a messy one can still be right. The difference between testing an argument and possessing the knowledge to decide its subject is the difference the Charmides draws between Socrates’ examinations and the expertise of the doctor, and a good reporter keeps that difference visible to her readers. They are better served by a clear account of the disagreement, its likely sources and the views of the wider field than by a verdict she has no standing to give.
My verdict is that an informed outsider covering a dispute between experts can do a great deal, testing consistency, asking what would change each mind, sorting factual disagreements from disagreements about values, and finding out where other specialists stand, but can’t settle the technical question itself. The Charmides draws exactly that line, between examining what people say and knowing what they’re talking about. A reporter who respects it will write a story that is both more modest and more useful than one that pretends to have found the right answer.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
If the engineers agree on the dam’s measurements but disagree about how much risk is acceptable, how should the reporter characterize the dispute?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a reporter cannot decide which technical claim is true, what would make her coverage genuinely useful rather than merely inconclusive?→
- How should a reporter distinguish a factual disagreement from a disagreement about values when the experts themselves do not clearly separate the two?→
- When, if ever, might an expert’s reputation or communication style be relevant evidence rather than a distraction from the argument?→