Renaissance

The Punch That Shaped a Face

Cellini, Condivi and Vasari tell the same story of Michelangelo’s broken nose with different motives. Pater places it at the start of a story about strength turning bitter.

A bronze portrait gives the injury a visible trace. The early biographies and Pater’s essay show how readily a fact about a face can turn into a claim about character.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Pater gives the blow a place in the storyHe says Michelangelo knew how to excite hatred before he mentions the punch. That order encourages a reader to look for a connection.
  • The witnesses give Torrigiano different motivesIn Cellini’s account, Torrigiano says he had been mocked. Condivi and Vasari give the injury a different moral emphasis.
  • The portraits retain the damaged bridgeA bronze bust attributed to Daniele da Volterra shows the distinctive nose. Its shape records an injury without settling what caused the quarrel.
  • Pater finds a contrast between face and workThe blow costs Michelangelo what Pater calls outward comeliness. His sculpture keeps finding beauty even when its forms look under strain.

Pater gives the most famous punch of the Renaissance one sentence, and the order of the clauses does a lot of quiet work. “He knew too how to excite strong hatreds; and it was at this time that in a quarrel with a fellow-student he received a blow on the face which deprived him for ever of the comeliness of outward form.” The hatred comes first and the blow second, so before we learn that someone hit Michelangelo we’ve been told he had a talent for making people want to, and the sentence reads less like an assault report than like the first scene in a character study.

The man who threw the punch told his side of it years later, and it survives because Benvenuto Cellini wrote it down. The sculptor Pietro Torrigiano, visiting Florence and trying to recruit young artists for work in England, told Cellini that as boys he and Michelangelo had studied together and that Michelangelo used to make fun of everyone. One day, he said, a gibe stung him more than usual, so he clenched his fist and hit Michelangelo on the nose so hard that the bone and cartilage gave way like a biscuit, and he bragged that Michelangelo would carry the mark to his grave. Cellini describes Torrigiano as a handsome, swaggering man who looked more like a hired swordsman than a sculptor, and Cellini, who worshipped Michelangelo, was so disgusted by the boast that he refused to go to England with him.

Condivi’s biography, written with Michelangelo’s cooperation, tells it from the other corner. His description of his master’s face says the nose was a little flattened, “not naturally, but because when he was a boy, one Torrigiano, a brutal and proud fellow,” hit him so hard that he almost broke the cartilage and Michelangelo “was carried home as one dead.” Vasari, for his part, put the blow down to envy of a more gifted rival. So we have the same punch in two versions, one in which a mocking teenager finally got what was coming to him and one in which a jealous thug lashed out at genius, and which version you believe says a lot about which Michelangelo you’ve already decided to like.

Torrigiano’s later life is a story of its own. He left Florence, worked in Rome, soldiered for a while, and ended up in England, where he made the gilt bronze tomb of Henry VII and Elizabeth of York in Westminster Abbey, a prominent early work of Italian Renaissance sculpture in England. He finished his days in Spain and died in a prison of the Inquisition in Seville, and yet for most people he’s remembered for a single swing of his fist, which is a strange fate for the man who made a king’s tomb.

The nose itself became part of the brand, and a bronze bust attributed to Daniele da Volterra shows the flattened bridge plainly. It became one of Michelangelo’s recognizable features, the way a boxer’s crooked nose becomes the first thing a cartoonist draws. It turned into evidence for a story about the man, and Pater uses it that way, since only a page later he’s gathering the hard sayings and bitter incidents of the life. “In the story of Michelangelo’s life the strength, often turning to bitterness, is not far to seek,” he writes, and “a discordant note sounds throughout it which almost spoils the music.”

The anecdotes Pater gathers are good ones, starting with the old story in which Michelangelo, meeting Raphael with his crowd of followers, jeered that he looked like a police chief with his posse, and Raphael answered that Michelangelo went about alone, which Pater compresses into the line that he walked the streets of Rome “like an executioner.” There’s his report that Michelangelo once “seems to have shut himself up with the intention of starving himself to death.” There are what Pater calls “harsh, untempered incidents,” and there’s his suspicion that Michelangelo belongs among the souls Dante condemns in the fifth circle of Hell for having “wilfully lived in sadness,” sulking in the mud while the sun shone above them. The broken nose sits at the head of this list like the first exhibit in a trial.

Here’s where I’d push back on the whole method. In his early career Michelangelo carved the Bacchus and the Rome Pietà, two of the most beautiful faces in European sculpture, so if the blow did anything to his art it made him no less devoted to beauty. Pater senses this, and his word “comeliness” is the clue, because a page earlier he praised an energy in Michelangelo that seems about to break through “all the conditions of comely form” and yet keeps winning back a loveliness found only in the simplest natural things. The blow takes from the man’s face exactly what his art keeps winning back, and that’s a lovely piece of literary design, but it’s Pater’s design and not the evidence’s.

So my verdict is that the broken nose tells us how these writers make a quarrel carry the weight of a character study. It tells us little about how Michelangelo carved a face. The anecdote is solid, since three early sources report it, while the meaning Pater hangs on it is a story about bitterness that the marble doesn’t tell. Michelangelo spent his life making bodies more beautiful than his own face, and that fact belongs to his ambition, not to the fist of Pietro Torrigiano.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what effect does Pater achieve by mentioning Michelangelo’s ability to provoke hatred before describing the blow?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.