Renaissance

The Pope Wanted More Gold

Julius II thought the Sistine ceiling would look richer with gold. Michelangelo’s joke gives Pater a way to ask where the picture’s richness comes from.

Condivi remembers a practical argument about finishing the vault. Pater turns Michelangelo’s reply into a way of describing the life the bare figures make a viewer imagine.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Julius wanted a final touch of goldCondivi tells how the pope worried that the vault would look poor. Michelangelo joked that the people he had painted were poor themselves.
  • Gold belonged to the chapel’s visual historyBefore Michelangelo’s ceiling, a starry sky occupied the vault. Julius was asking for a kind of richness already familiar in the room.
  • Pater attends to the life the figures suggestHe names birds, flowers and insects that the figures can bring to mind. The sense of abundance comes from the encounter with the painting.
  • The summer is still about to arrivePater ends with a brooding spirit of life. The image makes the ceiling feel full of what might happen next.

The ceiling was completed in 1512. In Condivi’s account, Julius II thought it was missing something. He wanted it touched up in the old way, with gold and ultramarine added a secco (“on dry plaster”) as the painters of the wall frescoes had done, because otherwise, he said, it would look poor. Michelangelo answered that the people he had painted were poor themselves. Condivi remembers it as a joke. Pater compresses the reply into a phrase, the figures are “simple persons, who wore no gold on their garments,” and he uses the exchange as evidence for a claim about where a picture’s richness really comes from. Julius had only a few months left to argue the point, since he died in February 1513.

To feel the force of the exchange, look at what the chapel looked like before. The earlier Sistine vault was a starry sky by Piermatteo d’Amelia, and the wall frescoes below were full of ultramarine and gilding. Vasari tells a story about one of those painters, Cosimo Rosselli, who knew he was weak in design and covered his scenes in the finest blue and the brightest colors and gold, and Pope Sixtus IV liked them so much that he gave Rosselli the prize and ordered the others to add azure and gold so they’d match. Rosselli’s scenes, including the Last Supper and the Sermon on the Mount, are still down there on the walls under Michelangelo’s plain giants, where the contrast with the ceiling is still worth looking at.

So Julius wasn’t being crude by the standards of his own chapel, because gold was the house style. He was asking Michelangelo to finish the job the way popes had always finished jobs, which is a bit like asking a minimalist architect to add some marble columns to the lobby so the investors know where the money went. Michelangelo said no, and, in Condivi’s account, the planned finishing touches of gold and ultramarine were left off. Pater reads that refusal as a principle rather than a whim, and he’s right to, because a man who had just spent four years on a scaffold wasn’t refusing a few more weeks of work out of laziness.

Pater sets it inside a paragraph about what Michelangelo leaves out. “He gives us indeed no lovely natural objects like Leonardo or Titian, but only the coldest, most elementary shadowing of rock or tree; no lovely draperies and comely gestures of life, but only the austere truths of human nature.” Then come the simple persons with no gold, and then the turn, because “he penetrates us with a feeling of that power which we associate with all the warmth and fulness of the world, the sense of which brings into one’s thoughts a swarm of birds and flowers and insects.” The richness, in other words, isn’t on the surface at all, and the ceiling makes you supply the birds and flowers yourself.

That’s an old trick in every art, the one Hemingway described when he said a story should work like an iceberg, with most of its mass below the waterline. Gold puts the value on the surface where you can count it, while Michelangelo’s bare bodies make you feel a fullness that isn’t painted anywhere, and the austere figures turn out to be the richest thing in the room precisely because they don’t spend their energy glittering.

Pater ends the paragraph with a sentence that explains the trick. “The brooding spirit of life itself is there; and the summer may burst out in a moment.” The word “brooding” carries a lot here, because it’s a bird’s word for sitting on eggs, and English readers knew it from Genesis, where the Spirit of God moves upon the face of the waters, and from Milton’s invocation in Paradise Lost to the Spirit who “Dove-like satst brooding on the vast Abyss.” Pater’s ceiling is rich the way an egg is rich, full of a life that hasn’t hatched yet but is plainly about to.

I’ll add one cheeky footnote to Michelangelo’s answer, which is that it wasn’t strictly true. Around the windows of the chapel he painted the ancestors of Christ from the genealogy in Matthew’s Gospel, and the tablets name men like Rehoboam, Asa, Jehoshaphat and Hezekiah, who were kings of Judah and presumably owned some gold. And yet in the small triangles above the windows those royal ancestors appear as tired families, a woman making a garment while her child watches, an exhausted mother clutching a round loaf while a child tries to nurse, which is about as far from court dress as Michelangelo could get. So the reply was partly a witty dodge to a pope who wanted bling and partly a true description of how he had painted the kings, and Pater, who repeats it with a straight face, takes the joke and turns it into an aesthetic, which is a very Pater thing to do.

So my verdict is that Pater reads the anecdote rightly, even if he reads it more solemnly than Michelangelo said it. A scene is rich in proportion to the life it makes you feel, and gold makes a picture expensive without making it full, which is why the ceiling Julius thought looked poor still makes visitors stand under it with their heads tipped back. The pope wanted his money to show, and the artist made sure that what showed instead was the summer about to burst out.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author argue that Julius II’s request for gold and ultramarine was understandable in its setting?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.