Renaissance
The Poet Who Made Both Guest Lists
Raphael put Dante in the Disputation and again on Parnassus. Pater uses the same face to compare the authority of faith with the authority of taste.
The Renaissance (1893)Dante belongs in two of Raphael’s gatherings. The scholar Pater brings into the room, Winckelmann, has to find his way into a tradition from much farther away.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The poet in two placesRaphael depicts Dante among the religious figures of the Disputation and again among the poets of Parnassus.
- Two kinds of inheritancePater treats the walls as portraits of communities that carry Catholic teaching and classical taste forward.
- The room also houses philosophyThe School of Athens gives reason a place in Raphael’s larger program, even though Pater focuses on two other frescoes.
- A scholar arriving from outsidePater likens Winckelmann to Herodotus’s Scyles, who enters another culture and takes on some of its practices.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, pp. 129–130, Dante in both frescoes and Scyles · Winckelmann, note 300 · Winckelmann, note 301
Pater walks us into one of the most famous rooms in Europe the way a good tour guide does, by pointing at two walls and asking you to notice who’s standing in both pictures. The room is the Stanza della Segnatura, painted for Julius II. Its subjects include theology, philosophy, poetry and law. Pater picks two of them, the Disputation of the Sacrament, where “Raphael has commemorated the tradition of the Catholic religion,” and the Parnassus, which “presents a very different company, Dante alone appearing in both.” That one shared face lets Pater stage a comparison between two kinds of authority, and the way he handles it tells you a lot about how much weight he wants taste to carry.
In the Disputation, “Against a space of tranquil sky, broken in upon by the beatific vision, are ranged the great personages of Christian history, with the Sacrament in the midst,” and Dante stands in profile on the right, behind a figure with the features of Pope Sixtus IV. A poet among the theologians might look like a gate-crasher, but his friend Giovanni del Virgilio’s epitaph at Ravenna had called him Theologus, the theologian, and the long stretches of doctrine in the Comedy made the label stick. The Vatican’s own guides still call his placement significant and surprising, because the painter has put a poet among the Church Fathers and theologians.
The Parnassus gathers poets around Apollo above a window, and Pater gives that gathering a single sentence. “Surrounded by the muses of Greek mythology, under a thicket of laurel, sits Apollo, with the sources of Castalia at his feet,” and to one side the blind Homer sings while Virgil points toward Apollo and Dante stands just behind them, laurel-crowned again. Raphael’s Apollo plays a lira da braccio, a Renaissance instrument that places the ancient company in the painter’s own time. The grouping also echoes Dante’s own poem, where the great ancient poets welcome him into their band and he becomes, in his proud phrase, sesto tra cotanto senno, sixth among so much wisdom.
That echo matters, because in Dante’s poem the welcome happens in Limbo, where Homer, Virgil and the rest live forever without hope of heaven, and Virgil has to hand Dante over to another guide before Paradise. Dante kept the two traditions in strict order, with the pagans honored and shut out, while Raphael’s room puts them on neighboring walls under one roof, a pope’s library where Apollo and the Sacrament are neighbors. The ceiling makes the claim bolder still, since the roundel above the Parnassus shows Poetry with the motto Numine afflatur, breathed upon by a divine power, a phrase that grants the poet a kind of divine prompting. So the room itself already grants poetry a share of inspiration, and Pater’s reading has more support in the walls than a skeptic might expect.
Then Pater makes his boldest move with a few borrowed words. He says the waters of Castalia come down to the poets like the river of the Psalm that makes glad the city of God, and he calls Parnassus a second City of God, lifting the title of Augustine’s great book and handing a copy to the pagans. “In this fresco,” he goes on, “it is the classical tradition, the orthodoxy of taste, that Raphael commemorates,” and a few lines later he says that Winckelmann’s life “authenticates the claims of this tradition in human culture.” Orthodoxy and authentication are church words, the vocabulary of creeds and relics, and Pater is plainly enjoying the provocation of applying them to a hillside full of poets who never heard of either.
The other side deserves a fair hearing here, because the parallel limps in ways Pater doesn’t mention. The Church’s tradition has councils, creeds, sacraments and a priesthood to carry it from one generation to the next, while Pater’s account of taste puts the emphasis on objects and the people who are moved by them, and Pater himself concedes that outsiders “might imitate that enthusiasm,” so that classicism could become a passing “intellectual fashion.” He also skips the most famous wall in the room, the School of Athens, and the omission narrows the range of authorities available for his comparison.
That gap is exactly where Winckelmann comes in, and Pater’s turn to him is the hinge of the passage. Unlike Dante, Winckelmann stands on neither wall, and Pater stresses how far outside the tradition he started, since “he lived at a time when, in Germany, classical studies were out of favour,” far from the places where the old relics still lay about. “Yet, remote in time and place, he feels after the Hellenic world,” like Herodotus’s Scyles, the Scythian king who slipped into Greek clothes inside a Greek town and worshiped Greek gods in secret until his own people found out and his brother had him beheaded. Pater calls this the testimony of “a solitary man of genius,” and the irony that Winckelmann joined the Church of the first fresco on his way to the poets of the second hangs over the sentence without being spoken.
My verdict is that the double Dante is a brilliant device and that the orthodoxy of taste is a calculated overstatement the device helps Pater get away with. Dante shows that one person can carry both traditions without contradiction, and Raphael’s room shows that a pope could house them side by side, so Pater isn’t inventing the pairing. But the authority he claims for taste works differently from the Church’s, because his evidence is a person who felt his way back to the works. Whatever institutions preserve the objects, that encounter is what makes the tradition alive for Pater. That’s a weaker kind of authority than a creed and a more moving one, and Pater’s choice of a lonely witness rather than a council as his evidence is the most honest thing about the whole comparison.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the main argumentative purpose of Dante’s appearance in both the Disputation and the Parnassus?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Does Dante’s ability to belong to both frescoes genuinely support Pater’s comparison between religious authority and classical taste, or does it only make that comparison visually persuasive?→
- If a tradition remains alive primarily through individuals being moved by preserved works, what kind of authority can it claim—and how does that authority differ from one grounded in institutions?→
- How does Pater’s omission of the School of Athens affect the fairness or strength of his interpretation of Raphael’s room?→