Renaissance
The Plato Who Gives Desire a Place in Learning
Pater takes the scene of the Lysis and the theory of recollection in the Phaedrus to explain why Plato mattered to Winckelmann.
The Renaissance (1893)The wrestling school gives Pater a setting where physical beauty and thought can meet. His change to Plato’s Greek shows how he adapts that meeting to Winckelmann.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A scene from the LysisSocrates is drawn into a wrestling school where talk about friendship begins among young men already preoccupied with desire.
- The Phaedrus gives sight a roleThe sight of beauty can awaken a memory and begin a movement of the mind toward what it once knew.
- Pater recasts Plato’s wordingPater describes philosophizing with love in more general terms than the Greek of Phaedrus 249a.
- A selective likenessThe two dialogues help Pater make sense of Winckelmann’s experience, while other Platonic passages give the senses a less generous role.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, the young men of the Lysis · Note 282, the Lysis and its wrestling school · Winckelmann, enthusiasm in the broad sense of the Phaedrus · Winckelmann, recollection and having philosophized with love · Note 295, Pater’s adaptation of the Greek · Lysis 203a–204a, the invitation to the wrestling school · Lysis 205c–206a, Socrates on a lover’s praise · Lysis 219d–220c, what is loved for its own sake · Phaedrus 248e–249d, love, philosophy and recollection · Phaedrus 249d–250c, recollection and the lover’s madness · Phaedrus 250c–251b, beauty and the power of sight
Pater makes the exception explicitly, and with a backhanded compliment. “Plato, however, saved so often for his redeeming literary manner, is excepted from Winckelmann’s proscription of the philosophers.” Then he draws a careful distinction between two Platos. “The modern student most often meets Plato on that side which seems to pass beyond Plato into a world no longer pagan, and based upon the conception of a spiritual life,” which is the Plato of the Church fathers and the Christian Platonists. “But the element of affinity which he presents to Winckelmann is that which is wholly Greek, and alien from the Christian world,” and Pater locates it in a single scene.
The scene is the opening of the Lysis, “that group of brilliant youths in the Lysis, still uninfected by any spiritual sickness, finding the end of all endeavour in the aspects of the human form, the continual stir and motion of a comely human life.” Plato sets the dialogue at a newly built wrestling school outside the city walls, where Socrates gets pulled in by young men, one of whom, Hippothales, is so in love with the boy Lysis that he blushes at his name. Hippothales has been pestering his friends with poems about the boy, and Socrates teases him that a lover who praises his beloved before winning him only makes the boy vainer and harder to catch, a reminder that the philosophical conversation starts in a recognizable social situation. The conversation that follows is about friendship and ends without an answer, but Pater takes almost nothing from the argument and everything from the setting, the gym, the crowd, the beauty and the easy talk among bodies at leisure.
That selection is the first thing worth noticing about Pater’s method here. The Lysis is a philosophical dialogue that at one point asks whether there is a first object of affection for whose sake other things are loved. The dialogue goes on to test that suggestion. Pater leaves that argument aside and keeps the palaestra, because what Winckelmann needed from Plato wasn’t a doctrine but a world, a picture of a society in which looking at beautiful young people and thinking hard went on in the same room. The dialogue does the work of a backdrop, establishing the scene in which Winckelmann’s kind of seeing makes sense.
The Phaedrus does a quite different job in the portrait. When Pater explains the secret of Winckelmann’s power over the Greek world, he names enthusiasm “in the broad Platonic sense of the Phaedrus,” and he describes it as an excitement “dependent as it is to a great degree on bodily temperament,” with “a power of reinforcing the purer emotions of the intellect with an almost physical excitement.” In the Phaedrus Socrates praises a divine madness, of which love is the highest form, and he says that beauty alone among the forms shines through sight, the sharpest of the bodily senses, so the sight of a beautiful person can remind the soul of beauty itself and make it grow its wings again.
Pater then reaches for the dialogue’s doctrine of recollection. Winckelmann “seems to realise that fancy of the reminiscence of a forgotten knowledge hidden for a time in the mind itself,” Pater says, “as if the mind of one, lover and philosopher at once in some phase of pre-existence,” φιλοσοφήσας πότε μέτ’ ἔρωτος, having once philosophized with love, had “fallen into a new cycle” and were beginning again “with a certain power of anticipating its results.” That explains the uncanny speed of Winckelmann’s insight, his ability to grasp the laws of a style from a few examples, as recognition rather than discovery, the way you might know a song you can’t remember ever hearing.
Look closely at Pater’s Greek, though, because it isn’t quite Plato’s. In the Phaedrus the souls that regain their wings soonest are those of the man who has philosophized without guile or who has loved boys together with philosophy, and Pater’s phrase turns that around into having once philosophized with love. The change is small and telling, since it keeps the union of eros and philosophy while softening the specific Greek setting of the original, and it shows Pater adapting his source to the portrait even as he invokes it. The original is far more specific about the kind of love it means, and Pater’s version could have been read aloud in a Victorian drawing room. The adjustment is part of how Pater makes the dialogue speak to his subject.
All this has to be kept apart from any general claim about Plato and the senses. The Phaedo calls philosophy a practice of dying and treats the body as an obstacle to knowledge, the Republic ranks the visible world below the intelligible, and even the Phaedrus has its charioteer hauling back the unruly horse of appetite. Taken as a whole, Plato is far more suspicious of the senses than Pater’s portrait suggests, and Pater knows it, which is why he speaks of the Plato who “presents” an affinity to Winckelmann rather than the Plato who taught it. The dialogues are chosen because they’re the places where Plato gives desire and sight a real role in learning.
My verdict is that Pater’s Plato in this essay is a deliberately partial Plato, and the partiality is legitimate as portraiture because it’s Winckelmann’s Plato rather than Plato’s system. The Lysis supplies the scene and the Phaedrus supplies the mechanism, a world where bodies and talk mix and a theory in which the sight of beauty can lift the mind toward knowledge. Pater’s quiet adjustment of the Greek shows how carefully he tailors the source to his subject, and the honest reading takes both dialogues as evidence of what Pater thinks drew Winckelmann to Plato, a philosopher who, in a few unforgettable pages, lets desire take a seat in the classroom.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article distinguish the roles of the Lysis and the Phaedrus in Pater’s portrait of Winckelmann?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does selective interpretation become legitimate portraiture, and when does it become a distortion of the thinker being interpreted?→
- What is gained or lost when Pater takes the setting of the Lysis more seriously than its philosophical argument?→
- How does Pater’s adaptation of Plato’s language affect the relationship among desire, historical context, and philosophical learning?→