Philosophy

The Perfect Dashboard

A personal dashboard can show better sleep, more money, and faster runs. Socrates’ dream of a world full of real experts asks what such good results can tell someone about how to live.

A rising line can mark real progress. Deciding which lines matter and what they add up to calls for a judgment the dashboard cannot make.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Every chart looks goodThe person in the example earns more, runs faster, and keeps better track of her sleep. The numbers are useful evidence about those parts of her life.
  • Socrates grants the experts their successHis dream has real doctors, safe voyages, and well-made goods. He asks what would let the people who enjoy those successes say they are living well.
  • Someone chooses the measuresYankelovich’s McNamara fallacy starts when people count what is easiest to count and let harder questions drop out of view. The same risk applies to a personal dashboard.
  • A number needs a purposeMore pay can mean welcome security or less time for the people one cares about. Reading the number well means asking what it is helping a person do.

Charmides 173a–c, 173c–174a, 174a–d · Daniel Yankelovich The New Odds · Robert F. Kennedy Address at the University of Kansas

Consider a thirty-five-year-old with a beautifully designed personal dashboard. It shows her salary rising every year, her promotions on schedule, her resting heart rate falling, her running times improving, her sleep tracked to the minute and her screen time down. Every chart points the right way, and the app congratulates her weekly on her progress. The question is whether all those good numbers could decide that her life is going well, or whether something essential is missing from the screen. A new feature on the app offers to add still more things to track.

Socrates’ dream in the Charmides is a dashboard for a whole civilization. With temperance ruling, he says, we would be “healthier in body than we are now,” would “come through safe when in danger at sea and in war,” and our “equipment and clothing and our footwear” would be expertly made, with true prophets to forecast the future. Every measure of competent living would be at its best, and every item on his list is genuinely worth having. Then he refuses to grant that we would therefore do well and be happy, since “this, my dear Critias, we cannot yet learn.” The thought experiment grants the experts their successes, so those successes can be tested on their own.

The reason the dream falls short also applies to the dashboard. Every number on the screen measures a means, something good for the sake of something else. Salary is good for what it buys, fitness for what it lets you do, sleep for the energy it gives, promotions for the work or recognition they bring. None of these numbers says what the means are for, and a person can improve every one of them while pursuing a life she would not, on reflection, want to be living. A pile of good means can even make the problem harder to see, since each improvement feels like evidence that the whole is going well.

The deeper problem is that the dashboard isn’t neutral. Someone chose what to measure, and the choice already contains a view of what a good life is. Salary is on the screen, while friendship isn’t, and running times are there while kindness isn’t. Efficient habits are tracked, while the hours spent with an aging parent or a struggling friend show up only as inefficiency. A dashboard like this can settle what matters before its owner has stopped to ask. The designers made those choices, usually for convenience, since steps and calories are easy to count and gratitude and courage are not.

In a 1971 speech, the researcher Daniel Yankelovich called one version of the problem the McNamara fallacy. Measurement starts with what is easy to count. Trouble comes when harder-to-count things are treated as less important and eventually disappear from the decision. He pointed to the American use of body counts in Vietnam. Robert F. Kennedy made a related criticism in 1968, when he asked what gross national product could tell Americans about the quality of their lives.

Reading the numbers requires judgment too, since a rising salary might mean success or might mean a job that is consuming everything else, and falling screen time might mean discipline or loneliness. Even the same number can mean opposite things in different lives, so interpreting the dashboard requires knowing what the person is aiming at and whether the aim is a good one. That is the knowledge the Charmides finally names, the knowledge of good and bad, which tells you what the other knowledges are for and is not itself on any screen. Fewer hours at the office might be the best news on the dashboard or the worst, and nothing on the dashboard can say which.

Information about health, money, and habits is valuable. A city with genuine doctors and pilots has good reason to keep them, and a runner who wants to improve her time has good reason to use a watch. The harder question is which tools to reach for and when. It comes up as soon as a person has two good uses for the same hour and has to choose between them.

The dashboard can tell this woman whether she’s getting where she meant to go. It can even alert her to a change she wouldn’t otherwise have noticed. Socrates’ dream leaves her with one more thing to ask. Is that still where she wants to be going, and can she give herself a good reason for it?

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article say a dashboard full of improving numbers cannot by itself establish that a life is going well?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.