Philosophy

The People the Perfect City Forgot

The rulers in Socrates’ imagined city decide who knows enough to do each job. What would change if the people living under those decisions were asked what they know?

Socrates’ imagined city makes expertise the condition of good rule. Aristotle’s householder and Plato’s flute-player bring the experience of the governed into view.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The rulers do the judgingSocrates imagines rulers who find competent people and decide which work everyone is allowed to do. The people living under those decisions have no speaking part in the picture.
  • Users know how things workAristotle’s householder and diner can judge things the builder and cook make. Hayek gives a modern account of knowledge spread among people in particular places.
  • Plato gives users a sayIn the Republic, the flute-player knows what a good flute needs to do and can advise the maker. The article asks what happens if citizens can judge their institutions in the same way.
  • Agreement enters the pictureThe Republic describes a temperate city as one where rulers and ruled agree who should rule. The comparison brings the governed into the account of temperance.

Charmides 171d–172a · Republic 431d–432a, 601d–e · Aristotle, Politics III.11 · F. A. Hayek The Use of Knowledge in Society

Read the picture of the temperate city again and count whose judgments appear in it. “We would find those who did know and hand things over to them,” Socrates says as he imagines the rulers’ position, and “Nor would we allow the others we ruled to do anything except what they would do correctly, and that would be whatever they had knowledge of.” Every verb of judging belongs to the rulers, who find, hand over and allow, while the others appear only as people who are ruled, permitted or forbidden. Nobody in the picture asks the governed what they think, and the passage never suggests their opinion might matter. Even the grammar keeps them passive, “the others we ruled,” as if their whole role in the city were to be ruled well.

Socrates sketches this arrangement while asking Critias to recall what they had hoped temperance could do. The passage tests a promise about expert rule. Its silence leaves the reader with a question the speakers never take up. What might change if the people living under these arrangements could bring their judgment to bear?

The first thing that changes is what counts as knowledge in the city. The rulers know who is competent at which craft, but the people who live under the arrangements know things the rulers can’t, such as how the arrangements actually feel, which ones work in practice and which ones only work on paper. Aristotle made this point with homely examples, saying the person who lives in a house judges it better than the builder, and the diner judges a feast better than the cook. On that view the governed aren’t just objects of good management, they’re a source of knowledge the managers need. Aristotle used the point to argue that the many, judging together, can sometimes judge better than a few experts, at least where a thing’s value shows up in its use.

The economist Friedrich Hayek made a related argument in a famous essay of 1945. Much of the knowledge a society runs on, he argued, isn’t scientific knowledge that experts can collect in one place, but knowledge of particular circumstances of time and place, scattered among millions of people who each know their own corner. No central authority, however expert, can gather it all, which is why systems that try to direct everything from the top tend to make mistakes the people on the ground could have warned them about. The temperate city, run entirely by those who know who knows, would have exactly this blind spot.

There’s a neat irony here that Plato’s own work supplies. In the Republic he argues that for every made thing, the user knows best what makes it good and tells the maker how to make it, as the flute-player instructs the flute-maker. If the city’s arrangements are things made by its rulers and used by its citizens, the user principle would seem to give the citizens a kind of knowledge the rulers lack, which is exactly the knowledge the temperate city leaves out. A city is used by everyone who lives in it, and nobody uses it more than the ordinary people whose days are shaped by its rules.

A deeper irony comes from the Republic’s account of temperance itself. In the Republic, temperance in a city turns out to be an agreement between rulers and ruled about who should rule, a harmony that runs through the whole city, so that the governed share in it by consenting to the arrangement. On that account the judgment of the governed isn’t an optional extra, it’s the very thing that makes a city temperate. The temperate city of the Charmides, with all judgment on the rulers’ side, would on the Republic’s terms not be temperate at all.

So what changes when we consider the judgments of the governed? The city stops being a machine operated by those who know and becomes a shared arrangement whose success depends partly on whether the people living in it understand and accept it. The rulers’ expertise is still valuable, but it becomes one input among several, and the question of benefit, which Socrates has already said the picture can’t answer, gains a new dimension, since benefit to a people surely depends in part on what those people can see for themselves. A ruler who has to explain a decision in terms the governed can check is also easier to correct, which matters in a dialogue so preoccupied with error.

My verdict is that the imagined city’s exclusive focus on its rulers’ judgments is a real gap, but one the Charmides raises rather than endorses. The passage doesn’t state a doctrine that the governed should have no voice, it simply leaves them out, and putting them back in changes the picture at every level, from what the city knows to whether it can be called temperate at all. In the Republic, the agreement of the governed is part of what makes the city temperate. That lets us hear what’s missing from the first picture.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article treat the governed as a source of knowledge rather than merely as recipients of expert rule?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.