Renaissance

The Parthenon Riders Pater Would Save

Asked to save one thing from Greek art, Pater chooses young riders whose horses are moving faster than their faces suggest.

Pater’s choice brings together the liveliness of the cavalcade and the steadiness of the young people keeping it in order.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • An unexpected choicePater chooses a stretch of carved relief showing several riders instead of a famous statue of a single god.
  • Stillness above movementThe riders’ steady faces and upright bodies stand out against overlapping horses in motion.
  • A rein can be missing and still matterHoles for bronze fittings survive where some of the reins once joined the stone.
  • The whole depends on the groupPater’s phrase exquisite service makes the riders’ calm part of a shared discipline.

Everybody has played the desert-island game, and Pater plays it with the whole of Greek art. “If a single product only of Hellenic art were to be saved in the wreck of all beside,” he says, he might choose from the Panathenaic frieze of the Parthenon “that line of youths on horseback, with their level glances, their proud, patient lips, their chastened reins, their whole bodies in exquisite service.” It’s a startling pick, and his hedging “perhaps” suggests he knows it. He passes over the great gods, the famous single statues and the heroic groups in favor of a strip of shallow relief about a meter high that once ran some 160 meters around the temple, and within it he chooses a crowd of anonymous young riders.

The choice makes sense once you see what the riders give him that a single statue can’t. His ideal Greek figure is a type rather than a portrait, a body in motion that stays in repose, and a self-command so complete that it looks effortless. A lone god can show calm easily, because nothing is asking anything of him, but the riders are doing something hard, holding powerful animals in check at a steady pace, and the calm on their faces is visibly earned. They show repose as an achievement in action, which is the paradox the whole chapter keeps circling.

Start with the “level glances,” which turn out to be a design decision. The narrow band of relief keeps many of the riders’ heads close to a shared level. The eye can follow that calm line even where the horses overlap and change pace. The riders mostly look straight ahead, with a rare one turning back toward a companion, and that shared gaze produces the effect Pater calls “an awaking, of a child’s sleep just disturbed,” alert without strain. It’s the same calm you see in a good marching band, where dozens of players in motion keep their eyes on one line.

Below that calm horizontal line, though, there’s plenty of energy at work. On the north side the cavalcade builds from quiet preparation to a gallop, with horses overlapping several deep, rearing and tossing their heads, manes clipped short and nostrils flared, while their riders stay composed. That contrast is the whole show, the animal force underneath and the human poise on top, and it’s why Pater speaks of “proud, patient lips,” faces that have nothing to prove and plenty to manage.

The “chastened reins” hold the two together, and here there’s a detail Pater may not have known. Some reins and bridles were made of bronze and attached through drill holes in the marble. The metal is long gone, and what survives are the little holes, so the reins Pater admires are largely invisible, and he’s reading their restraint from the riders’ hands, the arched necks of the horses and the whole set of the bodies. That makes his phrase a good piece of seeing, because the control he describes is there in the figures even with the straps missing.

Then comes “exquisite service,” the phrase that tells you most about his choice. The procession honored Athena at her great festival, and the riders seem to be arranged in groups, perhaps by the ten tribes of Athens, with small variations of dress within each group, caps for some, cloaks or breastplates for others, and the same steady rhythm throughout, so that nobody is the star. The beauty of the frieze lies in many young men doing the same thing well together, each slightly different, all subordinate to the movement of the whole, the way a section of violinists bows as one without becoming one person.

Fittingly, the frieze was itself a team effort from start to finish. It was carved by many sculptors working to a single design, usually credited to Pheidias, and specialists can see different hands in different blocks, some carved with more skill than others. Its original setting was nothing like Pater’s view either, since it ran high up inside the colonnade in dim, reflected light, and bronze fittings supplied details now missing from the stone. The riders Pater’s readers could see in a London gallery were already removed from the frieze’s original height and architectural setting. Today the surviving frieze is divided mainly between London and the Acropolis Museum in Athens, so the surviving parts of the procession are seen in different collections.

My verdict is that Pater’s desert-island choice reveals the social heart of his Greek ideal. He admired gods in repose, but the work he’d save shows repose produced by discipline and shared among many, energy held in check by people acting together, each a distinct individual and none a soloist. The riders carry the paradox of animated calm more convincingly than any single god, because their restraint is visible in an act, and their “exquisite service” suggests that what Pater loved in Greece was a whole community moving in step, which is a richer ideal than the lonely perfection the rest of the chapter sometimes implies.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article argue that the riders embody Pater’s ideal more fully than a lone god does?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.