Renaissance

The Only Promise Art Makes

Other passions can quicken a life. Pater singles out art for saying openly what it offers the person who gives it their attention.

The closing sentence of the Conclusion moves from art’s own sake to the sake of a passing moment. Two small revisions make that offer easier to hear.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Other passions can quicken lifePater includes the joy and sorrow of love and the energy of other enthusiasms before he singles out art.
  • What art offers franklyPater says art offers a quality of experience while the reader’s or viewer’s moment is passing.
  • From professing to proposingThe later verb makes the last sentence sound more like an offer a person can consider than a declaration they have to accept.
  • Whose moments matterThe phrase about the sake of the moments gives a concrete meaning to the earlier phrase about art’s own sake.

By the last paragraph of the Conclusion you might expect Pater to crown art the only road to a full life, and he doesn’t. “Great passions may give us this quickened sense of life, ecstasy and sorrow of love, the various forms of enthusiastic activity, disinterested or otherwise, which come naturally to many of us.” That’s a generous concession from the supposed high priest of aestheticism, since it says that a person in love, a person grieving, or a person thrown into a cause can live just as intensely as any connoisseur. Art gets ranked first, but it gets ranked first in a field, and the reason Pater gives for its rank is the most interesting thing in the paragraph.

“Of such wisdom, the poetic passion, the desire of beauty, the love of art for its own sake, has most.” Then comes the last sentence of the essay, which explains why. “For art comes to you proposing frankly to give nothing but the highest quality to your moments as they pass, and simply for those moments’ sake.” A person in love gives their attention to someone. A person working for a cause gives it to an outcome they hope to bring about. In either case their own heightened attention may be a consequence they never set out to get. Art, on Pater’s account, says exactly what it’s offering and nothing more, like a concert ticket that sells you two hours of music and makes no claim to fix your marriage.

The word “frankly” is doing the real work, because art’s advantage lies in the honesty of the deal rather than the intensity of the experience, so it doesn’t pretend to save you or improve you or make you rich, and it doesn’t smuggle its gift inside some other promise. Love quickens you because you’re absorbed in someone, a cause quickens you because you’re absorbed in a goal, and in both cases the quickening is a byproduct you didn’t sign up for. With art the quickening is the whole offer, stated plainly at the door, which is why Pater can say it holds the most of this particular wisdom without claiming that it holds the most of every kind.

Pater tuned this sentence between editions, and the small changes all push in the same direction. In 1873 the final clause read “for art comes to you professing frankly to give nothing but the highest quality to your moments,” and in 1893 “professing” became “proposing,” while the semicolon before “for art” became a full stop, so that the closing sentence now stands on its own. To profess is to declare something publicly, the way a believer professes a faith or a professor professes a subject, and it has the ring of a claim. To propose is to make an offer the other person can accept or decline, like a proposal of marriage or a motion at a meeting, so the 1893 art no longer announces its doctrine, it extends an invitation.

The bigger change concerns the familiar phrase about art’s sake. In 1873 Pater wrote “the love of art for art’s sake,” and the note marks it as the more slogan-like version. The English phrase was already circulating in the 1860s. In his book on Blake, Swinburne had put art’s own purposes first. Pater’s 1893 text keeps the point while changing the wording to “the love of art for its own sake.”

The last clause then says what that “own sake” turns out to be. Art comes to you “simply for those moments’ sake,” so the sake in question belongs to your moments, the passing minutes of your life that art proposes to fill with “the highest quality.” That’s a precise answer to an argument that had been running for most of the century. Against the moralist, it says art isn’t for preaching or improving, and against the cultist, it says art isn’t for a coterie of initiates or for its own glorification either, since its sake is the quality of the time it gives to whoever turns up, which makes “for its own sake” mean, finally, for the sake of the experience while it lasts.

You could object that this shrinks art, since art also gives us knowledge, moral vision, a shared history, and Pater’s “nothing but” seems to throw all of that away. I don’t think it does, because “nothing but” governs what art promises, not what it delivers. A novel may teach its reader a great deal. Pater’s sentence gives the reader a reason to care about what the novel is like to read, whether or not a lesson can be carried away. And “quality” isn’t intensity either, since quality is a matter of judgment, of fine distinctions, which ties the offer back to the discrimination the whole essay has been training, so what art gives is a better moment and not merely a louder one.

What art supplies with unusual directness, then, is the essay’s own goal, a passing moment lived at its highest quality, and the final sentence makes that quality the whole of the offer. The revisions sharpen the point, since “proposing” makes the offer modest and the move from “art for art’s sake” to “its own sake” turns a slogan back into an argument. And the final clause fixes the meaning of that phrase for good, because the sake art serves is the sake of your moments, which gives the argument about aestheticism a place in the reader’s actual day.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, why does Pater rank art first among experiences that can quicken life?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.