Renaissance
The Mother Pater Found in a Pair of Curves
Pater sees the contours of a woman’s face again in the fuller face of a child. Leonardo’s studies suggest more than one reason the lines might recur.
The Renaissance (1893)A resemblance between two drawings makes Pater think of a mother and child. The passage shows how quickly a visible feature can become a story about the people drawn.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater starts with a line he can describeHe notices the worn contours of the woman and the fuller curves of the child. Their resemblance gives his reading an exact visual starting point.
- The pairing invites a family storyPater says the likeness leaves no doubt that the two are a mother and child. Their arrangement in separate frames leaves the history of the pairing open.
- Leonardo explores variations in facesA Royal Collection sheet places profiles around a Madonna and Child. Differences of age and expression can emerge from closely related forms.
- The passage ends by returning to the drawingPater asks us to look at hair, a raised arm and the child’s skull beneath the skin. The details remain available whatever story a viewer imagines.
The Renaissance · Leonardo da Vinci, pp. 77–78, the woman and child and the bounding lines
When Pater turns to the drawings, he starts with a principle. Leonardo’s “curious beauty is seen above all in his drawings, and in these chiefly in the abstract grace of the bounding lines,” the contours that close a form. Then he picks an example in Florence, “the heads of a woman and a little child, set side by side, but each in its own separate frame.” Anyone who’s walked through a gallery knows the effect, because two pictures hung next to each other start to look related, the way two strangers photographed together start to look like a couple. Pater’s paragraph is a small lesson in how a critic moves from what’s on the paper to what he believes about the people drawn on it.
The observation itself is lovely, and the movement from a curve to a claim is worth following. “There is much pathos,” he writes, “in the reappearance, in the fuller curves of the face of the child, of the sharper, more chastened lines of the worn and older face, which leaves no doubt that the heads are those of a little child and its mother.” The claim begins as a fact about drawing, the same curves appearing twice, sharpened by age in one face and swollen with youth in the other, and it ends as a fact about a family. Then Pater widens it into a theme, “a feeling for maternity is indeed always characteristic of Leonardo,” and finds the same feeling in “the half-humorous pathos of the diminutive, rounded shoulders of the child.”
It’s worth slowing the sequence down, because each step is doing different work. The first step is seeing, the repeated curve, and nobody needs to argue with it. The second is feeling, the pathos of the repetition, which is fair enough as a response. The third is a story, mother and child, and here the phrase “leaves no doubt” carries far more weight than the drawing can, since nothing on the paper says these two people ever met. Pater even tells us they hang in separate frames, which suggests they weren’t drawn as a pair at all, and that some of the kinship he feels was supplied by whoever hung them side by side.
Leonardo’s own drawings offer a different reason for the same curves to recur. On a sheet in the Royal Collection, Leonardo draws profiles around a Madonna and Child with the infant Baptist. The sheet shows how readily he could vary a contour to explore different faces. For a draftsman who worked this way, the same line sharpened in an old face and softened in a young one is what you’d expect from a single type carried through different ages, with no family required. The same goes for the paired profiles he drew all his life, an old man facing a youth, which nobody reads as a grandfather and his grandson.
There’s a second explanation, and Leonardo supplied it himself. “A painter who has clumsy hands will paint similar hands in his works,” he warned in his notes on painting, and elsewhere he called it the greatest defect in painters to make their faces resemble their author, explaining that the soul which shaped the painter’s own body goes on guiding his arm, so that it keeps copying itself. By his own theory, then, a curve that turns up in two faces may be the signature of the hand that drew them as much as the blood of the people drawn. A resemblance in drawings is first of all a resemblance between drawings.
Still, Pater’s interest in mothers isn’t arbitrary or merely sentimental. Leonardo drew the Madonna and Child over and over in his early Florentine years, including a run of quick studies of a baby wrestling with a cat, and his late work keeps returning to the Virgin seated on her own mother’s lap. The theme is real, and it had a strange future, since Sigmund Freud, who quoted Pater in his study of Leonardo, built a whole psychology out of the painter’s two mothers. Pater’s “feeling for maternity” sits at the head of that line of reading, which is why it’s worth noticing how quickly, in this paragraph, a line on paper becomes a family and the family becomes a feeling in the artist.
What saves the paragraph, in the end, is the way it closes. After drawing in other images of sorrow and fright, Pater pulls himself back to the paper. “But note in these, as that which especially belongs to art, the contour of the young man’s hair, the poise of the slave’s arm above his head, and the curves of the head of the child, following the little skull within, thin and fine as some sea-shell worn by the wind.” That last image is about structure, bone under skin, and it describes something you can actually check on the sheet. Pater the storyteller and Pater the looker are both in this paragraph, and in the final sentence the looker wins.
My verdict is that Pater’s eye gets the drawing right and his story runs ahead of it. The repeated curves are evidence of a type and of a hand before they’re evidence of a mother, and they leave the family relationship a possibility rather than a certainty. The best way to read the passage is the way Pater ends it, holding on to the contour and the little skull inside the child’s head, and treating the mother and child as what the critic told himself while he looked, a guess the drawing permits but never confirms.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, at what point does Pater’s interpretation go beyond what the drawing itself can establish?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does an interpretation of an artwork become too certain, and what kinds of evidence should limit a critic’s claims?→
- How might the placement of separate artworks beside one another shape the relationships viewers imagine between them?→
- Can a critic’s unsupported story still deepen our experience of an artwork, or does it distract from what is visibly present?→