Philosophy

The Man Who Made His Own Strigil

Socrates’ imaginary city makes a rule out of Hippias’ boast about making his own gear.

Socrates’ list of things a citizen would have to make includes an athlete’s scraper. The same object turns up in Hippias’ boast about what he made for himself.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The city of do-it-yourselfersSocrates asks whether a city would run well if everyone had to make their own clothes, shoes and gym kit. Charmides agrees that it wouldn’t.
  • Hippias at OlympiaSocrates recalls Hippias boasting that he made everything he had with him at Olympia, including his ring, belt, oil-flask and strigil. The two small objects put the imagined city beside a famous display of skill.
  • A farmer needs a cobblerIn the Republic, Socrates and Adeimantus consider whether a farmer should make his own clothes and shoes. They give him a better way to spend his time by having him grow food for others.
  • Knowing your partA cobbler can do his own work because other people grow food and weave cloth. The thought experiment shows why taking responsibility for your work can go hand in hand with relying on someone else’s.

Charmides 153a, 161e–162a, 162a · Hippias Minor 368b–d · Republic 369b–c, 369e–370a, 370b–c · Leonard E. Read I, Pencil

The second blow against doing one’s own business is a picture of an absurd city. Socrates asks whether a city would be well managed “under a law that ordered each man to weave and wash his own cloak, cobble his own shoes, and make his own oil-flask and strigil and everything else on the same principle.” Charmides says no. He also agrees that a city managed with temperance would be well managed. The last two items give the example a local touch. A strigil is the curved scraper athletes used to clean oil and dirt from their skin. It and the oil-flask are the sort of kit people bring to a wrestling school.

Plato’s audience may have caught a joke here, because there’s a man in another dialogue who boasts about doing just this. In the Hippias Minor, Socrates recalls hearing Hippias boast that everything he had on him at Olympia was his own work. He lists the ring, a seal, the sandals, the cloak and tunic, the fancy belt and, sure enough, the strigil and the oil-flask. Hippias’ account of himself also includes poetry and expertise in rhythms and harmonies. The same pair of gym accessories turns up in both dialogues, small enough to carry and just right for showing off.

Picture the impossible city as Hippias multiplied by a whole population. The shoes might be lumpy, the cloaks thin and the strigils dull, and every citizen would spend the day taking a turn at jobs someone else could do better. There’s a modern version of the thought experiment in Leonard E. Read’s 1958 essay I, Pencil. He follows the wood, graphite, lacquer and metal band back through the different hands that produce them. Even an object you can hold between two fingers turns out to be the work of a great many strangers.

The Republic makes a similar point at the beginning of its city. Socrates says a city comes into being because each of us needs things we can’t supply for ourselves. He asks whether a farmer should grow food for four people or spend a quarter of his time on food and the rest building a house, making a garment and cobbling shoes. Adeimantus favors sharing the work. Socrates adds that people have different abilities and that a job goes better if the person doing it can give it the time it needs.

What this shows is how much your own work can depend on the work of other people. The cobbler can spend his day making shoes because the weaver is making cloth and the farmer is growing grain. Take away that web and the cobbler has to spend much of the day on something besides shoes. Even a hermit, for that matter, might have started out with a knife somebody else forged.

If temperance has anything to do with doing your own business, it needs room for those other people from the start. The cobbler can know his part in a shared life, make good shoes and trust the weaver to do his part. That also gives him something to ask about the work he takes on. Is he the person who should do it? It’s a better question to ask at his workbench than whether he ought to wear a cloak somebody else made.

There’s even a hint that Hippias’ self-sufficiency can look like a kind of intemperance. The detail Socrates remembers is the boast, down to a belt made like the costly Persian kind. Hippias wants people to hear how much he can do for himself. Whether or not the matching objects are a deliberate joke, the little scraper has acquired two lives. It can be a piece of equipment somebody needs, and it can be a prop in a story about how remarkable its maker is.

My verdict is that the impossible city is a fair test of one reading of the saying. A city of people who refuse to rely on other people’s work would have a hard time doing any work well. Once the cobbler can wear the weaver’s cloak, the interesting question is what makes the shoes his proper work. A strigil is humble equipment, but it’s enough to put that question on the floor of the wrestling school.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article treat Socrates’ “impossible city” as a challenge to one interpretation of doing one’s own business?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.