Philosophy
The Man Who Knew Everything
Socrates imagines a man who knows everything past, present, and future. Critias must say which part of all that knowledge makes him happy.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe imaginary knower lets Socrates ask what makes a good life while granting Critias the largest possible stock of information.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Give Critias everythingSocrates imagines someone who knows the past, present, and future. The case grants Critias the broadest possible knowledge to work with.
- Ask which part mattersSocrates asks whether all of this person’s kinds of knowledge make him happy equally. Critias immediately says they don’t.
- Other kinds of total knowledgeLaplace imagines a mind able to calculate the course of nature. Borges imagines a memory that takes in so much detail that generalizing becomes difficult.
- Knowledge with a distinct jobThe imagined knower can possess both factual and ethical knowledge. The question is which of his abilities helps him judge how to live.
Charmides 173d–174a, 174a–c · Pierre-Simon Laplace A Philosophical Essay on Probabilities, p. 4 · Jorge Luis Borges Funes el memorioso
Critias has declined to say that knowing leatherwork, bronze-working or woodworking makes a person happy, so Socrates proposes a bigger candidate. Perhaps Critias means the prophet who knows the future, or perhaps “the sort of man who, besides the future, knew everything that has happened and everything that is now, and was ignorant of nothing.” Socrates says, “Let us suppose there is such a man,” since Critias surely wouldn’t say anyone lived more knowledgeably than he did. Critias, who has been defending the claim that living knowledgeably makes a person happy, can hardly refuse the man who knows the most. Then Socrates asks the question that turns the whole conversation, “which of the kinds of knowledge makes him happy? Or do they all, alike?”
It’s worth noticing what Socrates doesn’t say about this man. He doesn’t describe him as unhappy, or as a lonely genius crushed by too much information, or as a cautionary tale of any kind. If anything, the question grants that the man is happy and asks where the happiness comes from, which is a much more interesting move. The omniscient man functions like a laboratory setup, holding all possible knowledge constant so that we can ask which part of it is doing the work, the way a chemist tests every ingredient in a recipe to find out which one actually makes the bread rise. Critias plainly takes it that way too, since he doesn’t object that such a man might be miserable, only that his kinds of knowledge are not all alike in what they contribute.
The thought experiment has a famous modern relative, since in 1814 the French mathematician Pierre-Simon Laplace imagined an intellect that knew every force in nature and the position of every particle, and said that for such an intellect nothing would be uncertain, since the future, like the past, would be present before its eyes. Laplace’s demon, as it came to be called, is the scientific version of Socrates’ total knower, a mind holding a complete survey of events. And the question Socrates asks applies to it too, since a complete list of where every particle will be doesn’t include, anywhere in the list, an answer to what is worth doing.
Jorge Luis Borges wrote a short story that pushes the point from another direction. After a fall from a horse, Ireneo Funes remembers his experiences in extraordinary detail. His narrator suspects that Funes is barely capable of thought, because thought involves setting differences aside and finding what things have in common. Funes is a different kind of case from the man in the Charmides. His memory is remarkable, and the story asks what such a memory would enable him to understand.
So the concession sharpens a distinction that could easily have stayed blurry. One kind of knowledge is a survey of events, facts about what happened, what is happening and what will happen, and the total knower has all of it. The other kind is the knowledge that contributes to happiness, and Socrates’ question shows that it must be a particular part of the total rather than the total itself, since even the man who knows everything can be asked which of his knowledges makes him happy, and Critias immediately answers, “Not alike at all.” The answer comes from Critias, not Socrates, so the distinction isn’t forced on him, it’s something he already believes once the question is put sharply enough.
There’s a subtle point hidden in the phrase “ignorant of nothing.” A man who is ignorant of nothing must know what is good and bad, since that’s one of the things there is to know, so the knowledge Critias eventually names is already among the total knower’s possessions. The thought experiment doesn’t set factual knowledge against ethical knowledge as if they belonged to different people. It shows that even inside one perfect mind, they are different knowledges, and only one of them is responsible for the happiness, which is why Socrates can ask the question without contradiction. That matters for reading the end of the dialogue, since it means the knowledge of good and bad isn’t a mysterious faculty outside ordinary knowing but one knowledge among the rest, with a special job.
Modern life gives the point a practical edge. We can collect records of purchases, trips, and searches and use them to make more accurate forecasts. A shopkeeper who knows what everybody bought last month can still ask which products are worth selling. Socrates’ total knower makes the same problem visible on a larger scale. A survey of what happened leaves room for a question about how well it went.
My verdict is that the imagined man who knows everything is one of the cleverest devices in the dialogue, because it lets Socrates isolate the knowledge that makes for happiness without claiming that knowledge of events is worthless or that the man who has it is miserable. A complete survey of past, present and future can sit in a single mind alongside the knowledge of good and bad, and the thought experiment shows that only the second is doing the work of making the life a good one. That distinction, once drawn this sharply, sets up everything that happens in the last pages.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the main function of Socrates’ imagined person who knows everything?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If complete knowledge of past, present, and future does not by itself answer what is worth doing, what additional role must knowledge of good and bad play?→
- Does the total-knower thought experiment successfully isolate the source of happiness, or does it assume too quickly that happiness must come from a kind of knowledge?→
- How do the cases of Laplace’s intellect and Borges’s Funes clarify different limits of possessing an extraordinary amount of information?→