Greek Antiquity

The Lawgiver with No Résumé

Line 25 of the Prayer calls on a goddess named Giver of Law, a name that turns up nowhere else in Greek. The easy move is to say she’s Demeter, but the company she keeps tells a different story.

In the Prayer to Musaeus, the Giver of Law stands beside Trust and Justice. The article asks whether her name points to Demeter or gives lawmaking a place of its own.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A name among civic powersThe Prayer names the Giver of Law just after Trust and Justice. Their company suggests a personification of lawgiving.
  • The case for DemeterDemeter’s familiar title Thesmophoros makes a connection plausible. The names share a Greek element associated with established laws or sacred ordinances.
  • The catalogue names Demeter alreadyDemeter appears earlier beside Phersephone. Her own hymn supplies a fuller test by showing how the collection actually names her.
  • Lawgiving joins the invocationThe collection often builds divine names around the idea of giving. The article reads this one as a civic power while allowing that the name may echo Demeter.

Orphic Hymns, Prayer 6, 23–25, 35–37, with the note on 25; XL.1–3, 8; XLII.1; LXII–LXIV

Halfway through the catalogue the Prayer reaches a line that sounds like a civics lesson, “and Pistis, and Dike, and the blameless Thesmodoteira,” which is Faith, then Justice, then a goddess called the Giver of Law. The first two any Greek would know, but the third is a stranger, because the edition’s note says flatly that her name “occurs nowhere else in Greek” and appears in no inscription, so she has no temple, no festival and no other poem behind her. She’s like the guest at a wedding whom nobody at your table can place, and the natural question is whose side she’s on, since a name with no history has to be read entirely from where it’s sitting.

The usual answer is that she’s Demeter in disguise, and it’s a good answer with a real case behind it. Demeter’s most famous title was Thesmophoros, the bringer of thesmoi, a word for the laws or sacred ordinances that are laid down and set in place, older and holier than anything a city council votes on, and it gave its name to the Thesmophoria, the women’s festival that Aristophanes built a whole comedy around. The Romans kept the idea alive, so when Virgil’s Dido sacrifices before her doomed marriage she offers to legifera Ceres, “law-bearing Ceres,” and the logic behind the title was that farming brought settled life and settled life brought law. A name built on the same thesm- root, “Giver of thesmoi,” looks like a cousin of Demeter’s title, and that’s why commentators usually hand her the role.

Now look at the line she actually stands in. Pistis is Trust or Good Faith, the power that makes a promise worth something, and Theognis had already mourned her centuries earlier as a “mighty god” who abandoned the human race, while Dike is Justice, the giving of each person their due. Themis has been named two lines before, as “scanner of men’s offerings,” so she isn’t the one being reached for here. Read as a unit, line 25 is a little set of the powers that hold a community together, keeping your word and getting what you’re owed and living under rules somebody laid down, and the Giver of Law makes the third of them without any strain at all.

There’s also the awkward fact that Demeter has already come to the party. She’s named at line 6, “and Phersephone holy, and Demeter of splendid fruit,” right where you’d expect her among the great Olympians. The catalogue does allow some doubling, since it calls on Rheia at 26 and the Mother of the immortals at 40, but those were figures with cults and worshippers of their own who were often run together, whereas a second Demeter here would be the same goddess coming back under a name that no one, before or after, ever used for her. That’s a lot to ask of a single unexplained word, especially in a catalogue that otherwise calls its gods by the names their worshippers actually used.

The collection gives you an even better test in its own hymn to Demeter of Eleusis, which piles title on title onto her. She’s “giver of prosperity, / wealth-giving goddess, feeder of the corn-ear, all-bestowing,” and she’s the one who was “first to yoke the ploughing neck of oxen,” which is precisely the culture-hero credit ancient writers used to explain why she was a lawgiver, and yet in a whole hymn of praise nobody calls her that. Her real law title does turn up in the book, but at XLII.1 it goes to somebody else entirely, “The law-bringing, fennel-bearing Dionysos I call,” and the edition’s note points out that this is Demeter’s own title given away. In this collection, clearly, law words float free of her.

The name itself looks like house style rather than cult. The collection loves building gods out of the word for giver, so two lines down Palaimon is “giver of prosperity” and Asklepios “giver of gentleness,” Night elsewhere is the giver of sleep, the Moirai are “givers of all,” and the Mousai are “straight-givers of the understanding,” and nobody needs a cult behind any of them to see what they mean. A poet who can coin those whenever a line needs one can coin a Giver of Law just as easily, which is what the edition’s note means when it calls the word “a literary formation, not a cult title.” What a reader can infer from a name nobody else used, in other words, is that it came from the poet’s workshop and not from anyone’s altar.

The best case for Demeter that remains is about the ear, since any Greek hearing thesm- would think of her and of the women camping out for the Thesmophoria, so the coinage might be a deliberate wink in her direction. I’ll grant the wink, and I’d still say a wink doesn’t make an identification. The line treats her as one more power in a row, with an epithet of her own, “blameless,” and the Prayer asks her to come with the rest, which is how it treats Faith and Justice beside her and not how it treats anybody’s alias.

So my verdict is that she’s a personified power, Lawgiving itself, the third member of a small civic trinity with Trust and Justice, and that Demeter’s shadow falls across the word without falling across the line. It’s also a preview of how this book thinks, because the Prayer turns an idea into a goddess on the spot, and the collection later gives Dike, Dikaiosyne and Nomos, Justice, Righteousness and Law, three hymns of their own in a row. The Giver of Law is the first sign of that habit, and she came out of the same instinct that prays to justice as if it could hear.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the placement of Thesmodoteira beside Pistis and Dike matter most to the author’s interpretation?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.