Renaissance

The Last Curiosity

Pater gives Leonardo a motto about observing nature, then sends him toward a place beyond observation. The question at the end is what curiosity can still do.

Leonardo took notes on the death of a man he had spoken with in a Florence hospital. Pater uses a different kind of inquiry to imagine the artist’s own last hours.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Bacon gives the observer a limitA person can interpret nature to the extent that its workings can be observed. Pater puts that limit at the opening of Leonardo’s essay.
  • Leonardo looks for causes in particularsAt a hospital in Florence he spoke to a very old man and later examined his body. He wanted to understand how the man could die so quietly.
  • Pater’s ending leaves observation behindHands, flowers and hair have precise forms. The land Pater imagines at death offers Leonardo no such thing to look at.
  • The Conclusion gives the question a second settingPater urges readers to stay alert to experience while there is time. Leonardo’s last curiosity is one way the essay imagines that attitude meeting its limit.

Pater starts his essay on Leonardo with a Latin motto, Homo minister et interpres naturæ, which means the human being is the servant and interpreter of nature. It’s the opening line of Francis Bacon’s Novum Organum, published in 1620, more than a century after Leonardo died in 1519, so Pater is pinning a later philosopher’s slogan on an earlier man’s chest. Bacon’s aphorism goes on to say that we can do and understand only as much as we’ve observed of nature’s order, and that beyond this we neither know nor can do anything, which is a strict job description, and it’s worth keeping in mind, because Pater’s essay ends by sending Leonardo past exactly that boundary.

The servant half of the motto fits Leonardo almost too well. Pater describes him seeking “to satisfy a boundless curiosity by her perpetual surprises, a microscopic sense of finish by her finesse,” meaning nature’s delicacy, and he borrows Bacon again for the subtilitas naturae (the subtlety of nature) that outruns our senses. His observations, Pater says, “fill thirteen volumes of manuscript,” and among other things he “explained the obscure light of the unilluminated part of the moon,” the glow we now call earthshine, and “knew that the sea had once covered the mountains which contain shells.” This is a man who earns his wisdom one observed thing at a time. The patient gathering of observations gives the comparison with Bacon its force.

The interpreter half is the painter, and Pater names its engine in a single line. “Curiosity and the desire of beauty,” he writes, are “the two elementary forces in Leonardo’s genius,” and the two don’t always get along, since curiosity keeps dragging him below the surface where, Pater thinks, art “really begins and ends.” The result is a life of restless experiments and unfinished work, with the painter waiting for a rare moment of well-being in which an idea finally turns into an image. Serving nature means watching her closely, and interpreting her means turning what you’ve watched into something you can see.

Then comes the ending, which is one of the most famous closing sentences Pater ever wrote. He brushes aside the two questions scholars liked to argue about, the form of Leonardo’s religion and whether the king was at his deathbed, and says we forget them “in speculating how one who had been always so desirous of beauty, but desired it always in such precise and definite forms, as hands or flowers or hair, looked forward now into the vague land, and experienced the last curiosity.” The servant of nature, whose commission ran only as far as observation goes, walks off the edge of the map still wondering what’s there. It’s a sentence that sounds like a deathbed scene and contains no scene at all, which is exactly Pater’s point.

Is that fair to Leonardo, or just a pretty way to end an essay? There’s real evidence that Leonardo faced death with his notebook open. In a note from his anatomical studies, Leonardo recalls a visit to the hospital of Santa Maria Nuova in Florence. There he chatted with an old man who said he was over a hundred and felt nothing wrong except weakness, and who then, sitting on his bed, passed away without any movement or sign of distress. Leonardo’s note on what came next is unforgettable. “And I dissected him to see the cause of so sweet a death.” The examination gave him a way to compare the changes he saw in old age with the vessels of a child he had also examined.

That’s curiosity meeting death head-on, through a habit formed among particular things, hands and arteries and the texture of a vessel wall. But notice what the dissection can and can’t do. It explains how a body runs down, and it says nothing about what dying is like from the inside or where, if anywhere, the old man went. Pater’s sentence knows this, because it sets Leonardo’s “precise and definite forms” against “the vague land,” and a vague land is precisely the place where a method built on precision has nothing to grip. The last curiosity is the one experiment that comes with no specimens and no notes.

It helps to remember what Pater believed about curiosity himself. The Conclusion to this same book says that “we are all under sentence of death but with a sort of indefinite reprieve,” and urges us to spend the interval burning with “this hard, gem-like flame,” seeing and touching as much as we can. Pater’s Leonardo dies the way that Conclusion tells us to live, leaning forward into one last impression, so the ending is partly a portrait of Leonardo and partly a statement of Pater’s own creed, with the old artist cast as its best example. There’s a twist there, too, since the same Conclusion says that “our failure is to form habits,” while the habit Pater admires in Leonardo, that lifelong discipline of precise looking, is exactly what carries him to the border with his eyes open.

So here’s where I come down on Pater’s famous ending. He does make inquiry into a way of facing death, and Leonardo’s own notes give him real support, since the man who sat with a dying centenarian and then opened him up to understand his sweet death had clearly decided that death was something to look at rather than look away from. But Bacon’s servant stops at the edge of what can be observed, and Pater’s Leonardo steps past it, which is Pater’s faith more than Bacon’s or Leonardo’s. Curiosity can’t take you into the vague land, though it can decide your posture at the border, and that is what Pater’s last sentence describes.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article distinguish the “interpreter” from the “servant” in its account of Leonardo?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.