Philosophy

The Inquiry Did It

Socrates pictures the inquiry as a bully that found two easy marks. The joke lets him say who made the definition and what happened when they put it to the test.

In the closing speech, the inquiry gets a personality and very bad manners. The verbs still tell us who agreed to the premises and put the account of temperance together.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The inquiry gets a partSocrates says the inquiry found him and Critias easy to deal with. He makes it the character that mocks their efforts and exposes the result.
  • The bite in the jokeThe Greek describes the inquiry’s conduct as insolent. Aristotle’s discussion of humiliating people for pleasure helps explain how sharp the personification can sound.
  • Who built the definition?Socrates says that he and Critias agreed to the claims, fashioned the definition together, and laid it down. The inquiry shows them what they made.
  • A way to face embarrassmentEarlier Socrates said Critias was ashamed to admit he was stuck. The closing joke includes both men and gives them a way to look at their shared failure.

Charmides 169c–d, 175b–d · Protagoras 360e–361c · Aristotle, Rhetoric 2.2, insolence

Socrates has just finished listing everything they conceded without warrant, and then he does something unexpected and turns the inquiry into a person. “Still, though it found us so simple-minded and so easy to deal with,” he says, “our inquiry is no more able to find the truth.” Worse, it has behaved outrageously, since “It has made such a mockery of the truth that what we long ago agreed on, and made up between us, and laid down as temperance, it has shown, with the utmost insolence, to be of no benefit.” The investigation, which a moment ago was something the speakers were doing, is now somebody doing things to them, and that somebody has rotten manners.

The word for its manners carries weight. The Greek behind “with the utmost insolence” is an adverb from the family of hybris. Aristotle discusses this kind of insolence in the Rhetoric. He describes the pleasure someone takes in doing or saying something that shames another person. Socrates’ inquiry sounds like the bully who spots a couple of easy marks and has a little sport at their expense. The speakers have already made things easy for it by granting points that their argument hadn’t earned.

Plato uses the trick again in the Protagoras. Socrates says their discussion seems to accuse and mock them like a person. If it could speak, it would point out how far each has travelled from his starting position. Socrates began by doubting that virtue can be taught and ended up pressing the view that it’s knowledge. Protagoras started out on the teaching side and is now resisting the claim that virtue is knowledge. The imagined heckler can say in a few words what took the speakers the whole discussion to do.

The joke shifts agency in a way we recognize. You can say the spreadsheet hates you when your own formula is wrong, or that the test was mean when you didn’t study. It feels good to give something else the starring role for a moment. Socrates gives the inquiry a part too. The question is what he has left in the script for himself and Critias.

Read the sentence slowly and notice who gets which verbs. The inquiry mocks the truth and shows that their temperance would be of no benefit. The speakers are the ones who “agreed on, and made up between us, and laid down” the definition. The middle verb carries an image of fashioning something together. The inquiry can handle it roughly because the two men have already given it a shape.

So making the inquiry a character leaves the speakers’ work in full view. It’s as though you could tell the story of the spreadsheet refusing to cooperate and still show us the formula you entered. The joke points back to the chain of agreements Socrates has just listed. When he says they laid down the definition, he gives his listener someone to ask about the choices that led to it.

It’s worth asking why Socrates tells the story as a joke. A few pages earlier, he says Critias was too ashamed in front of the company to admit he was stuck. Giving the inquiry the worst manners in the room may make the failure easier to face. Socrates includes himself among the easy marks. There’s room for both men to laugh and still hear exactly which part they played.

My verdict is that the insolent inquiry helps us see who did what. The inquiry has the nerve to show the speakers an unwelcome result. The two men supplied it with the definition and the concessions that made the result possible. The joke gives them a little distance from their embarrassment and keeps their hands on what they made.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the main effect of personifying the inquiry, according to the article?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.