Renaissance
The Giant That Had to Fit Its Block
Michelangelo inherited marble another sculptor had already cut into. Finding a figure within it was one problem, and deciding where Florence would see it was another.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater likens carving David to cutting a diamond without loss. The contract and the debate over its placement show how the finished statue changed from a cathedral project into a civic figure.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The marble arrived with limits already setAgostino di Duccio had roughed out the large block for the cathedral works. Michelangelo’s contract records that he inherited a block already shaped badly.
- Pater’s diamond is an image for constraintMichelangelo had to find a figure within the stone available to him. Pater’s comparison draws attention to making full use of that material.
- Florence debated where to show the giantThe committee considered the cathedral, a sheltered loggia and the government palace. Outside the palace, David acquired a civic meaning.
- The original has had more than one settingDavid was moved to the Accademia in 1873. A copy stands outside Palazzo Vecchio, where the original once confronted passersby.
The Renaissance · The Poetry of Michelangelo, p. 57, the diamond and David’s display · The Poetry of Michelangelo, note 143
Pater sets up the David with a jeweler’s image. “A vast fragment of marble had long lain below the Loggia of Orcagna, and many a sculptor had had his thoughts of a design which should just fill this famous block of stone, cutting the diamond, as it were, without loss.” A diamond cutter works out a shape within the rough stone, balancing the design with the material available, and Pater’s point is that the David was that kind of puzzle, a figure that had to be found inside a block whose limits were already set and partly ruined before Michelangelo was even born.
The block had a long, sad history, beginning in 1464, when the cathedral works of Florence contracted the sculptor Agostino di Duccio for a giant prophet to stand high on one of the cathedral’s buttresses, and he began roughing out a block about nine Florentine arm-lengths tall, roughly seventeen feet, before abandoning it. In 1476 Antonio Rossellino was hired to continue and also gave up, and a later record describes the giant lying in the yard. Michelangelo’s 1501 contract places the partly worked block in the cathedral workshop, while Pater puts it under the Loggia.
Michelangelo signed for the job on 16 August 1501, aged twenty-six, and according to the records began carving early in the morning of 13 September. The problem was brutal, since other hands had already cut into the stone, leaving a block that was tall and unusually shallow from front to back, and anything not inside that envelope simply didn’t exist. The block’s shape may help explain the figure’s slim profile. Its turned head and tensed body also give a positive reason for Michelangelo’s choice of the moment before combat.
Vasari, writing later, made the block’s rescue the heart of the miracle, praising Michelangelo for completing the giant without adding a single extra piece and for restoring to life a block that had been given up for dead. That’s Pater’s diamond again, a design that wastes nothing because it can’t afford to, and the most famous statue in the world turns out to be a triumph of making do, which is a strangely comforting thought for anyone who has ever had to cook dinner from whatever was left in the fridge.
Then came the second problem, which had nothing to do with carving. On 25 January 1504, with the statue nearly finished, a committee of about thirty citizens met to decide where it should go, among them Leonardo, Botticelli, Perugino, Filippino Lippi and the architect Giuliano da Sangallo. Botticelli wanted it near the cathedral, others wanted it beside the door of the Palazzo della Signoria, and Sangallo, backed by Leonardo, proposed putting it under the Loggia, sheltered from the weather because the marble was flawed. The city’s herald argued instead for the spot by the palace door where Donatello’s bronze Judith stood, saying it had been set up under an evil star. The Loggia lost, the Judith was moved, the statue was dragged across the city in a hanging wooden frame over several days, and it was unveiled in front of the palace on 8 September 1504.
Shaping the block and exhibiting the statue turned out to be opposite kinds of problem. The block was a fixed set of limits that a single sculptor could solve once and for all with geometry and nerve, while the exhibition was an open question of weather, politics and taste that no one person controlled. The giant designed to be seen far above the streets on a cathedral buttress ended up at eye level on a pedestal by a government door, where the size of its head and right hand became part of a much closer encounter, and its meaning shifted from a prophet for the church to a symbol of the republic.
The display history Pater summarizes has kept shifting ever since. In 1527, during a riot against the Medici, a bench thrown from a window of the palace broke the left arm into three pieces, which were gathered up and later reattached. In 1873 the original was moved to the Accademia. A marble copy took its place outside the palace in 1910. Pater says the statue “stood till lately on the steps of the Palazzo Vecchio, when it was replaced below the Loggia,” which is wrong a second time, since it went to the Accademia, but it’s a revealing mistake, because the Loggia is exactly where Sangallo and Leonardo had wanted it in 1504.
So my verdict is that Pater’s diamond is the best short description anyone has given of the carving problem, while his display history is muddled in a way that tells its own story. Michelangelo solved the block completely, wasting nothing and inventing a pose out of the limits he was handed, but the question of where to show the result has never been solved, and Pater, by putting the statue under the Loggia twice, kept sliding it toward the shelter Florence argued about in 1504 and refused. The shaping was finished in 1504, and the exhibiting is still going on.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author consider Pater’s diamond metaphor especially apt for Michelangelo’s carving problem?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the article’s contrast between carving and exhibiting complicate the idea that a work of art can ever be completely “finished”?→
- To what extent should Michelangelo’s adaptation to the damaged block be understood as a limitation, a source of creativity, or both?→
- Why might moving David from its intended religious setting to a civic setting change how viewers interpret its pose, scale, and meaning?→