Renaissance

The Friendship That Stayed a Possibility

Pater ends Winckelmann’s life by imagining a meeting with Goethe. Goethe’s books show how much the younger man learned from a teacher he never saw.

Pater regrets that the men never met. The relationship that can be traced through books, memory and editing gives that regret a measure.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A meeting left unrealizedPater frames the encounter with Goethe as a possibility and builds his account around the regret that it never occurred.
  • A teacher known indirectlyGoethe learned from Winckelmann’s work and from people such as Oeser, who had taught both men to draw.
  • The work of a later editorIn 1805 Goethe published Winckelmann’s letters to Berendis alongside essays, giving the younger writer a real part in carrying on the older one’s work.
  • What Virgil did for DantePater’s analogy with Dante’s guide makes it easier to see how a writer can shape someone who only knows them through books.

Music fans love the collaboration that never happened, the session two legends almost booked before one of them died, and the fact that nobody can ever hear it is a big part of why people keep talking about it. Pater closes his account of Winckelmann’s life with exactly that kind of what-if. After the medals, the stranger at the inn and the death in Trieste, he steps out of the record and says that it is “not fanciful to regret that his proposed meeting with Goethe never took place,” and from there he builds a friendship out of two temperaments and an encounter that remained a possibility. The interesting question is what that frankly imagined friendship does for the biography, and whether Pater has earned the right to imagine it at all.

The facts he reports on the way there all lean toward the future, which is what makes the ending sting. Winckelmann is carrying gold medals from Vienna, which are honors for work already done, and on his last morning he’s writing “memoranda for the future editor” of his History, so he’s already thinking about the people who’d handle his book after him. Pater adds that he was “still seeking the perfection of his great work,” which means the man dies in the middle of planning for later readers, and the meeting with Goethe belongs to the same pile of unfinished business. Even the child who knocks and gets no answer stands for something interrupted, a companionship that had only just started.

The meeting was already unlikely before the murder. Winckelmann left Vienna “intending to hasten back to Rome,” and the route documented by the Winckelmann Museum takes him toward Italy again. Pater’s word “proposed” suits the kind of regret he expresses. The possibility had existed even though the trip was taking Winckelmann elsewhere.

The loss mattered to Goethe’s account of his education. Pater opens the whole chapter by calling Winckelmann “the teacher who had made his career possible, but whom he had never seen.” That phrase does a lot of work, because it admits that a teacher Pater considers decisive was one he knew only through books, prints and other people’s stories, starting with Oeser, who taught them both to draw. Goethe went to Rome in 1786 and found Winckelmann’s memory “ever active,” and in 1805 he published Winckelmann’s letters to Berendis in a volume of letters and essays. The younger man took a real part in making the older one’s work available to later readers.

Pater’s comparison for what Winckelmann became to Goethe is “something like what Virgil was to Dante,” and it’s sharper than it first looks. Dante never met Virgil either, since the Roman poet had been dead for many centuries, and the great guide of the Comedy is a writer Dante knew only from the page, whom he then imagined into a living companion who walks beside him, scolds him and finally has to leave him at the top of Purgatory. So the comparison already concedes Pater’s deepest point, that the most formative guidance can come through books and memory, and that a meeting staged in the imagination can do some of the work of a real one. Pater’s what-if is a small act of the same kind, a Dantean meeting with the dead dressed up as historical regret.

The friendship Pater imagines rests on a theory of timing. Winckelmann, he says, “had reached that age and that period of culture at which emotions hitherto fitful, sometimes concentrate themselves in a vital, unchangeable relationship,” while Goethe was still young enough to be untouched by the storm and stress that would shake his twenties, and so “German literary history” seemed to lose “the chance of one of those famous friendships, the very tradition of which becomes a stimulus to culture.” I have my doubts about “unchangeable.” The older man and the younger reader might well have had something to say to each other. A lasting friendship would have depended on more than the admiration that makes the scene appealing.

Goethe’s actual life offers a useful check on Pater’s dream at this point. He did get one of those famous friendships, with Schiller, from 1794 until Schiller’s death in May 1805, the same year Goethe brought out his Winckelmann volume, and when their letters were published in 1828 and 1829 they became exactly the kind of tradition Pater describes, a friendship whose record keeps stirring people who never knew either man. That partnership gives us something to compare with Pater’s imagined friendship because readers have an actual record of the work it took to sustain it.

So my verdict is that Pater’s counterfactual is legit, and that it works for reasons he only half states. He marks it plainly as regret and builds it from real dispositions and a prospect that never became a meeting, and its job in the chapter is to measure what actually happened, a relationship carried on entirely through books, memory and editing that turned Winckelmann into Goethe’s Virgil. By leaving the meeting as a possibility, Pater gives the biography an unresolved future, which suits a man who died writing notes for editors he would never meet, and it lets readers keep doing what Goethe did, learning from Winckelmann without any risk of being let down by him in person.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How do the details about Winckelmann’s medals, editorial notes, and unfinished pursuit of perfection shape the article’s interpretation of his death?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.