Renaissance

The Fresco That Lives On as a Crimson Trace

Little remains of Giorgione’s fresco at the Rialto, while intact paintings have been reassigned to other artists. Pater feels the difference between losing an image and losing its name.

A wall at the Fondaco dei Tedeschi and a book by Crowe and Cavalcaselle mark two kinds of loss. The surviving fragment and a story from Vasari show why even a known location cannot settle every question of authorship.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wall by the RialtoGiorgione worked on the Grand Canal side of the rebuilt German merchants’ warehouse, while Titian painted toward the Merceria.
  • A fragment comes off the wallThe damaged figure known as La Nuda was detached in 1937. Much of the fresco program had already disappeared.
  • A different kind of lossCrowe and Cavalcaselle’s history changed the list of paintings attributed to Giorgione without changing the paintings themselves.
  • A name can move againSome attributions continued to shift after Pater, while the qualities he calls Giorgionesque could still be seen in works by several painters.

Stand at the foot of the Rialto Bridge and look at the big square building on the Grand Canal. In 1508 it was brand new, the Fondaco dei Tedeschi, the warehouse and hostel of the German merchants, rebuilt after a fire, a city within the city where traders from Nuremberg and Augsburg slept, stored their goods and did business under Venetian eyes, and its outside walls were covered in frescoes. Giorgione painted the façade on the canal and the young Titian worked on the side toward the Merceria. Pater says this public work “in all probability passed away almost within his own age,” though he gives the surviving “crimson traces” a “strange additional touch of splendour to the scene of the Rialto.” His essay keeps that remnant visible in words.

The physical loss happened slowly, in public, over four centuries. Vasari says he could not make out what Giorgione’s figures meant and had not found anyone who could explain them. In 1760 Anton Maria Zanetti published prints after some of the surviving figures and praised the tinta sanguigna e fiammeggiante, the blood-red, flaming color, of Giorgione’s frescoes, recalling the color Pater finds in the traces. In 1937 restorers detached the fragment known as La Nuda. The figure survives in the Accademia, though its place in the original scheme is difficult to read.

The other loss happened quietly, in libraries and archives. Pater says that around the middle of the sixteenth century “the tradition miscarries,” that it “became fashionable for wealthy lovers of art, with no critical standard of authenticity, to collect so-called works of Giorgione,” and that “a multitude of imitations came into circulation.” Then came what he calls the “new Vasari,” the history of North Italian painting that Joseph Crowe and Giovanni Cavalcaselle published in 1871, a nickname that casts them as the Vasari of the age of archives, which “scrutinised thread by thread” the great reputation until the painter was “reduced almost to a name.” His summary is bitter, that “the accomplished science of the subject” has “not made the past more real for us, but assured us only that we possess less of it than we seemed to possess.”

Put the two losses side by side and they work in opposite directions. Salt air destroys paint but leaves the place, the documents and the memory, so you still know where Giorgione’s wall was and what he painted there, even when you can barely see it. Reassignment destroys no paint at all, since the pictures can still be seen even after they are given a different author, but it removes the name, and with the name the story that tied those pictures together into one painter. It’s the difference between a stadium that got torn down and a song you loved that turns out to have been recorded by a different band.

Pater feels the second loss more sharply, and you can see why. An inheritance is a story about who made what, and when the Louvre picture becomes a follower’s work, you haven’t lost a canvas, you’ve lost a piece of a person. The crimson wall has a strange advantage here, because the place and early accounts help connect surviving fragments to Giorgione, even as much of the design has vanished. The ghost keeps its name while the healthy bodies lose theirs. There’s even an irony in Pater’s phrase “thread by thread,” since it makes scholarship sound like unpicking a tapestry, the exact reverse of the weaving he’d used a few pages earlier for Titian’s color.

Even the wall, though, came with an attribution mix-up from the start. Vasari tells how Giorgione’s friends, admiring a figure on the Merceria side of the building, congratulated him on doing even better work on that side than on the canal, when the figure was actually Titian’s, and how Giorgione was so annoyed that he kept out of sight until Titian finished. If Vasari’s story is right, people were already mistaking one painter for the other as parts of the work came into view, which suggests that a tidy line between Giorgione’s work and his circle’s may never have existed in the first place, even for the people standing under the scaffolding.

There’s also a case that reassignment isn’t pure loss. It gave Titian, Sebastiano and others work that belonged to them, it made the picture of Venice in 1510 more accurate even as it made Giorgione smaller, and later scholars have handed some pictures back, so the catalog turns out to be a moving argument rather than a final verdict. Pater himself doesn’t stay in mourning, since a few pages later he invents a way to keep what the name lost, by talking about the Giorgionesque, a spirit that runs through the school whoever held the brush.

So I’d say physical loss takes away what you can see but leaves you a place to stand, while reassignment leaves everything to see and takes away where you stand. Pater’s crimson trace is the better image of what we really inherit from Giorgione, which is color, a location and a set of figures that even Vasari couldn’t make sense of, and that turns out to be a fair description of the painter scholars have left us too. The red on the Rialto wall is long gone now, but Pater’s sentence about it keeps doing what the stain did, adding a touch of splendor to a scene whose details we can’t recover.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the article’s central distinction between physical deterioration and scholarly reassignment?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.