Renaissance

The Form of a Gesture at the Dinner Table

Pater finds a kind of art in furniture, clothes and small courtesies. Renaissance books of manners help show how much a graceful gesture depends on the people around it.

Passing bread can be both practical and beautiful. Reading Pater alongside Castiglione and Della Casa makes it possible to ask how a gesture’s manner expresses attention to somebody else.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Form in daily lifePater finds artistic qualities in the way people move, speak and dress as well as in paintings and songs.
  • The appeal of easeCastiglione calls for a grace that makes practiced conduct look easy, a quality he calls sprezzatura.
  • One gesture, different audiencesThomas Coryat’s experience with a fork shows that the same habit can read as ordinary courtesy or conspicuous refinement.
  • Grace shared at a tableDella Casa asks the reader to consider the comfort of other people, making their experience part of a gesture’s form.

Pater’s argument about matter and form takes a turn you don’t expect in an essay on Venetian painting. The principle, he says, “holds good of all things that partake in any degree of artistic qualities, of the furniture of our houses, and of dress, for instance, of life itself, of gesture and speech, and the details of daily intercourse.” Picture a dinner table, where someone passes you the bread, and the matter of that gesture is completely fixed, since the bread has to get from one end of the table to the other. Everything else is form, how fast, with which hand, whether the person looks at you, and Pater’s claim is that this leftover part, the manner, can carry real value of its own.

He says these things are, “for the wise,” capable of “a suavity and charm, caught from the way in which they are done, which gives them a worth in themselves.” Suavity comes from the Latin for sweet, and the sweetness Pater means sits entirely in the doing, so two people can perform the identical act and one of them is a pleasure to watch. You know this from any coffee bar, where two baristas make the same drink and one of them moves through it with an ease that makes the line feel shorter. Pater’s point is that this ease is the same thing he’s been chasing in pictures and songs, matter so thoroughly penetrated by its handling that you can’t separate the act from the way it was done.

The period Pater is writing about had already turned this into a subject. Baldassare Castiglione’s Book of the Courtier, published in 1528, made a famous word out of sprezzatura, a kind of studied nonchalance that hides the effort behind graceful behavior, and thirty years later Giovanni della Casa’s Galateo laid out in detail how a gentleman should eat, talk and carry himself, so successfully that its title became the ordinary Italian word for good manners. The Renaissance treated conduct as something you could practice and refine like drawing, and Pater, writing a book about that age, takes the idea seriously instead of treating it as the fussy little sister of the real arts.

Thomas Coryat noticed a difference in table manners while traveling in Italy. In his 1611 account of the trip, he says the fork kept diners’ fingers off the meat that others would eat. He took up the habit and a friend teased him for it back home. A gesture that could keep food clean in one company could look like an affectation in another. Its grace depended in part on who was watching.

Then Pater names the collective version of all this. “Herein, again, lies what is valuable and justly attractive, in what is called the fashion of a time, which elevates the trivialities of speech, and manner, and dress, into ‘ends in themselves,’ and gives them a mysterious grace and attractiveness in the doing of them.” Fashion is the word for a manner that a whole society shares for a while, and the “of a time” part is essential, since the grace partly comes from the fact that it’s dated. Think of the way people held a cigarette or answered a telephone in an old movie, gestures that look elegant now precisely because nobody does them that way anymore.

The trouble is that fashion has another face, and Pater doesn’t look at it. Manners have always worked as a fence as well as a grace, a way of finding out who knows which fork to use and shutting out whoever doesn’t, and any rule about forks can become a test of who already knows the rules. His phrase “for the wise” is doing a lot of work to keep the snobbery out, since it suggests that wisdom, rather than social standing, decides which fashions carry real grace. It’s a fair hope, but the essay doesn’t tell you how a wise person tells charm from exclusion.

Della Casa, of all people, can help him out here. In the Galateo, Della Casa asks how much everyday conduct can please or displease the people one lives among. That concern helps explain his close attention to such things as chewing and talking at table. That suggests a correction to Pater’s “ends in themselves,” because a gesture at the dinner table is never only an end in itself, since it’s always done for someone across the table. The grace he sees is real, but it comes from attention, the visible sign that the person passing the bread is thinking about you while they do it.

So my verdict is that Pater is right that the form of a daily act can give it worth, and right that a period can share a style of doing things that has its own fading charm, which is what he means by the fashion of a time. Where he goes too far is in cutting the manner loose from the people it’s for, because the gestures that feel most graceful are the ones where the handling has absorbed someone else’s needs, the way a good host’s movements seem to anticipate you. That’s still his principle of form soaking into matter, only with the other diner counted as part of the matter.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

In the bread-passing example, what does the article identify as the gesture’s “form”?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.