Renaissance
The Faces He Followed Until Sundown
Vasari has Leonardo following strangers through Florence. The artist’s own notes show what memory could do with the faces he brought home.
The Renaissance (1893)Leonardo’s advice on faces and stained walls complicates Pater’s choice between natural grotesques, deliberate exaggeration and mockery.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A face in the streetVasari says Leonardo could follow someone with an unusual face all day and draw that person from memory.
- A face in a stainLeonardo tells painters to look for forms in marked walls and develop what they see into finished designs.
- A face built from partsHis notes also teach painters to remember unfamiliar faces by recognizing and recombining familiar features.
- The Dante problemThe Royal Collection describes its grotesque Dante as a copy after Leonardo, which makes the drawing uncertain evidence for Leonardo’s own attitude.
The Renaissance · Pater on the faces Leonardo followed · Pater on Dante and nature’s grotesques · Vasari’s account of following unfamiliar faces · Leonardo’s Treatise on Painting · Four Grotesque Heads Including a Caricature of Dante, Royal Collection · Leonardo’s palm-reading drawing, Royal Collection
Pater gives us one of the great images of the artist as a stalker, a polite one, a young man who catches something in “the strange eyes or hair of chance people” and follows them “about the streets of Florence till the sun went down.” Vasari told the story first, saying Leonardo loved bizarre heads with wild beards or hair and would follow one that pleased him “a whole day,” then go home and draw the man as if he were sitting in front of him. Think of a street photographer without a camera, trailing a great face for hours because memory is the only way to keep it, and remember that everything in those drawings had to survive the walk home.
Pater makes three quick moves, and each points toward a different answer. Some of the sketches, he says, are “full of a curious beauty,” the kind you only reach by refining on the accepted types of beauty, but there’s “an element of mockery also,” so that “whether in sorrow or scorn, he caricatures Dante even.” Then come the “legions of grotesques” sweeping under his hand, followed by a rhetorical question about whether nature hasn’t grotesques of her own, with examples that are hard to forget, “the rent rock, the distorting lights of evening on lonely roads, the unveiled structure of man in the embryo, or the skeleton.” So the grotesque could be an intensified way of seeing, a form of ridicule, or something the world itself offers, and Leonardo’s own papers give real support to more than one of these.
The case for finding starts with a precept Leonardo was a little embarrassed to give. He calls it “a new device for study” which “may seem but trivial and almost ludicrous,” and it amounts to staring at a wall spotted with stains or a jumble of mixed stones until you see landscapes and battles in it, along with “strange faces and costumes,” which you can then “reduce to complete and well drawn forms.” That’s Pater’s rent rock in practice, the world offering a blot and the painter seeing a face in it. The rest of Pater’s list reads like a tour of Leonardo’s own desk, since he dissected corpses, drew the skeleton from several sides and, around 1511, drew a fetus curled inside the opened womb, so on this view nature hands over its oddities and the artist mainly has to notice them.
The case for making is just as strong, and it also comes from Leonardo. In a note on keeping a face in mind, he tells the painter to learn the parts first, since noses come in ten types in profile and eleven seen from the front, and to carry a little book of such features, so that after one glance at a stranger you can privately mark which nose or mouth comes closest and rebuild the face at home. Then he adds, almost with a shrug, “Of grotesque faces I need say nothing, because they are kept in mind without difficulty.” The method offers one way to read the grotesque heads, as stock features pushed further, a chin too long here and a nose too short there. The Royal Collection dates many of these drawings to around 1490, when Leonardo was also studying ideal proportions.
Mockery deserves its hearing too, because a few sheets really do sneer. A drawing at Windsor from around 1493 crowds five grotesque heads into a scene of a man having his palm read by an old woman while another figure goes for his purse, and the Royal Collection suggests it could satirize current affairs at the Sforza court, in the context of restrictions against Roma. Pater’s Dante is another matter, though, since the red chalk sheet at Windsor that shows the poet with what the Royal Collection calls “a deformed, imbecilic grin” is now catalogued as a copy after Leonardo made around 1517 to 1520, probably by his pupil Melzi, and Wenceslaus Hollar’s etchings of the 1640s spread heads like it across Europe as comic prints. The Milanese painter Lomazzo, who knew Melzi, tells how Leonardo once invited some peasants to dinner, told them stories until they were helpless with laughter and then drew them from memory, which is laughter shared at a table rather than scorn.
The other side deserves its due, because the finding theory can be too kind. Nobody walking around Florence ever had some of the noses on those sheets, and the heads often look more like a cartoonist’s exaggeration than a naturalist’s record. Pater’s own list cheats a little as well, because Leonardo drew the embryo and skeleton with a care that suggests the anatomical subjects interested him in their own right, and calling them nature’s grotesques sneaks Victorian gothic into what was for him a laboratory. And the mockery reading, for all that it leans on copies and prints, still has the palm-reading sheet behind it, where a satirical reading has a stronger footing.
Leonardo’s two notes bring the possibilities closer together, because they describe related acts of selection and reconstruction. The stained wall and the catalogue of noses both picture an eye that takes a hint from the world and a mind that reduces it, in his word, to form with a stock of parts it already owns, and the grotesques are where that method shows most clearly, since, as he says, they stick in the memory without effort. The eye grabs the deformity first, and then the hand, working from the catalogue, pushes it further than any one face pushed it. Read beside those notes, following a stranger till sundown looks like an exercise in memory as much as a search for comic or beautiful faces.
My verdict is that the grotesques were found and then built, with the finding and the building happening in nearly the same glance. Scorn is real but a minority note, and Pater’s best proof of it, the Dante, rests on a copy that may say more about Leonardo’s followers and the seventeenth-century print trade than about Leonardo himself. If you have to choose among Pater’s three answers, choose nature’s grotesques, but read them the way Leonardo did, as hints that a trained memory completes, because the rent rock and the stained wall don’t draw anything until somebody arrives with ten kinds of nose already filed away.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article ultimately connect Leonardo’s stained-wall exercise with his catalogue of facial features?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Leonardo both discovered unusual forms in the world and intensified them through learned conventions, where should we locate artistic originality: in perception, memory, transformation, or some combination of the three?→
- How should the uncertain authorship and later reproduction of the Dante image affect the weight we give it when interpreting Leonardo’s attitude toward grotesque faces?→
- When does close observation of an unusual face become ridicule, and what kinds of evidence would help distinguish curiosity, shared amusement, satire, and scorn?→