Greek Antiquity
The Education the Muses Give the Soul
The Muses nurse the soul and guide the mind in a hymn that gives education the care of an upbringing.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThe Orphic hymn describes the Muses as teachers before it names them one by one. Its word for nurse also describes Leukothea’s care for the infant Dionysos.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A sequence of teachingThe hymn moves from the excellence of education to nursing the soul, straightening understanding, and guiding the mind.
- A word from the nurseryThe same Greek word names Leukothea as Dionysos’s nurse and the Muses as nurses of the soul.
- Learning over timeThe feature uses the nursing image to explain why the hymn treats intellectual growth as slow and dependent on care.
- A place for the artsThe Muses’ individual names come later, after the work of forming a mind has been set out.
Orphic Hymns, LXXVI.1–7, with the notes on LXXVI.4–6 and LXXVI.5, 2; LXXVII.3–8
You expect a hymn to the Muses to be about poetry, and the Orphic one surprises you at once. After their parentage and their fame, it calls them “begetting the blameless excellence of all education, / nurses of the soul, straight-givers of the understanding, / and queens, guides of the greatly able mind.” The edition’s note says bluntly that “the vocabulary is a schoolmaster’s, not a poet’s,” and points out that the arts the Muses are named after “appear only as their names in lines 8–10.” These are Muses who run a school before they inspire a poem.
The words of education come in a careful order. The Muses beget the excellence of education as a whole, then nurse the soul, then straighten the understanding, then guide the mind, so the list moves from the general good to the particular faculties, as a curriculum moves from its purpose to its subjects. The word for guides has had a long life, since in modern Greek a university professor is still called by the same title, a guide in the old sense. The hymn has given the daughters of Zeus the job descriptions of a faculty, and the great research institution of Ptolemaic Alexandria was named the Mouseion, the shrine of the Muses, a building for scholars and not for poets alone, from which every museum since takes its name.
The image at the center is nursing, and the note on that line observes that the same word for nurse stands two hymns back, where Leukothea is the nurse of the infant Dionysos, and that “the same agent-noun serves once for a goddess who raised a god and once for goddesses who raise a faculty.” The note adds that the collection habitually takes “a physical office” and applies it “to the inner life,” and nursing is the clearest case. To call the Muses nurses of the soul is to say that learning is fed to a person slowly, daily and dependently, the way a child is fed, and not poured in all at once.
Plato thought about education in just these terms, since in the Republic Socrates argues that the young should be raised among beautiful things as animals graze in a healthy pasture, taking in good influences without noticing, and that education in music matters most because rhythm and harmony sink deepest into the soul. The Greek word for that education is mousikē, the art of the Muses, which covered poetry, music and the whole training of the mind, so when Plato speaks of nourishing the soul with it, he is describing the Muses’ work as this hymn describes it, a long feeding of the learner rather than a sudden gift to the genius.
The hymn to Mnemosyne, which follows, carries the same picture into the mind’s workings. Their mother is “holding together the whole mind that dwells with the souls of mortals, / increasing the strong and greatly able reasoning of mortals,” and she is “putting all things in mind, / whatever each man lays up always as purpose in his breast.” Increasing and holding together are words of growth and keeping, the work of a mother who tends what has been planted, and Plato makes Memory the ground of learning too, comparing the mind to a block of wax that receives impressions and calling it a gift of Mnemosyne, the mother of the Muses. The same hymn calls her lover of wakefulness, an epithet that suits a mother who keeps watch over what she is raising.
This concentration on the learner changes the familiar picture of the Muses. The tradition we know best is the one of inspiration, in which the Muse seizes a poet and speaks through him, and Plato’s Ion describes the poet as a light and winged thing, out of his senses while the god speaks. That picture is about the gifted few and the sudden visit. The hymn’s Muses instead attend to everyone who learns, and their work is gradual, so that the soul grows under their care as a child grows under a nurse’s, and the poet’s flash of genius becomes one possible fruit of a long upbringing.
The New Testament uses the same imagery of feeding for growth in understanding. Peter tells his readers, as newborn babes, to desire the sincere milk of the word, that they may grow thereby, and Paul tells the Corinthians that he fed them with milk and not with meat, because they were not yet able to bear it. Both treat teaching as nourishment matched to the learner’s strength, and Proverbs gives the parent the same patient task, telling him to train up a child in the way he should go, so that when he is old he will not depart from it, and Paul reminds Timothy that he has known the holy scriptures from a child, taught by his grandmother Lois and his mother Eunice.
My verdict is that the nursing image turns intellectual formation into care, and that this is the hymn’s real contribution to the picture of the Muses. By calling them nurses of the soul and guides of the mind, the hymn makes them patrons of the learner as well as of the artist, powers who raise a mind over years rather than strike it in a moment. The arts they are named after still stand at the end of the hymn, but the hymn suggests that they are the fruit of an education the Muses have nursed from the start, and that the blameless excellence of learning is their first and greatest gift.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article emphasize the order in which the hymn describes the Muses’ educational roles?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If learning is understood as nourishment rather than information transfer, how might that change what teachers and learners owe one another?→
- Does the article’s contrast between gradual education and sudden inspiration require us to choose between them, or can each depend on the other?→
- What assumptions about human development are implied by calling the Muses both “nurses” and “guides” of the mind?→