Renaissance

The Dreams That Came with a Budget

Pater calls Leonardo’s plans to bore mountains and turn rivers dreams. A Florentine wartime excavation shows how far some of those ambitions moved beyond paper.

An audacious scheme to lift a baptistery and two separate projects for the Arno put Pater’s “love of the impossible” in the world of working engineers.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A persuasive modelVasari says Leonardo convinced Florentine officials that their baptistery could be raised to put steps underneath it.
  • Pater’s two historiesPater considers natural magic and modern mechanics, then calls the young Leonardo’s audacious schemes dreams.
  • A trade with precedentsIn Bologna, Aristotele Fioravanti had already moved a masonry tower using mechanical means.
  • Two plans for the ArnoLeonardo drew a proposed navigation canal, while a separate attempt to divert the river away from Pisa went as far as excavation in 1504.

At some point in his Florentine years, if Vasari has it right, Leonardo stood in front of the men who ran the city with a model and a plan to lift the Baptistery of San Giovanni, Saint John’s, one of the city’s most venerable buildings, and slide a flight of steps underneath it without cracking a stone. Vasari says he argued it so well that it seemed doable while he was talking, and that each of those citizens, once he’d gone home, could see for himself “the impossibility of so vast an undertaking,” which is the startup pitch that dazzles in the conference room and falls apart in the parking lot. That little scene is where Pater’s most memorable phrase about the young Leonardo comes from.

Pater turns the scene into a whole temperament in the paragraph where Leonardo first plunges into the study of nature, saying that the young man “was smitten with a love of the impossible,” and listing the symptoms as “the perforation of mountains, changing the course of rivers, raising great buildings, such as the church of San Giovanni, in the air.” Those are, he adds, “all those feats for the performance of which natural magic professed to have the key.” Then he heads off an objection, writing that “later writers, indeed, see in these efforts an anticipation of modern mechanics; in him they were rather dreams, thrown off by the overwrought and labouring brain.” So he offers two histories for the same feat, one old and magical and one new and mechanical, and then declines both and calls it a dream.

In the Florence of Ficino and Pico, natural magic promised a magus who understood the hidden sympathies that tie stars, stones, plants and bodies together, the same “correspondences which exist between the different orders of living things” that Pater has Leonardo brooding over a few lines earlier, and who could work wonders by pulling on those threads. On that reading, a pierced mountain would prove secret knowledge. The funny part is that the tradition already had its own debunker, since in the thirteenth century the friar Roger Bacon wrote a letter on the secret works of art and nature and the nullity of magic, which promised ships that move without rowers and a small instrument for lifting and lowering great weights, and insisted that none of it needed spirits at all.

Leonardo himself sat squarely on Bacon’s side of that line. In one of his notebooks he calls belief in necromancy, which he describes as “the sister of Alchemy,” the most foolish of all human opinions, and he gives alchemy its due only because it works with real materials the way human hands do, the hands that “have produced, for instance, glass.” In another note he turns on the inventors of perpetual-motion machines and tells them to “go and be the companions of the searchers for gold.” A man who writes like that is policing the border of the possible, and by his own standard a building raised on screws and levers falls safely inside it.

And something very like it had already been done. In 1455, when Leonardo was three, the Bolognese engineer Aristotele Fioravanti used machinery and rollers to move the brick bell tower of the Magione more than forty feet along Strada Maggiore in front of a crowd, a feat the city still marks with a plaque, and Fioravanti, who later built the Cathedral of the Dormition in the Kremlin for Ivan III, was no wizard, just the most famous building mover of his century. When Vasari says Leonardo kept making models to show “how to remove mountains with ease, and how to bore them,” and how to raise great weights with levers, windlasses and screws, he’s describing the toolbox of men like Fioravanti, which puts the San Giovanni scheme at the bold far end of an ordinary trade.

Rivers make the point even more plainly, since the river schemes left behind maps, letters and a hole in the ground. Vasari credits Leonardo with being the first, while still young, to talk about canalizing the Arno between Pisa and Florence, and a drawing at Windsor from around 1503 traces a navigable route that swings north from Florence through Prato and Pistoia and then cuts deep through the mountain pass at Serravalle, a perforated mountain on paper. A separate wartime project aimed to turn the Arno away from Pisa. Leonardo surveyed the river, and Machiavelli backed the undertaking in Florence. Work began in August 1504 under the hydraulic engineer Colombino, but the diversion failed and was abandoned that autumn.

Now you can see what the same act means in each of Pater’s two histories. As natural magic, turning a river would be a display of occult mastery, and as modern mechanics it would be an early sketch of what steam and dynamite would someday do. In 1504 it was neither of those things, because it was public works and it was war, an item in the budget of a republic that wanted Pisa back, with hired crews on the riverbank and Machiavelli writing anxious letters to the site. Pater’s third option fits worst of all, because dreams don’t get construction crews, and the word hides the most interesting thing about the Arno project, which is how drawings, surveys and a wartime budget put the possibility of changing the map of Tuscany within reach.

Still, I don’t want to throw out the phrase along with the theory, because “love of the impossible” catches something the documents confirm. Vasari’s citizens felt the impossibility only after Leonardo left the room, and the Arno works failed when the channels could not do what the planners needed, so the pattern is a mind that kept asking for more than its century could deliver while knowing exactly which tools the job would take. Pater also notices, in the same paragraph, that “the motion of great waters” stayed with Leonardo all his life, and the late deluge drawings, where water tears down mountains with no engineer in sight, are where those ambitions finally turned into visions. My verdict is that Pater should keep the love of the impossible and drop both the natural magic and the dreams, because the feats belonged to a working engineer who overreached, and that’s a more interesting kind of impossible than sorcery.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author argue that calling the Arno diversion a “dream” is misleading?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.